BENERU
Corporations, inheritance and successionPublished Updated

I was told that incorporating is pointless unless I build another apartment building. Is that true?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. There is no rule that you must build a new building to get the benefits of incorporating. Whether incorporating pays off is judged by calculating the difference between individual and corporate tax rates, the taxes on transferring properties, and where the corporation's losses can be used.

Individual and corporate tax rates

CategoryTax rate (as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8))
Individual income taxProgressive from 5% to 45% (plus 2.1% of the income tax amount separately as special income tax for reconstruction). On top of this, 10% resident tax on income
Corporate tax (corporations with capital of ¥100 million or less)15% on the portion up to ¥8 million a year, 23.2% on the portion above

The 15% corporate tax is a special rule that applies to business years beginning by March 31, 2027 (Reiwa 9). For business years with income over ¥1 billion a year it is 17%, and wholly (100%) owned subsidiaries of large corporations and the like are not covered. Corporations are also separately subject to local corporate tax, corporate inhabitant tax and enterprise tax.

Treatment of losses

  • Losses from an individual's real estate income can be offset against other income such as salary (offsetting losses against other income). However, the part corresponding to interest on borrowing to acquire land cannot be offset.
  • A corporation's losses (net operating losses) can be deducted from that corporation's income for 10 years from the following business year onward, if it files a blue return.

Even if a newly created corporation builds a building and makes a loss, that loss can be used only when that corporation has income. The income of properties the individual keeps owning does not decrease.

If properties are transferred from the individual to the corporation

To whomWhat is charged
Individual (seller)Tax on capital gains (transfer income). The building's acquisition cost is calculated after subtracting the amount equivalent to depreciation expense
Corporation (buyer)Real estate acquisition tax, registration and license tax

If you sell to a corporation at a price below one-half of market value, capital gains are calculated as if it were sold at market value (Income Tax Act, Article 59). Even at one-half or more, in transactions with a family company, the calculation may be made at market value. When a corporation acquires a second-hand building, it can estimate the useful life of a second-hand asset (by the simplified method and so on) and depreciate it from the business year it starts using it in the business. If renovation costs after acquisition exceed 50% of the acquisition cost, the simplified method cannot be used.

Order of checks

  1. List the market value, loan balance, and annual rent and expenses of each of the 8 buildings.
  2. Check the individual's taxable income and current tax rate.
  3. Estimate the tax on capital gains, and the real estate acquisition tax and registration and license tax, if the properties are transferred to the corporation.
  4. For a newly built building, set aside the tax story and check whether it balances on rent and repayments alone.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think incorporation and new construction should be judged separately. The gains and losses of incorporating can be calculated from the numbers of the existing properties, and new construction is a matter decided by whether it holds up even without taxes.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. You want to reduce taxes. I totally get that feeling. Looking at the tax bill for 8 buildings every year, of course you'd want to reduce it. But you know, "building another one to create a loss" is the most expensive way to answer that feeling.

Back to the formula. A loss on the books is the amount that goes negative when you subtract expenses, interest and depreciation from rent. The one most likely to get big among these is depreciation. And what depreciation is: it's just splitting the money you paid to build over a number of years and making it an expense. According to the National Tax Agency's explanation of corporate tax, assets acquired on or after April 1, 2007 (Heisei 19) can be depreciated down to ¥1 left on the books once the useful life has passed. In other words, the upper limit of what becomes an expense is exactly the amount you paid.

All numbers are assumptions. Say you build for ¥80 million. This building's depreciation, however many years it takes, totals about ¥80 million. Looking only at the corporate tax rate, even if all of it could be used in the 23.2% portion, the tax reduced is ¥80 million × 23.2%, about ¥18.56 million. In the 15% portion up to ¥8 million a year, it's about ¥12 million. Wow. You pay ¥80 million, and the tax that comes back is at most about ¥18.56 million. The remaining roughly ¥61.44 million can only be recovered through rent. Does that answer it? Looking at corporate tax alone, tax saving is a deal where you "spend ¥1 and get back at most ¥0.232."

And on top of that, that roughly ¥18.56 million doesn't come back all at once. Assume a useful life of 22 years and divide roughly by 22: depreciation is about ¥3.64 million a year, and the corporate tax reduced is about ¥840,000 a year. That's assuming the corporation has that much income every year. If you borrowed to build, repayments start from the first month.

Well, of course, the real point starts here. So why does the mood turn troubled when "the first building's depreciation ends"? When depreciation ends, expenses go down and taxes go up. But depreciation was an expense where no money goes out in the first place. Even when it ends, the money leaving your bankbook only increases by the increase in tax. This part's a bit tricky, but the problem isn't "the loss disappearing," it's "how much of the rent is going to principal repayments, which aren't an expense." Get it?

Well, I won't say depreciation on a new build means zero. It has the effect of pushing taxes back. But pushing back and erasing are different. The book value drops by the amount depreciated, so when you sell someday, the profit comes out bigger by exactly that much.

"The bank's trust" splits in the same order. Borrowing itself isn't trust, it's a liability. The record of continuing to repay is what becomes trust.

How to check. Take the total tax savings in the proposal and divide by the construction cost. Whatever ratio comes out, 1 minus that is the part recovered through rent. Is that recovery table in the proposal? If not, just have them provide it. Okay?

Turnips, right — when they come with leaves, you feel like you got a bargain, but nobody buys 10 turnips because they want the leaves. Tax saving is the leaves. When you choose, look at the turnip itself. See you.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper