BENERU
BENERU Q&A

Questions without a single right answer, answered by people with different viewpoints.

Find ↓

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.

  • Corporate goods prices rose 7% from a year earlier. Should I also raise the repair cost estimate for the property I own by 7%?

    This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Multiplying the repair cost estimate directly by the 7.1% year-on-year rise in corporate goods prices is n…Read moreClose

    This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Multiplying the repair cost estimate directly by the 7.1% year-on-year rise in corporate goods prices is not appropriate. The Corporate Goods Price Index is an average of the prices of "goods" traded between companies; it does not measure the price of repair work itself. It is more accurate to review the repair cost estimate work item by work item, separating materials from labor.

    What the 7.1% measures

    The October Domestic Corporate Goods Price Index (preliminary), released by the Bank of Japan on November 12, 2026, rose 7.1% from a year earlier and 0.7% from the previous month. It is an average of the prices of 515 items of goods traded between companies, weighted by transaction value, and services are not covered. It does not include contract prices for construction work or the wages of tradespeople.

    What lies inside the same 7.1% differs greatly by field.

    GroupYear-on-yearItems involved in repairs (examples)
    Nonferrous metalsUp 31.7%Copper pipes, electric wires and cables
    Chemicals and related productsUp 15.5%Paints, synthetic resins
    Plastic productsUp 14.1%Resin pipes and fittings
    Lumber and wood productsUp 9.0%Plywood, sawn lumber
    Metal productsUp 6.5%Aluminum sashes, locks and building hardware
    Iron and steelUp 6.3%Steel materials such as galvanized steel sheets
    Ceramic, stone and clay productsUp 5.3%Cement, ready-mixed concrete, tiles
    General purpose machineryUp 3.2%Pumps, commercial air conditioners

    In the same month, import prices rose 24.8% from a year earlier on a yen basis and 19.2% on a contract currency basis. This shows that it is not only the weak yen; the prices of the goods themselves bought overseas are rising.

    Repair costs are not decided by "materials" alone

    The price of repair work is decided by the cost of materials plus the labor of tradespeople, scaffolding and transport, and the general contractor's overhead. What the Corporate Goods Price Index directly reflects is only the materials and equipment part of this. As a measure closer to the work itself, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's "construction cost deflator" has a "building repair" series covering renovations and repairs that improve a building's function or useful life. Monthly values are released with a lag of about 2 months, and the statistical table dated November 13, 2026 (Reiwa 8) includes figures up to August 2026 (Reiwa 8).

    How to review the estimate

    1. Divide the planned work into items such as piping, exterior walls and roof, equipment, and interior finishes.
    2. For each work item, check the rough proportions of materials and labor on the quote. Work with a lot of copper piping or electric wiring tends to show a large rise in material costs, as in the table above.
    3. When using a past quote, check its date, restate it using the growth in the construction cost deflator (building repair), and then compare it with a new quote.

    From here on, this is my opinion

    If you apply one rate to all the work, it can happen that the estimate falls short for work with a lot of piping or electrical equipment and is too high for work that is mostly interior finishes. I think it is better to restate the estimate according to what each piece of work consists of.

    Sources (in Japanese): 日本銀行「企業物価指数(2026年10月速報)」/日本銀行「企業物価指数(2020年基準)の解説」/国土交通省「建設工事費デフレーター」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Management and operation 2 other answers
  • If the Bank of Japan's "Summary of Opinions" lines up voices calling for a rate hike, does that mean a hike at the next meeting?

    This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Even if opinions calling for a rate hike line up in the Bank of Japan's "Summary of Opinions at the Moneta…Read moreClose

    This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first.

    Even if opinions calling for a rate hike line up in the Bank of Japan's "Summary of Opinions at the Monetary Policy Meeting" (Omo na Iken; hereafter, the Summary of Opinions), that does not mean a rate hike at the next meeting. The Summary of Opinions is not a document recording the meeting's decision; it is a document in which the Policy Board members and the government attendees summarize their own remarks, and the chair edits them by topic. Neither the speakers' names nor the numbers for and against are written in it. The policy rate is decided by a vote at the meeting and is released as a statement on the final day of the meeting.

    What is decided, and how

    • The guideline for money market operations is decided by a vote of the Policy Board (Bank of Japan Act (Nihon Ginkō Hō), Article 15, paragraph 1, item 4).
    • The Policy Board has 9 members: 6 appointed members (shingi iin), plus the Governor and the 2 Deputy Governors (Article 16 of the same Act). Proceedings are decided by a majority of the members present, and in the event of a tie the chair decides (Article 18, paragraph 2 of the same Act).
    • The Minister of Finance and the Minister of State for Economic and Fiscal Policy (or officials they designate) may attend meetings and state their opinions, and may submit proposals or request that a vote be postponed (Article 19 of the same Act). They are not members.
    • How the Summary of Opinions is made is written in the document's note. The opinions each Policy Board member and government attendee expressed at the meeting are summarized by the speakers themselves within a certain number of characters and submitted to the Governor, who is the chair, and the chair edits them by topic on the chair's own responsibility.

    What to compare

    DocumentWhat is written in itRelease date for the October 29-30, 2026 meeting
    Statement on Monetary Policy (the statement)The content of the decision, the numbers for and against, the members who dissented, and their proposalsOctober 30, 2026
    Summary of OpinionsOpinions summarized by the members and government attendees, edited by the chair by topic. No speakers' namesNovember 10, 2026
    MinutesAn outline of the proceedings. Released after approval by the Board at a Monetary Policy Meeting (Article 20, paragraph 1 of the same Act; in practice, approved at a later meeting)December 23, 2026 (scheduled)
    TranscriptsThe record of the meeting's proceedingsAfter 10 years have passed since the meeting, released twice a year, half a year's worth at a time

    The document for confirming the decision is the statement. The Summary of Opinions is a document for learning what opinions came up on the way to the decision.

    Where the answer splits

    Let us set the two documents side by side for the October 29-30, 2026 meeting.

    In the "Opinions on Monetary Policy" section of the Summary of Opinions, there are opinions that "the next rate hike should be carried out when it can be, without being overly cautious" and that "it is necessary to bring the policy rate to the neutral level early." In the same section there is also an opinion that "at this meeting, it is appropriate to keep the policy rate unchanged." In the "Opinions on Economic Activity and Prices" section, there is an opinion that it is also necessary to pay attention to the risk that past rate hikes will push economic activity and prices downward with a lag.

    In the statement, a proposal to encourage the uncollateralized overnight call rate to remain at around 1.25% was decided by a vote of 8 for and 1 against. The 1 dissenting member proposed raising it to around 1.5%, and that proposal was defeated by a majority vote against.

    Even though several opinions in favor of a rate hike were listed, only 1 member proposed a rate hike at that meeting. Moreover, "without being overly cautious" is an opinion about the next rate hike and does not indicate timing. One line in the Summary of Opinions does not correspond to one member's one vote. This is a point that is easily overlooked.

    Conditions behind the numbers

    • This is based on the statement (October 30, 2026), the Summary of Opinions (released November 10, 2026), and the schedule of Monetary Policy Meetings, as published by the Bank of Japan as of November 13, 2026.
    • The next meeting is December 17-18, 2026, and the Summary of Opinions for that meeting is scheduled for release on December 28 (schedule). The schedule may change.
    • The document does not state a number for the upper limit on the characters in each summary in the Summary of Opinions.
    • The timing of the release of transcripts follows the Bank of Japan's "Guidelines on the Release of Transcripts and Other Records of Monetary Policy Meetings." The law (Article 20, paragraph 2 of the same Act) only provides "after a reasonable period has passed."

    Order of checks

    1. In the statement released on the final day of the meeting, check the content of the decision, the numbers for and against, and the proposals of members who dissented.
    2. When reading the Summary of Opinions, read it separating which section the opinion is in (economic activity and prices, monetary policy, the government) and whether it is about "this time," "next time," or "conditional."
    3. Check the date of the next meeting on the Bank of Japan's schedule.
    4. In your own loan contract, check the review date for the base rate and the rules for when the applied rate and the repayment amount change.
    5. Calculate in advance, with your own balance and remaining term, the repayment amount if the applied rate rises by 0.25 percentage points or 0.5 percentage points.

    From here on, this is my opinion

    The Summary of Opinions is useful as material for learning which issues are being discussed within the Policy Board. On the other hand, given how it is made, I think it is not suited as material for predicting the outcome of the next meeting.

    Nothing in this document gives a reason to hurry refinancing, or the choice between fixed and variable, on a prediction of the next meeting's outcome. I think that first calculating the repayment amount if rates rise, and deciding on whether you can bear it, makes the impact smaller when the prediction turns out wrong.

    Sources (in Japanese): 日本銀行「金融政策決定会合における主な意見(2026年10月29、30日開催分)」/日本銀行「当面の金融政策運営について(2026年10月30日)」/日本銀行「金融政策決定会合の運営(会合日程・公表予定)」/日本銀行「金融政策決定会合議事録等公表要領」/e-Gov法令検索(デジタル庁)「日本銀行法」

    The page for this question (1 other answer) →

    Financing and interest rates 1 other answer
  • Corporate goods prices rose 7% from a year earlier. Should I also raise the repair cost estimate for the property I own by 7%?

    Hey, it's Jamie! When I hear "repair cost estimate," I remember the error beep of a water heater. Beep-beep, beep-beep. That sound on a winter morning! At a use…Read moreClose

    Hey, it's Jamie! When I hear "repair cost estimate," I remember the error beep of a water heater. Beep-beep, beep-beep. That sound on a winter morning!

    At a used condominium unit I own, I got a message from the tenant: "There's no hot water." The building is a little over 20 years old. The water heater there is an electric water heater, it had been replaced once under the previous owner, and the quote from that time was among the documents I took over. I looked at it, thought "if I replace it, it'll be this price," and copied it straight into the repairs column of my notebook. I didn't look at the date. I was completely convinced that as long as I had the amount written down, I was perfectly prepared!

    But the quote from the contractor who came out was about 30% higher than that old quote. Without thinking, I showed them the old one and said, "Last time it was this price." The contractor pointed at the date and asked, "How many years ago is this from?" The date on the quote was long before I bought the unit. Both the price of the equipment and the cost of the labor had gone up in the meantime.

    On top of that, when a water heater breaks, it can't wait. In a unit with no hot water in winter, you can't tell the tenant, "Please wait 1 week so I can get competing quotes." I asked for the work that same day. The moment something breaks, the time to compare whether it's expensive or cheap disappears.

    Later I read the Bank of Japan's corporate goods price release. In October 2026, domestic corporate goods prices were up 7.1% from a year earlier. So what about my electric water heater? I looked, and "electric water heaters and water heating appliances" fall under a group called electrical machinery and equipment, which was up 6.7% from a year earlier. Great, this solves the mystery of the 30%! I thought, but it doesn't. That's one year's rise, and it's only about equipment shipment prices. My old quote was from years ago, and the bill also included the labor for installation and disposal of the old unit. No matter how long you stare at one year's rate, it won't check the answer on a quote that sat around for years!

    There are three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

    • With a quote you took over, look at the date before the amount
    • For equipment like water heaters that can't wait once they break, get a quote at today's price once before they break
    • "Last time it was this price" isn't a phrase that lowers the price. It's a phrase that confesses your preparation was out of date

    By the way, since that winter, in the repairs column of my notebook I write "as of when" along with the amount. Thanks to that, my notebook is starting to look like a timeline. Maybe the one who knows the history of prices best is my notebook!

    Sources (in Japanese): 日本銀行「企業物価指数(2026年10月速報)」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Management and operation 2 other answers
  • If the Bank of Japan's "Summary of Opinions" lines up voices calling for a rate hike, does that mean a hike at the next meeting?

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Lines up"? That document isn't the line outside some popular restaurant, you know? No, I get what you mean. If there are a bunch of sente…Read moreClose

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Lines up"? That document isn't the line outside some popular restaurant, you know?

    No, I get what you mean. If there are a bunch of sentences saying "raise rates," of course you want to read it as "next time it goes up." But look, answer first. The number of lines isn't the number of votes. What gets decided at the next meeting can't be read from this document.

    So, here's the main point. How this "Summary of Opinions" is made is written in the note. The members and the people attending from the government summarize their own remarks themselves within a certain number of characters and hand them to the chair, the Governor. The chair edits them by topic on the chair's own responsibility. No names attached. Folks like me read documents by cutting them into words and lines, so with a document like this, the first thing that catches me is that "whose line is this?" isn't written. Can you count something as a number of people when you can't tell who wrote how many lines? No way, right?

    Let's actually check. In the "Summary of Opinions" for the October 29-30, 2026 meeting (released November 10), eager lines like "the next rate hike should be carried out when it can be, without being overly cautious" and "it is necessary to bring the policy rate to the neutral level early" are right there. In the same section, "at this meeting, it is appropriate to keep the policy rate unchanged" is there too. And if you look at the statement released on the final day of the meeting, the vote was 8 for, 1 against. The one who put forward a hike to around 1.5% was 1 member, and it was defeated by a majority against. Get it? No matter how many eager lines you see, the number who raised a hand for a hike right there was 1.

    What's more, "without being overly cautious" is about "the next rate hike," and it doesn't say when. "This time," "next time," and "conditional" are mixed on the same sheet of paper. Read it without telling them apart, and you get a sloppy, full-of-holes prediction.

    Well, of course, I'm not saying it isn't worth reading. To know what issues are coming up in the Board, which way the wind is blowing, it's a good source. But which way the wind is blowing and the result of the next single meeting are different things. OK?

    So, here's the thing. One more blind spot. The question of trying to call "will it go up next time" is itself a bit off. Whether you call it right or wrong, what hits you as the borrower is "how much more per month if it goes up," isn't it?

    Let me calculate on assumptions. A balance of ¥30 million, 25 years remaining, equal principal-and-interest payments, a current applied rate of 1.5%. If it rises 0.25 percentage points, the monthly repayment goes from about ¥119,980 to about ¥123,540, an increase of about ¥3,600 a month. At 0.5 percentage points, it's about ¥127,160, an increase of about ¥7,200 a month. When the repayment changes depends on the rules in your contract, but whether your household budget and rental income can bear that increase is something you can check yourself before the next meeting. Predictions can miss, but this calculation you can do now with your own numbers. Don't you think?

    So there's no need to rush a decision on refinancing, or on fixed versus variable, by looking at the number of lines in the "Summary of Opinions." If you're going to decide, do it after you've lined up your contract's review date and the repayment if rates rise.

    It's the season for winter yellowtail. At the port, no matter how many rumors line up saying "they're fatty this year," the only thing that sets that day's price is the one morning auction. Listening to rumors is free, but you can open your wallet after you've seen the auction result.

    Sources (in Japanese): 日本銀行「金融政策決定会合における主な意見(2026年10月29、30日開催分)」/日本銀行「当面の金融政策運営について(2026年10月30日)」

    The page for this question (1 other answer) →

    Financing and interest rates 1 other answer
  • Corporate goods prices rose 7% from a year earlier. Should I also raise the repair cost estimate for the property I own by 7%?

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Answer first. Multiplying by 7% is half right, and half dangerous. Let's start with the right half. Trying to restate your repair cost est…Read moreClose

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Answer first. Multiplying by 7% is half right, and half dangerous.

    Let's start with the right half. Trying to restate your repair cost estimate is good of you. Prices are going up, so it's way better than staring at a plan with unit prices from years ago. With me so far?

    The dangerous half has two parts.

    The first is using 7% as "the rate for every year from now on." The October domestic corporate goods price index the Bank of Japan put out on November 12, 2026 was up 7.1% from a year earlier. That's a snapshot of how much prices rose over the past year. It's not a forecast. If you go back through the tables in the same release, a year earlier, in October 2025, it was 2.8%, and in February 2026 it was 2.2%, and then it jumped to 5.5% in April and 7.7% in July. A rate that more than tripled in under half a year, and you set it as the same for 10 years ahead? That's a stretch, right? Let's try multiplying work you've scheduled for 10 years from now by 7% every year. 1.07 to the 10th power is about 1.97 times, almost double today's quote. Do the same calculation with the 2.8% from a year earlier and it's about 1.32 times. Just which month you made the plan in changes the estimate this much. Stretch one year of growth over 10 years, and the snapshot turns into a forecast. Get it?

    No, it's right, putting the rise into the estimate is right, but the problem is how you put it in.

    The second one matters more. If you multiplied your expenses by 7%, what percentage are you multiplying your income by? Even if repair costs go up, rent doesn't go up automatically. Rent is decided by what tenants can pay and by the rent of similar units nearby. Looking at the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' consumer price index, rent for privately owned housing in September 2026 was up 0.8% from the same month a year earlier. Compared with the 7.1% for corporate goods prices, that's much slower. Sometimes it's right to inflate only the expenses with prices and leave income at current rent. But then the estimate of your cash left over goes down. Looking at that lower number and deciding whether you'll still keep holding the property is the real work. Did you notice?

    Well, then again, if you've added the same 7% to rent too and made it "break even," that's the more dangerous one. The 0.8% is a national average, and how rent rises is totally different depending on a property's location and age.

    "Didn't you just say multiplying by a rate is dangerous?" I didn't say don't multiply. I'm saying if you multiply, put a rate with a basis on each of expenses and income.

    So there's one thing to check. In the table where you fixed the repair cost estimate, what rate did you put on the rent estimate? Can you write the basis for that rate in one line? If you can't, that's the biggest hole. Well?

    Honestly, price figures are like the heat under a hot pot. If you only look at the high heat right now and write the recipe assuming high heat until the end, it'll burn, or you'll run short of ingredients. A winter hot pot is something you taste along the way and add to.

    Sources (in Japanese): 日本銀行「企業物価指数(2026年10月速報)」/総務省統計局「消費者物価指数(全国)2026年(令和8年)9月分」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Management and operation 2 other answers
  • What is required when buying or selling land or buildings in a "special monitoring zone"?

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The way you ask "what is required?" already has the look of someone half reading it as "a permit is required," right? No, I get what you m…Read moreClose

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita.

    The way you ask "what is required?" already has the look of someone half reading it as "a permit is required," right? No, I get what you mean. The state designates zones and even draws lines on a map. Then the inside looks like a place where buying and selling needs the state's stamp.

    Let me give the answer first. What's required isn't a permit, it's a notification. And it's before the contract, from both the selling side and the buying side. The threshold is 200 m² or more, and even a single condominium unit can fall within scope depending on how you count.

    Let's sort it out once. There are 3 assumptions around this question.

    The first is "once you're in a zone, you can't sell." The Cabinet Office FAQ says this law doesn't regulate transactions in land and the like, and that if you notify properly, it's fine to sign the contract. What gets stopped isn't the transaction, it's the person who signs a contract without notifying. If you sign without notifying, you can face imprisonment of up to 6 months or a fine of up to ¥1 million.

    The second is "only the buying side notifies." The subject of the provision is "the parties," and the Cabinet Office writes that it's both the seller and the buyer. The selling side also has a document to submit in its own name. Get it?

    The third is "you can submit it after the contract." The opposite. The provision says "in advance." If you mail it, it has to reach the Cabinet Office by the day before the planned contract date. There are exceptions, like mediation or auctions, where you submit within 2 weeks after the contract, but an ordinary sale isn't one of those.

    So, here's where people trip up the most. The one line "200 m² or more." We read sentences by cutting them into units, so it bugs us that the single word "area" has 3 kinds packed into it: land, buildings, and sectional units.

    Land is per parcel. Buildings are the floor area per building (the total of each floor, including annexed buildings). For a condominium unit, it's the floor area of the exclusive area, and common areas aren't added. Reading this far, you'd think a 25 m² studio unit has nothing to do with it, right?

    But there's the way the land side is counted. If the total site area multiplied by that unit's site-right share comes to 200 m² or more, notification is still required. Say the site-right share is 50/10,000: with a 30,000 m² site that's 150 m², out of scope; with 40,000 m² it's exactly 200 m², in scope. Even with the unit staying small, at a housing complex with a large site it crosses the line. Deciding "this has nothing to do with us" from the unit's size alone is too early. Okay?

    It's right, making the lines visible on a map to anyone. From October 28, 2026, the outer boundary lines of special monitoring zones were added to the Real Estate Information Library. But what the map tells you goes only as far as "inside or outside the line." How many m², who submits, by when: you have to count those yourself.

    What to do is honestly plain stuff. Check on the map whether you're inside. Count the 200 m² with the registered land area and floor area and the site-right share (for land, use the latest survey if there is one). Before setting the contract date, set the notification date. If a brokerage firm is involved, this notification is also among the items in the explanation of important matters (jūyō jikō setsumei), so you can check it there too.

    A reservation slip for New Year's Eve soba means something because you hand it in before New Year's Eve. Hand in the slip after you've finished eating, and it's just paper. Notification is the same: it's a notification because you submit it before the contract.

    Sources (in Japanese): 内閣府「届出について」/内閣府「FAQ(よくある質問)」/内閣府「土地等売買等届出書記載要領」/国土交通省「「不動産情報ライブラリ」コンテンツ追加およびデータ更新! ~「特別注視区域」(重要土地等調査法)データの追加等を10月28日に実施しました~」/e-Gov法令検索「重要施設周辺及び国境離島等における土地等の利用状況の調査及び利用の規制等に関する法律」/e-Gov法令検索「宅地建物取引業法施行令」

    The page for this question (1 other answer) →

    Law, contracts and systems 1 other answer
  • Are the loans shown at the top of a mortgage comparison site listed in order of the best terms?

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The moment you read "at the top" and "the best terms" as meaning the same thing, the design of that screen has already scored a point on y…Read moreClose

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The moment you read "at the top" and "the best terms" as meaning the same thing, the design of that screen has already scored a point on you.

    No, I get what you mean. It's shown at the very top, so it must be the best, right — that's what people normally think. So let me ask: "the best terms" for whom? For someone borrowing for how many years?

    Answer first. What shows up at the top is the loan that came out on top by the yardstick that site decided on. It isn't necessarily the best loan on your terms. What the yardstick is, the site writes somewhere on the screen. If it isn't written, the only thing you learn is that you don't know what order it's in.

    Let's sort it out once. There are two blind spots.

    One. There's only one yardstick. Even if you sort by lowest interest rate, interest isn't the only thing you pay after you borrow. When a loan whose administrative fee is "a percentage of the loan amount" sits next to one with a "flat" fee, the one ranked higher on rate can come out worse in total, depending on how many years until you finish paying it off (or sell, or refinance). And the rate shown isn't necessarily the same as your rate after you pass screening. The number one on the screen doesn't know your screening result. Get it?

    Two. The ordering itself can be built. Folks like me read words by cutting them into pieces, so when it says "recommended," I go looking for the subject. Recommended by whom?

    Here, the regulators are looking at the same spot. In the revision to the supervisory guidelines that the Financial Services Agency applied from November 6, 2026, a note was added: a comparison site simply posting product information received from a financial institution is not a problem. But if it processes the content, or sets up a design or algorithm so that products it wants to push come out on top, that may amount to "intermediation" under bank agency business. It also answered that even sorting by an objective yardstick like interest rates and fees, a license may be needed in some cases depending on how it's displayed and what else is written.

    That's right — it's about protecting users. But read it the other way round, and this note seems to assume that the ordering can be designed, and that the design moves how people choose. Am I wrong?

    So. What to do is, honestly, unglamorous. Read the explanation of the ordering. Check who runs the site, and which financial institution is the counterparty to the contract. Finally, with your own loan amount and your estimate of how many years until you let the home go or refinance, re-sort the totals of interest plus fees yourself. Number one is the entrance to the candidates. Not the conclusion. OK?

    With a box of apples, they line the best-looking ones on the top layer, right? That isn't cheating; it's how the box is made. Checking down to the bottom layer by hand is the buyer's job.

    Sources (in Japanese): 金融庁「「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針」等の一部改正(案)に対するパブリックコメントの結果等の公表について」/金融庁「「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針」等の一部改正(案)に対するパブリックコメントの概要及びそれに対する金融庁の考え方(別紙1)」/金融庁「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針 新旧対照表(別紙2)」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Financing and interest rates 2 other answers
  • What is required when buying or selling land or buildings in a "special monitoring zone"?

    This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. When concluding a contract such as a sale for land or buildings of 200 square meters or more inside …Read moreClose

    This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first.

    When concluding a contract such as a sale for land or buildings of 200 square meters or more inside a special monitoring zone, both the seller and the buyer notify the Prime Minister (the contact point is the Cabinet Office) before concluding the contract. It is not a procedure for obtaining a permit. Concluding a contract without notifying carries penalties. Even a single condominium unit is in scope if the total site area multiplied by the site-right share is 200 square meters or more.

    What is set and how

    The basis is the so-called Important Land Survey Act (formal name: Act on the Review and Regulation of the Use of Real Estate Surrounding Important Facilities and on Remote Territorial Islands, Act No. 84 of 2021 (Reiwa 3)) and its enforcement order.

    1. Monitoring zones: designated by the Prime Minister from areas within roughly 1,000 meters around the sites of important facilities and areas within remote territorial islands and the like (Article 5, Paragraph 1 of the Act).
    2. Special monitoring zones: designated in cases such as where the important facility related to a monitoring zone is a specified important facility whose function is difficult for other important facilities to substitute (Article 12, Paragraph 1 of the Act).
    3. Notification: when concluding a contract (including a preliminary agreement) that transfers or establishes ownership, or a right aimed at acquiring it, over land or the like within a special monitoring zone, the parties notify in advance of their names and addresses, the location and area, the type of right, the purpose of use, and so on (Article 13, Paragraph 1 of the Act). The size threshold is 200 square meters (Article 4 of the Enforcement Order).

    Land or the like that is only in a monitoring zone is not subject to notification.

    What to compare

    SituationNotificationBasis
    Sale, exchange, or gift (including a preliminary agreement) of land or buildings of 200 square meters or more within a special monitoring zoneRequired. Before the contract, from both the seller and the buyerArticle 13, Paragraph 1 of the Act; Article 4 of the Enforcement Order
    Within a monitoring zone (not a special monitoring zone)Not requiredCabinet Office, "On Notification"
    Transfers not based on a contract, such as inheritance, division of an estate, or a corporate mergerNot requiredSame as above
    Leases, establishment of superficies or mortgages, etc.Not required (not a transfer or establishment of ownership etc.)Same as above; Cabinet Office FAQ Q5-11
    The party acquiring the right is the national government, a local government, or a corporation specified in the Enforcement OrderNot requiredArticle 13, Paragraph 1 of the Act; Article 5 of the Enforcement Order
    Contracts through civil mediation, settlement in litigation, family mediation, or auction (as delinquency disposition, compulsory execution, or enforcement of a security interest)Within 2 weeks from the date the contract is concludedArticle 13, Paragraphs 2 and 3 of the Act; Article 7 of the Enforcement Order

    The dividing point

    Whether notification is required divides on how the area is counted.

    SubjectHow the area is counted
    LandPer parcel (judged based on the latest surveyed area)
    BuildingsFloor area per building (total of each floor, including annexed buildings)
    A unit in a sectionally owned buildingFor the building, the floor area of the exclusive area (common areas are not added). For the land, the total site area × that unit's site-right share

    The following are assumptions for illustration.

    ExampleCalculationNotification
    Exclusive area of 25 square meters, site of 30,000 square meters, site-right share of 50/10,00030,000×50/10,000=150 square metersNot required
    The same unit, with a site of 40,000 square meters40,000×50/10,000=200 square metersRequired
    An apartment building on 1 parcel of 165 square meters of land, with a building floor area of 220 square metersThe building is 200 square meters or moreRequired
    2 parcels of 120 square meters of land (240 square meters in total), no building120 square meters per parcelNot required

    Even if the exclusive area is small, in a building with a large site the land side can reach the threshold. This is an easily overlooked point.

    Conditions on the numbers

    • The system and zones are as of November 2026, and zones are designated successively by notice. The notification forms were changed on April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8).
    • Notification is by mail or by electronic application through e-Gov. By mail, it must reach the Cabinet Office by the day before the planned contract date. Email and fax are not accepted.
    • Concluding a contract without notification, failing to notify within 2 weeks, or making a false notification is subject to imprisonment of up to 6 months or a fine of up to ¥1 million (Article 26 of the Act).
    • The Cabinet Office FAQ states that this law does not regulate transactions in land and the like, and that if a proper notification is made, it is fine to conclude the contract. When a notification is made, the Prime Minister conducts a survey of the notified matters (Article 13, Paragraph 4 of the Act). When it is found that a user of the land or the like is using it for, or is clearly likely to use it for, acts that obstruct the functions of an important facility or the like, a recommendation is made after hearing the opinion of a council, and if the measures in the recommendation are not taken without justifiable reason, an order is possible (Article 9 of the Act).
    • In sales in which a licensed real estate broker is involved, this notification is included in the "restrictions based on laws and regulations" in the explanation of important matters (jūyō jikō setsumei) (Article 3, Paragraph 1, Item 64 of the Enforcement Order of the Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō)). Leases are not included.

    The order to check

    1. Check whether the property is inside a special monitoring zone in the Real Estate Information Library (outer boundary lines shown from October 28, 2026) or in the Cabinet Office's list of zones. Near a boundary, check against the zone in the notice.
    2. Count whether it is 200 square meters or more: land per parcel, buildings per building, and for a sectional unit both the exclusive area and "site × site-right share."
    3. Check whether the type of contract is in scope (whether it transfers or establishes ownership etc., and whether it includes a preliminary agreement).
    4. Work back from the planned contract date to set the notification date. Notification is required from both the seller and the buyer (Form 3 if filed jointly; if filed separately, both Form 4 and Form 5).
    5. If there is a broker acting as intermediary, check whether this notification is written in the statement of important matters.

    From here on is my opinion

    It has become easier to check on a map whether a property is inside a zone. I think the remaining misunderstandings are the land area of a sectional unit and the point that the seller is also a party. I think it is best to treat the notification not as a review that decides whether a transaction may proceed, but as a procedure to build into the contract schedule.

    Sources (in Japanese): e-Gov法令検索「重要施設周辺及び国境離島等における土地等の利用状況の調査及び利用の規制等に関する法律」/e-Gov法令検索「重要施設周辺及び国境離島等における土地等の利用状況の調査及び利用の規制等に関する法律施行令」/内閣府「届出について」/内閣府「FAQ(よくある質問)」/内閣府「郵送による届出について」/内閣府「土地等売買等届出書記載要領」/内閣府「区域の指定について」/国土交通省「「不動産情報ライブラリ」コンテンツ追加およびデータ更新! ~「特別注視区域」(重要土地等調査法)データの追加等を10月28日に実施しました~」/e-Gov法令検索「宅地建物取引業法施行令」

    The page for this question (1 other answer) →

    Law, contracts and systems 1 other answer
  • Are the loans shown at the top of a mortgage comparison site listed in order of the best terms?

    This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. The ordering on a comparison site is not set by law as "in order of the best terms." The operator de…Read moreClose

    This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first.

    The ordering on a comparison site is not set by law as "in order of the best terms." The operator decides what to sort by. Being shown at the top only shows that it came out on top by that site's criteria; it does not show the order of total repayment for each borrower.

    What is decided, and how

    A business that conducts, on behalf of a bank, "agency or intermediation for the conclusion of contracts for the lending of funds or the discounting of bills" is bank agency business (Banking Act, Article 2, paragraph 14, item 2). A bank agent is a person who conducts bank agency business with a license from the Prime Minister (Article 52-36, paragraph 1 of the same Act) (paragraph 15 of the same Article). A mortgage is a contract for the lending of funds.

    How far something counts as intermediation is set out in VIII-3-2-1-1 of the Financial Services Agency's "Comprehensive Guidelines for Supervision of Major Banks, etc." (commonly called the supervisory guidelines). The "contracts for the acceptance of deposits, etc." referred to here include the lending of funds (VIII-3-2-1-1(1)). On November 6, 2026, a note about comparison sites and similar was added, and it has applied from the same day.

    What to compare

    What the comparison site doesThe supervisory guidelines and the FSA's viewBasis
    Simply reposts product information received from a financial institutionNot a problemNote to VIII-3-2-1-1(3)②(a)
    Processes the product information received and posts itMay amount to intermediationSame as above
    Sets up a design or algorithm so that products it recommends are shown at the topMay amount to intermediationSame as above
    Sorts by objective indicators such as interest rates and feesJudged on the individual facts. Depending on how it is displayed and what else is written, a license may be needed in some casesAnswer No.18 in the results of the public comment

    Where the answer splits

    Whether something amounts to intermediation is to be judged substantively, case by case, according to the actual circumstances (note to VIII-3-2-1-1(2)), and no uniform standard is given (Answers No.13 and No.18). From the reader's side, the dividing lines are the following 3 points.

    1. Whether the ordering is based on indicators such as interest rates and fees, or on the operator's recommendation
    2. Whether the interest rates and fees shown are the financial institution's information as is, or have been processed by the operator
    3. Whether the operator recommends or explains a particular loan as its own view

    Conditions behind the numbers

    • The revision to the supervisory guidelines was published on November 6, 2026 and applied from the same day. The FSA says that as long as appropriate steps toward improvement are being taken, it will not immediately treat it as a problem if improvements are not complete as of the publication date (Answer No.1).
    • The new note is written in general terms such as "acceptance of deposits, etc." and "products," and does not name mortgages (the example in Answer No.18 of the public comment is also deposit interest rates). However, "acceptance of deposits, etc." in the guidelines includes the lending of funds (VIII-3-2-1-1(1)).
    • The supervisory guidelines are the supervisory view. They do not define what the ordering means for users.
    • The ranking by interest rate and the ranking by total repayment do not necessarily match. Between a loan whose administrative fee is set as a rate on the loan amount and a loan with a flat fee, which total is larger can switch depending on the number of years until full repayment or refinancing.

    Order of checks

    1. Read the explanation of the ordering on the screen (what it is sorted by, and whether there are labels such as "recommended" or "PR")
    2. Check the operator's name and see whether it is on the FSA's list of bank agents and financial service intermediaries (a site that simply reposts does not need a license, so not being listed does not in itself mean there is a problem)
    3. Check the name of the financial institution that will be the counterparty to the contract
    4. Read the notes on the rate shown (under what conditions the rate applies, and whether it changes with screening)
    5. Re-sort the totals of interest and fees combined using your own loan amount, loan term and the number of years you expect until you let the home go

    From here on, this is my opinion

    The ordering is the result of how the operator chose and presented information. The November 2026 revision assumes that this presentation can move users' choices. I think it is reasonable to use comparison sites as a place to gather candidates, and to decide not by ranking but by the total calculated on your own terms.

