BENERU
Published Column

A good agent cannot be defined

When asked how to tell a good agent, what I want to check first is "good for whom." In place of a "good" that cannot be defined, we think about the order of deciding first the conditions you want to avoid and your own conditions.

Nel Shikina with a folder on her lap, listening to what the other person is saying

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

Good day.

There is something I am often asked by people who have started looking for real estate.

They want me to tell them how to tell a good agent.

I understand how they feel. I understand, but before I answer, let me check just one thing.

That "good": good for whom?


Did that sound mean-spirited? But if you skip this, the conversation does not move forward.

For example, suppose there is someone considering an income property for the first time who is simply anxious. For this person, a good agent is a company that will explain as many times as needed and patiently go along with their questions, even if the fees are somewhat higher. They are paying money to reduce their anxiety, so that makes sense.

On the other hand, what about a full-time landlord who can choose properties on their own? They need neither explanations nor proposals. It is enough if the necessary documents are handled accurately and quickly. The moment unnecessary contact comes, that company becomes a bad agent.

The same company becomes the best for one person and the worst for another.

Yes. After all, it is not the company that changed. What changed is the person doing the measuring.

So a "good agent" cannot be defined as a word.

But the other side gives a little more of an outline.


The conditions you want to avoid are probably easier to define

Selling while silently knowing it will harm the customer. Falsifying numbers. Talking about demand that cannot be confirmed. Showing only success stories and not touching on failures.

These are not a matter of who they are good for. There is contrivance in the acts themselves. So the reasons to avoid them are easy to explain.

There are also a few clues for telling them apart.

First, check what that company makes its money from. If its structure earns profit by selling, its proposals are built on the premise of the selling side's profit. This is not malice but a question of incentives. You look not at whether someone is a bad person, but at what kind of structure they are in.

Next, whether there is an explanation of the risks. Vacancy, rising interest rates, repairs, liquidity at the time of sale. An income property has both advantages and disadvantages, so if only one side comes up, the explanation is insufficient.

Then, try asking where the numbers come from. If you are told the yield is 8%, is that gross or net, what percentage vacancy rate is it based on, and what is included in the various expenses? If they cannot answer, or they leave it vague, that number cannot be used for your decision.

Finally, the reaction when you decline. If their attitude changes just because you declined, that is probably enough to go on.


Here, let me also think from the opposite side

Even so, you might say this.

That you do not have the time to look that carefully.

That is fair. In a first transaction, few people can check as far as the other party's revenue structure. In the first place, it is because they do not know what to ask that it becomes a request to be told about a good agent.

So I reverse the order.

Instead of trying to size up the other party, decide your own conditions first.

What are you looking for? How much support do you need? Which risks can you accept? Would you rather pay in fees or in effort?

If these are decided, there is no need to evaluate the other party. It is enough to check whether they fit your conditions.

Conversely, if you say you are "looking for a good agent" while these are not decided, you have no basis for judgment, so you end up thinking along the basis the person in front of you has presented.

And that basis is usually one that is convenient for them.

It is hard to say, but as long as BENERU too aims to be a company that handles income real estate, it cannot look at this structure as someone else's problem. In general, it is probably also true that when customers' own criteria are vague, it is easier for the selling side to move the conversation forward with its proposals. The reason I still write this is that properties bought without criteria lead to disputes a few years later. If what you were aiming for when you bought has not been decided, you cannot even examine what turned out different and how. At that point, we are in trouble too.


When the long autumn rains continue, the weather forecast announces, "Tomorrow will be good weather."

But good weather for a farmer about to harvest rice and good weather for someone who does not want to carry an umbrella on the weekend are not the same. The sky is not clearing for anyone in particular, yet the words decide "good" for you ahead of time.

Convenient, isn't it? Because it is convenient, you tend to stop thinking for yourself.

Whether something is good lies not on the side of the sky but on the side of the person looking. The same is probably true of agents, and of properties.

What to think about next