Yeah yeah, it's Rita. When someone tells you "it saves on taxes," first ask "which tax goes down, by how much, and when?" The answer is usually fuzzy.
Here's how it works. Real estate income is rent minus necessary expenses. Expenses include fixed asset tax, insurance premiums, repair costs, and depreciation expense, among others. If real estate income is in deficit, it can be offset against other income such as salary. This is offsetting losses against other income, and it's the logic by which tax withheld from your salary comes back. However, the part of the deficit corresponding to interest on money borrowed to buy the land can't be offset.
Let's do it in numbers. The assumptions are these. Rental income of ¥960,000 a year. ¥240,000 a year for the management fee and repair reserve fund, ¥80,000 a year for fixed asset tax and the like, depreciation expense of ¥700,000 a year, and loan interest of ¥250,000 a year, of which ¥50,000 is for the land. Total expenses are ¥1.27 million, and real estate income is a deficit of ¥310,000. The ¥50,000 of interest for the land can't be offset, so what can be offset against salary is ¥260,000. For someone whose combined income tax and resident tax rate is 30%, the tax that comes back is ¥78,000 a year.
Now let's look inside the wallet. Assuming loan repayments of ¥1 million a year in principal and interest, from the ¥960,000 of rent you pay ¥320,000 for the management fee and taxes and ¥1 million in repayments, so ¥360,000 a year out of pocket. The ¥700,000 of depreciation is an expense with no cash going out, so the deficit on the books and the actual out-of-pocket amount are different things. In other words, to reduce taxes by ¥78,000, you're paying ¥360,000 every year.
One more. The amount you expensed through depreciation is subtracted from the building's acquisition cost when you sell. As the price on the books goes down, the gain on sale comes out larger. The tax you reduced now is likely to come back when you sell. What's called tax saving is, in many cases, really "paying the tax later."
To be fair, if you're someone with a high tax rate on your salary and the tax rate when you sell is lower, that difference is a real gain. For long-term capital gains, income tax and resident tax combined are in the 20% range. But whether it's worth taking on the yearly out-of-pocket costs and the loan risk to go after that difference is a separate calculation.
Conclusion. Tax saving isn't a reason to buy a property; it's a bonus after you buy. A proposal that makes the bonus the star is the same as confessing that the main cash flow is in the red.
Looking only at the tax receipt and not at the wallet's balance. As household bookkeeping goes, that's the one way you must never keep the books.
Sources (in Japanese)
- 国税庁「No.1370 不動産収入を受け取ったとき(不動産所得)」(checked 2026-10-08)
- 国税庁「No.1391 不動産所得が赤字のときの他の所得との通算」(checked 2026-10-08)
- 国税庁「No.3202 譲渡所得の計算のしかた(分離課税)」(checked 2026-10-08)
- 国税庁「No.3208 長期譲渡所得の税額の計算」(checked 2026-10-08)