    Sources (in Japanese): e-Gov法令検索(デジタル庁)「銀行法」/金融庁「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針 Ⅷ 銀行代理業」/金融庁「「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針」等の一部改正(案)に対するパブリックコメントの結果等の公表について」/金融庁「「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針」等の一部改正(案)に対するパブリックコメントの概要及びそれに対する金融庁の考え方(別紙1)」/金融庁「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針 新旧対照表(別紙2)」/金融庁「免許・許可・登録等を受けている業者一覧」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Financing and interest rates 2 other answers
  • I heard the inheritance tax valuation of unlisted shares is being reviewed. What happens to inheritance planning that holds real estate in a corporation?

    This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. As of November 12, 2026, no review of the inheritance tax valuation of unlisted shares has been deci…Read moreClose

    This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. As of November 12, 2026, no review of the inheritance tax valuation of unlisted shares has been decided. In the expert panel meetings in August and September, the National Tax Agency presented a draft of a new valuation method and trial calculations, but in September the Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry announced its opposition, and the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency also submitted an opinion calling for careful consideration. On October 29, the Liberal Democratic Party's Japan Growth Strategy Headquarters adopted an emergency resolution stating that the National Tax Agency's draft was unacceptable. Then on November 4, the Minister of Finance said at the House of Representatives Committee on Financial Affairs that the expert panel would be halted for now and that the ruling parties' tax commission would be asked to discuss the matter without taking the National Tax Agency's draft as a premise. What can be said now goes only as far as "what the issues are."

    The current rules (the Basic Circular on Property Valuation)

    For shares with no market quotation, the method used depends on the size of the company. Large companies use the comparable industry method, small companies use the net asset value method, and medium companies use a combination of the two (small and medium companies have some room to choose). For corporations that hold real estate, the following rules have a particular effect.

    RuleContent
    Land-holding specified companyA company whose land and similar assets make up 70% or more of total assets for a large company, or 90% or more for a medium company, is valued by the net asset value method. A small company, too, is judged by the large-company or medium-company standard if its total assets are at or above a certain amount
    Land and buildings acquired within 3 years before the taxation dateIn calculating net asset value, they are valued at the ordinary transaction price, not at the inheritance tax assessed value such as road-rating land values (rosenka)
    Amount equivalent to corporate tax etc. on the valuation differenceWhen net assets calculated at inheritance tax assessed values exceed net assets at book value, a certain percentage of the difference (the valuation difference) is deducted. The percentage is 38% for inheritances and gifts on or after April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8) (37% before that)

    The draft the National Tax Agency presented to the expert panel (5th and 6th meetings)

    IssueContent of the draft
    Valuation methodStop distinguishing by company size and, in principle, unify into the "residual income method"
    How the residual income method worksAdd 5 years of residual income (normal profit minus "book net assets × capitalization rate") to book net assets, and multiply by a discount factor. The direction is for the National Tax Agency to publish the capitalization rate periodically. The discount factor is undecided
    Asset management companiesIn principle, the net asset value method. The direction is to judge by whether the book value of specified assets such as rental real estate is 70% or more of total assets, or whether income from managing them is 75% or more of total revenue. The standard for distinguishing a real estate rental business from an asset management company is undecided
    Trial calculationsAssuming a capitalization rate of 8% and a discount factor of 0.7, the median change against current filed valuations was a 50.3% increase for large companies and a 31.6% decrease for small companies

    Reports in August said "the aim is application from January 2028 at the earliest," but that is not an application date decided by the National Tax Agency, and the draft above has itself been halted for now.

    How to read this for corporations that hold real estate

    Because the residual income method is based on book value, if the draft goes ahead as written, unrealized gains on land would not be included as they are. On the other hand, if a company is judged to be an asset management company, the net asset value method applies and unrealized gains are included in the valuation. The valuation can change greatly depending on which way a company is sorted, yet that standard has not been decided. "Will inheritance planning that holds real estate in a corporation become more favorable or less favorable?" is a question that has no answer as of November 12.

    As a separate matter, in September the National Tax Agency published a draft circular stating that "rental real estate acquired within 5 years before the taxation date is valued at the ordinary transaction price," and invited public comments (a draft to apply to inheritances and gifts from January 2027 onward). Under the draft, this 5-year provision would not apply to land and buildings when valuing a corporation's shares at net asset value, and the 3-year acquisition rule would remain. This circular has not been finalized either.

    What you can do now

    1. Re-value your company's shares under the current rules. Check whether it is a land-holding specified company and whether it has any properties acquired within 3 years.
    2. Also work out the amount valued by the net asset value method alone. Whichever draft is adopted, it becomes a baseline for comparison.
    3. In the outline of the FY2027 (Reiwa 9) tax reform, expected to be compiled in December, check whether the review of unlisted share valuation is taken up, and if so, in which direction.

    From here on is my opinion

    For now, I think there is little reason to hurry into gifting shares or restructuring a company on the premise of a draft that has not been decided. I think it is not too late to decide after reading the outline and, if the review goes forward, the draft circular amendments presented after that.

    Sources (in Japanese): 国税庁「取引相場のない株式の評価に関する有識者会議(第5回)議事要旨」/PwC税理士法人「非上場株式の評価の見直し(続報)国税庁が示した見直し案と関係機関の意見」/経済産業省 中小企業庁「「取引相場のない株式の評価」見直しに係る意見(第6回有識者会議 オブザーバー提出)」/名南経営ソリューションズ「取引相場のない株式の評価に関する国税庁の見直し案、事実上の凍結?」/熊本日日新聞「非上場株の相続見直し反対 自民、投資抑制を懸念(共同通信配信)」/日刊薬業「非上場株の評価見直し案に反対 事業承継を阻害、日商」/熊本日日新聞「国税庁、非上場株の相続適正化 過度な節税防止へ新算定ルール案(共同通信配信)」/国税庁「取引相場のない株式等の評価(純資産価額方式における法人税額等相当額)」/税理士法人トゥモローズ「貸付用不動産の相続税評価はこう変わる|通達案(パブコメ)を図解で解説」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Taxes 2 other answers
  • Are the loans shown at the top of a mortgage comparison site listed in order of the best terms?

