BENERU
TaxesPublished

If it saves on taxes, is investing in a studio condominium a good idea?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

3 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. When someone tells you "it saves on taxes," first ask "which tax goes down, by how much, and when?" The answer is usually fuzzy.

Here's how it works. Real estate income is rent minus necessary expenses. Expenses include fixed asset tax, insurance premiums, repair costs, and depreciation expense, among others. If real estate income is in deficit, it can be offset against other income such as salary. This is offsetting losses against other income, and it's the logic by which tax withheld from your salary comes back. However, the part of the deficit corresponding to interest on money borrowed to buy the land can't be offset.

Let's do it in numbers. The assumptions are these. Rental income of ¥960,000 a year. ¥240,000 a year for the management fee and repair reserve fund, ¥80,000 a year for fixed asset tax and the like, depreciation expense of ¥700,000 a year, and loan interest of ¥250,000 a year, of which ¥50,000 is for the land. Total expenses are ¥1.27 million, and real estate income is a deficit of ¥310,000. The ¥50,000 of interest for the land can't be offset, so what can be offset against salary is ¥260,000. For someone whose combined income tax and resident tax rate is 30%, the tax that comes back is ¥78,000 a year.

Now let's look inside the wallet. Assuming loan repayments of ¥1 million a year in principal and interest, from the ¥960,000 of rent you pay ¥320,000 for the management fee and taxes and ¥1 million in repayments, so ¥360,000 a year out of pocket. The ¥700,000 of depreciation is an expense with no cash going out, so the deficit on the books and the actual out-of-pocket amount are different things. In other words, to reduce taxes by ¥78,000, you're paying ¥360,000 every year.

One more. The amount you expensed through depreciation is subtracted from the building's acquisition cost when you sell. As the price on the books goes down, the gain on sale comes out larger. The tax you reduced now is likely to come back when you sell. What's called tax saving is, in many cases, really "paying the tax later."

To be fair, if you're someone with a high tax rate on your salary and the tax rate when you sell is lower, that difference is a real gain. For long-term capital gains, income tax and resident tax combined are in the 20% range. But whether it's worth taking on the yearly out-of-pocket costs and the loan risk to go after that difference is a separate calculation.

Conclusion. Tax saving isn't a reason to buy a property; it's a bonus after you buy. A proposal that makes the bonus the star is the same as confessing that the main cash flow is in the red.

Looking only at the tax receipt and not at the wallet's balance. As household bookkeeping goes, that's the one way you must never keep the books.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. When the talk turns to tax saving, people suddenly loosen their purse strings. To cut ¥10,000 off their taxes, they won't hesitate to spend ¥100,000.

I'm in no position to talk. Once I went all the way to a liquor shop in the next town to buy sake cheaply, and the train fare cost more. I was so happy about buying it cheap that I bought 1 more bottle on the way home, so I no longer know how much I lost in the end.

People have always been like that. When the feeling of not wanting to pay is too strong, the amount they spend becomes bigger than the amount they'd pay.

Back to the point. A deficit in real estate income can be offset against salary. That brings back the tax withheld from your salary. As a mechanism, it's real. It's not a lie.

But what concerns me is who brings you this story. "It saves on taxes" is the seller's stock phrase. And the person this story hits hardest is someone in the year their annual income went up.

The year your annual income goes up is the year taxes feel heaviest, and also the year you feel most generous. The story comes right when both line up. It's well made.

One more thing. When you sell someday, the buyer doesn't inherit your tax rate. What the buyer looks at is only the rent and the price. The tax-saving gain is yours alone, and it isn't reflected in the property's price. When buying, you swallow the price feeling it "includes tax savings," and when selling, you sell at the bare price.

So there's only 1 thing to test. Erase all the talk about taxes: would you still buy this unit?

If you have a reason to buy based on rent and price alone, take the tax saving as a bonus. If no reason to buy is left once you erase the tax talk, then you're not buying real estate. You're buying your irritation at taxes.

There is a way of drinking sake while licking salt. But that way of drinking only works because the sake is good. Tax saving is the salt. The sake that matters is the rent.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! This is exactly the one where I thought "it's a good idea!" and went ahead and bought.

In the year my salary went up a little, I got a phone call at work. When I met him, he was a really smooth talker, and said, "The more your annual income has gone up, the more tax you can get back." The explanation was that if I bought a newly built studio unit, a deficit would appear on the books and tax withheld from my salary would come back. He also said I didn't need a down payment, and that was the deciding factor!

What I bought was a newly built studio unit for ¥25 million. Fully financed by a loan, 2% interest, 35 years. Rent of ¥85,000 a month.

Then, the tax return for year 1.

On the books, against ¥1.02 million of rent, the expenses — loan interest, management fee, fees to the property management company, fixed asset tax and depreciation — came to about ¥1.2 million, a deficit of about ¥180,000. Up to this point, it was just as explained!

But it turned out that not all of that deficit could be offset against my salary. The part corresponding to interest on money borrowed to buy the land can't be offset, under the rules. In my case, that was about ¥100,000, and what could be offset against my salary was about ¥80,000. With a 30% tax rate, what came back was about ¥24,000.

Meanwhile, what about the bankbook? The loan repayment was about ¥83,000 a month, plus I pay the management fee and fixed asset tax, so even with the rent coming in, about ¥240,000 went out in a year. That's about ¥20,000 a month.

I was paying ¥240,000 to get back ¥24,000!

The salesperson said "it saves on taxes," and that itself wasn't a lie. Tax really did come back. What I didn't ask was "how much comes back, and how much goes out."

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • When someone says "it saves on taxes," ask how many yen come back.
  • Write the amount that comes back and the amount that goes out every year on the same sheet of paper, side by side.
  • Remember that the deficit on the books and the money going out of the bankbook are different things.

By the way, I still own that unit, and it properly has a tenant too. Though it feels like I'm paying ¥20,000 every month to cover the rest of that person's rent!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper