BENERU
TaxesPublished

I heard the inheritance tax valuation of unlisted shares is being reviewed. What happens to inheritance planning that holds real estate in a corporation?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

3 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. As of November 12, 2026, no review of the inheritance tax valuation of unlisted shares has been decided. In the expert panel meetings in August and September, the National Tax Agency presented a draft of a new valuation method and trial calculations, but in September the Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry announced its opposition, and the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency also submitted an opinion calling for careful consideration. On October 29, the Liberal Democratic Party's Japan Growth Strategy Headquarters adopted an emergency resolution stating that the National Tax Agency's draft was unacceptable. Then on November 4, the Minister of Finance said at the House of Representatives Committee on Financial Affairs that the expert panel would be halted for now and that the ruling parties' tax commission would be asked to discuss the matter without taking the National Tax Agency's draft as a premise. What can be said now goes only as far as "what the issues are."

The current rules (the Basic Circular on Property Valuation)

For shares with no market quotation, the method used depends on the size of the company. Large companies use the comparable industry method, small companies use the net asset value method, and medium companies use a combination of the two (small and medium companies have some room to choose). For corporations that hold real estate, the following rules have a particular effect.

RuleContent
Land-holding specified companyA company whose land and similar assets make up 70% or more of total assets for a large company, or 90% or more for a medium company, is valued by the net asset value method. A small company, too, is judged by the large-company or medium-company standard if its total assets are at or above a certain amount
Land and buildings acquired within 3 years before the taxation dateIn calculating net asset value, they are valued at the ordinary transaction price, not at the inheritance tax assessed value such as road-rating land values (rosenka)
Amount equivalent to corporate tax etc. on the valuation differenceWhen net assets calculated at inheritance tax assessed values exceed net assets at book value, a certain percentage of the difference (the valuation difference) is deducted. The percentage is 38% for inheritances and gifts on or after April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8) (37% before that)

The draft the National Tax Agency presented to the expert panel (5th and 6th meetings)

IssueContent of the draft
Valuation methodStop distinguishing by company size and, in principle, unify into the "residual income method"
How the residual income method worksAdd 5 years of residual income (normal profit minus "book net assets × capitalization rate") to book net assets, and multiply by a discount factor. The direction is for the National Tax Agency to publish the capitalization rate periodically. The discount factor is undecided
Asset management companiesIn principle, the net asset value method. The direction is to judge by whether the book value of specified assets such as rental real estate is 70% or more of total assets, or whether income from managing them is 75% or more of total revenue. The standard for distinguishing a real estate rental business from an asset management company is undecided
Trial calculationsAssuming a capitalization rate of 8% and a discount factor of 0.7, the median change against current filed valuations was a 50.3% increase for large companies and a 31.6% decrease for small companies

Reports in August said "the aim is application from January 2028 at the earliest," but that is not an application date decided by the National Tax Agency, and the draft above has itself been halted for now.

How to read this for corporations that hold real estate

Because the residual income method is based on book value, if the draft goes ahead as written, unrealized gains on land would not be included as they are. On the other hand, if a company is judged to be an asset management company, the net asset value method applies and unrealized gains are included in the valuation. The valuation can change greatly depending on which way a company is sorted, yet that standard has not been decided. "Will inheritance planning that holds real estate in a corporation become more favorable or less favorable?" is a question that has no answer as of November 12.

As a separate matter, in September the National Tax Agency published a draft circular stating that "rental real estate acquired within 5 years before the taxation date is valued at the ordinary transaction price," and invited public comments (a draft to apply to inheritances and gifts from January 2027 onward). Under the draft, this 5-year provision would not apply to land and buildings when valuing a corporation's shares at net asset value, and the 3-year acquisition rule would remain. This circular has not been finalized either.

What you can do now

  1. Re-value your company's shares under the current rules. Check whether it is a land-holding specified company and whether it has any properties acquired within 3 years.
  2. Also work out the amount valued by the net asset value method alone. Whichever draft is adopted, it becomes a baseline for comparison.
  3. In the outline of the FY2027 (Reiwa 9) tax reform, expected to be compiled in December, check whether the review of unlisted share valuation is taken up, and if so, in which direction.

From here on is my opinion

For now, I think there is little reason to hurry into gifting shares or restructuring a company on the premise of a draft that has not been decided. I think it is not too late to decide after reading the outline and, if the review goes forward, the draft circular amendments presented after that.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me say this first. That "review" is the draft that came out at the National Tax Agency's expert panel in August and September, right? On November 4, the Minister of Finance said in the Diet that the panel would be halted for now and the ruling parties' tax commission would be asked to discuss it without taking the National Tax Agency's draft as a premise. So "the formula changes from 2028" is not a settled thing. We're way further back than the headlines' momentum suggests.

So, more than whether it changes, what bothers me is the premise in the question. "Hold real estate in a corporation and inheritance tax goes down" is conditional even under the current rules. Get it?

The price of a corporation's shares is set by the valuation of the real estate that corporation holds. A landlord's corporation tends to have almost all its total assets in land and buildings. A company with a large share of land becomes a "land-holding specified company" and is calculated by the net asset value method, which values the company's contents as they are. You can't use profits or dividends to push the share price down. On top of that, land and buildings the company bought within 3 years before the death are valued at the ordinary transaction price, not road-rating land values. If it was just bought, that's pretty much the purchase price.

Then where does the difference from holding in a corporation come from? Let me set one example with made-up numbers. A property the company bought decades ago, ¥100 million on the books and ¥140 million at inheritance tax assessed value. Assume no borrowing. Under the net asset value method, you can deduct 38% of the ¥40 million difference, ¥15.2 million (the percentage for inheritances on or after April 2026 (Reiwa 8); 37% before that). The share valuation is ¥124.8 million. If you held the same property in the same amount as an individual, it stays at ¥140 million. With me so far?

Well, calling this "the corporation's gain" isn't quite right. This deduction is an adjustment that anticipates the corporate tax that would be charged on the unrealized gain if the company sold the property. Plus, even if you move a property you hold personally into a corporation now, the books take the price at the time of transfer, so this difference hardly arises. There's tax when you transfer it, too. It's a thin difference that remains only for properties that have been in the company for a long time.

So if you set up a corporation for inheritance tax alone, the ground shakes under you every time the valuation rules move. Like this time, just a draft coming out and the sales materials push "take measures right now." It's right, it's right to pay attention, but honestly, people for whom holding in a corporation makes sense for reasons other than inheritance tax are on firmer ground. Whether you can split income among family members, how expenses are handled, the hassle of the procedures to pass it to the next generation. If it pays off on those, inheritance tax is just a bonus. If it doesn't, the whole plan falls apart when the valuation numbers move a little. Noticed?

There's one thing to check. "Even if the inheritance tax difference became zero, is there a reason to keep this corporation?" Write it on paper and see whether a reason remains. How about it?

You know hoshigaki, dried persimmons? You dry astringent persimmons to make them sweet. Even an astringent fruit transforms with time and effort. But if you dry sweet persimmons, there's little gain for the effort. If you don't decide first what you're drying them for, all that's left is the effort of hanging them under the eaves.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Let's talk about the lifespan of rules.

In April 1964 (Showa 39), the National Tax Agency set out the yardstick for valuing property in the Basic Circular on Property Valuation. The valuation of shares in unlisted companies has also continued within this circular, with revision after revision. That's why this National Tax Agency draft was reported as "the first fundamental review of the calculation method."

Around a rule that lasts a long time, know-how for poking at its gaps grows. As I see it, inheritance planning that uses the difference between valuation yardsticks like road-rating land values and actual buying and selling prices has turned up again and again, era after era.

One of those was stopped in a big way by the Supreme Court judgment of April 19, 2022 (Reiwa 4). A wealthy individual, also using borrowing, bought 2 rental condominium buildings for about ¥1,387 million in total, and after the death their valuation under the circular came to about ¥334 million in total. The inheritance tax was filed as zero. The state used the circular's exception provision, General Rule Paragraph 6, to reassess the tax at the appraised price, and the Supreme Court found that lawful. After that, in September 2023 (Reiwa 5), the National Tax Agency issued a new circular on the valuation of a unit in a condominium for sale, and from inheritances on or after January 1, 2024 (Reiwa 6), a mechanism was introduced to bring valuations closer to actual prices.

This review of unlisted shares also got moving when, in November 2024 (Reiwa 6), the Board of Audit pointed out that differences in valuation arise depending on the valuation method. But in the autumn of 2026 (Reiwa 8), opposition and calls for caution came from the chambers of commerce and the Small and Medium Enterprise Agency, and a resolution of opposition came from within the ruling party too. Then on November 4, the Minister of Finance said in the Diet that the National Tax Agency's panel would be halted for now. Even the side closing the gap can have its draft stopped in the political arena.

When I was young, I too figured out the trick of the happy hour at my regular place, and I'd order one drink after another just before closing to stock up. Within 3 years, the owner cut the time by an hour. My wife laughed and said what had shrunk was my wallet. Kakakaka.

There are 2 things history tells us. Planning that leans on the difference between valuation and actual prices gets closed off someday. With the condominiums, the circular came after the court case. And even the side closing the gap hasn't decided until it's decided. Neither direction is a reason to rush into moving.

If you have an inheritance planning proposal at hand, check which circular, and which provision from when, the places that say "the valuation goes down" are based on. The more a plan stands on old provisions, the more it shakes when the rules move.

Well, I think I'll slowly have a glass of shochu whose time doesn't get cut.