    Hey, it's Jamie! You'd think the one shown at the very top is the best loan, right? I thought so too! Actually, it's because I thought so that I'm writing this …Read moreClose

    Hey, it's Jamie! You'd think the one shown at the very top is the best loan, right? I thought so too! Actually, it's because I thought so that I'm writing this now.

    When I was looking into refinancing my mortgage, I re-sorted a comparison site by "lowest interest rate first." I re-sorted it myself, properly! Pretty good, right? Number 1 had a rate of 1.20%, number 2 had 1.30%. With a 0.1 percentage point difference, there's no reason to hesitate. I went straight from number 1's screen to applying, and refinanced.

    When I looked back over the documents later, number 1's administrative fee was "2.2% of the loan amount," and number 2's was "a flat ¥55,000." ...I think it was written somewhere on the screen. I probably just didn't scroll!

    So I redid the calculation. These are made-up numbers for illustration: a balance of ¥20 million, 35 years, equal principal-and-interest payments, the rate never changes, and all other costs are the same. Monthly repayment is ¥58,340 for number 1 and ¥59,296 for number 2, a difference of ¥956. If you repay it all over 35 years, the total of interest and fees is about ¥4.94 million for number 1 and about ¥4.96 million for number 2, so number 1 is about ¥17,000 less. So far, number 1 wins!

    But I'd been saying for a while that I wanted to move in about 10 years. If you sell in 10 years, the interest and fees for those 10 years are about ¥2.56 million for number 1 and about ¥2.35 million for number 2. Number 2 is about ¥200,000 less. That means the ¥440,000 fee I paid at the start can't be earned back in 10 years.

    The ranking doesn't know how many years I plan to keep the home. Obviously!

    There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

    • The yardstick I sorted by was just one. Neither the fees nor how many years until I let the home go are in that yardstick
    • Work out the total not only by "how many years you borrow for" but by "how many years until you sell or refinance"
    • Before going on to apply, scroll down to the fee section

    Thanks to that, now whenever I open a comparison site, I've got the habit of first scrolling all the way to the bottom. My finger has gotten really strong! ...As for the loan, I'm still borrowing with number 1, though!

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Financing and interest rates 2 other answers
  • I heard the inheritance tax valuation of unlisted shares is being reviewed. What happens to inheritance planning that holds real estate in a corporation?

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me say this first. That "review" is the draft that came out at the National Tax Agency's expert panel in August and September, right? …Read moreClose

    Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me say this first. That "review" is the draft that came out at the National Tax Agency's expert panel in August and September, right? On November 4, the Minister of Finance said in the Diet that the panel would be halted for now and the ruling parties' tax commission would be asked to discuss it without taking the National Tax Agency's draft as a premise. So "the formula changes from 2028" is not a settled thing. We're way further back than the headlines' momentum suggests.

    So, more than whether it changes, what bothers me is the premise in the question. "Hold real estate in a corporation and inheritance tax goes down" is conditional even under the current rules. Get it?

    The price of a corporation's shares is set by the valuation of the real estate that corporation holds. A landlord's corporation tends to have almost all its total assets in land and buildings. A company with a large share of land becomes a "land-holding specified company" and is calculated by the net asset value method, which values the company's contents as they are. You can't use profits or dividends to push the share price down. On top of that, land and buildings the company bought within 3 years before the death are valued at the ordinary transaction price, not road-rating land values. If it was just bought, that's pretty much the purchase price.

    Then where does the difference from holding in a corporation come from? Let me set one example with made-up numbers. A property the company bought decades ago, ¥100 million on the books and ¥140 million at inheritance tax assessed value. Assume no borrowing. Under the net asset value method, you can deduct 38% of the ¥40 million difference, ¥15.2 million (the percentage for inheritances on or after April 2026 (Reiwa 8); 37% before that). The share valuation is ¥124.8 million. If you held the same property in the same amount as an individual, it stays at ¥140 million. With me so far?

    Well, calling this "the corporation's gain" isn't quite right. This deduction is an adjustment that anticipates the corporate tax that would be charged on the unrealized gain if the company sold the property. Plus, even if you move a property you hold personally into a corporation now, the books take the price at the time of transfer, so this difference hardly arises. There's tax when you transfer it, too. It's a thin difference that remains only for properties that have been in the company for a long time.

    So if you set up a corporation for inheritance tax alone, the ground shakes under you every time the valuation rules move. Like this time, just a draft coming out and the sales materials push "take measures right now." It's right, it's right to pay attention, but honestly, people for whom holding in a corporation makes sense for reasons other than inheritance tax are on firmer ground. Whether you can split income among family members, how expenses are handled, the hassle of the procedures to pass it to the next generation. If it pays off on those, inheritance tax is just a bonus. If it doesn't, the whole plan falls apart when the valuation numbers move a little. Noticed?

    There's one thing to check. "Even if the inheritance tax difference became zero, is there a reason to keep this corporation?" Write it on paper and see whether a reason remains. How about it?

    You know hoshigaki, dried persimmons? You dry astringent persimmons to make them sweet. Even an astringent fruit transforms with time and effort. But if you dry sweet persimmons, there's little gain for the effort. If you don't decide first what you're drying them for, all that's left is the effort of hanging them under the eaves.

    Sources (in Japanese): 名南経営ソリューションズ「取引相場のない株式の評価に関する国税庁の見直し案、事実上の凍結?」/国税庁「取引相場のない株式等の評価(純資産価額方式における法人税額等相当額)」/野村不動産ソリューションズ(ノムコム・プロ)「評価会社が課税時期前3年以内に取得した土地や家屋を有する場合の純資産価額方式の計算」

    The page for this question (2 other answers) →

    Taxes 2 other answers