BENERU
Corporations, inheritance and successionPublished Updated

Should I hold real estate personally or through a corporation? Where does it split?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Whether to hold real estate personally or through a corporation splits on the size of the income from the real estate, the income from your main job, whether you can divide income among family members, and your inheritance plans. Individual income tax is progressive, with the rate rising as income grows, and the part of taxable income over ¥9 million up to ¥18 million is taxed at 33% by income tax alone. A corporation has fixed costs such as the per-capita levy of resident tax, which is charged every year even in a loss, and tax accountant fees.

Differences in taxes and costs

ItemIndividualCorporation
Tax on incomeIncome tax (progressive, 5–45%) + resident tax 10%Corporate tax, etc. For small and medium-sized corporations, the rate on the part of income up to ¥8 million is reduced
Tax charged even in a lossNonePer-capita levy of corporate resident tax (at least about ¥70,000 a year)
Costs of setting up and maintainingNoneCosts of incorporation registration, tax accountant fees, etc.
Dividing income among familySalaries for full-time family employees under blue-return filing, etc. (requires business-scale operations); the requirements are limitedEasier to divide through executive compensation, etc.
Range of what can be expensedCosts related to real estate incomeThe range widens to executive compensation, insurance contracted by the corporation, etc.
Tax when sellingSeparate taxation (about 20% for long-term)Combined with other income and subject to corporate tax, etc.

Situations where incorporating is easier to consider

SituationReason
Taxable income from your main job and real estate combined is highThe individual progressive rate rises, and the gap with the corporate rate widens
You can pay family members compensation as executivesDividing income can lower the overall tax rate
You plan to add more propertiesYou can get financing as a corporation and build up assets in the corporation
You are thinking about inheritance planningYou can pass it on as shares in the corporation rather than as properties

Order of checks

  1. Check your current taxable income and tax rate, combining your main job and the real estate.
  2. Write out the fixed costs of a corporation (per-capita levy, tax accountant fees, etc.).
  3. Estimate the burden, including social insurance premiums, if you pay family members executive compensation.
  4. Decide whether to move the properties you already own into the corporation, or to use the corporation from the next property you buy.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think incorporation should be judged not only by the difference in tax rates, but by whether a gain remains after subtracting the annual fixed costs and social insurance premiums. While you have few properties, the fixed costs often exceed the tax difference.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Holding personally or through a corporation. The line where it splits isn't carved into the ground; it's a line the authorities redraw from time to time — that's how I see it.

Let me turn the clock back. In the fiscal 2006 (Heisei 18) tax reform, a rule was introduced for companies where a family held almost all of the shares and executive seats. They were called "specially controlled family companies," and of the salary such a company paid its core executives, the part corresponding to the employment income deduction could not be counted as the company's expense. It applied from business years starting on or after April 1, 2006 (Heisei 18). As I see it, it was meant to rein in the double benefit of expensing it in the company and also taking the deduction personally.

But this rule was set to be abolished in the bill to amend the Income Tax Act, etc., submitted to the Diet in 2010 (Heisei 22). It vanished within a few years of coming in.

The line kept moving after that. For individual income tax, from 2015 (Heisei 27) a 45% rate was added for the part of taxable income over ¥40 million. The basic corporate tax rate went down from 25.5% in fiscal 2014 (Heisei 26) to 23.2% in fiscal 2018 (Heisei 30). So things moved in the direction of heavier at the top for individuals and lighter for corporations.

When I told my wife about this, she said, "It's just like your rules for your evening drink." I decided on 2 gō a day, yet at New Year it's 3 gō, and when guests come it's a separate tab. She asked whether rules are there to keep or to change, and I put down my sake cup without a word.

Back to the point. What does this history change for the reader? The advantage of holding through a corporation isn't made of the difference in tax rates alone. It sits on top of detailed rules, such as how executive salaries are treated and how family executives are treated. Between 2006 (Heisei 18) and 2010 (Heisei 22), the salary advantage of small family-run companies was cut once and then came back. There must have been people who set up corporations in that time, and people who wound them up.

People have always been like that. They think the current rules will go on forever and make their plans. But once you set up a corporation, winding it up also takes work and money. If you move a property into the corporation's name, moving it back isn't simple either.

So there's one thing to do. Write out on paper your reasons for wanting to hold through a corporation, and mark the ones that would vanish if just one tax rule changed. If reasons without a mark remain, those are reasons that won't waver even when the line is redrawn.

Young ones, rules change. The one who chose a form that won't be troubled when they change is the one who laughs last.

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper