BENERU
Cash flow and yieldsPublished

Is a property with a high gross yield a buy?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Gross yield is a catalog spec. It's not a measured value.

Gross yield is the annual rent assuming full occupancy divided by the purchase price. The price in the denominator is fixed by the contract. The rent in the numerator is an assumption: "this is what it'd be if fully occupied." First, get it into your head that it's an indicator that divides a fixed number back by a hope.

Let's do a concrete example. Say there are two properties, both ¥50 million. A brings in ¥5 million a year when full, so its gross yield is 10%. B brings in ¥4 million a year when full, so 8%. Looking only at gross, A wins.

Now assume A has a 20% vacancy rate and expenses of 30% of actual income. Picture an old building that costs money for both repairs and finding tenants. Assume B has a 5% vacancy rate and a 15% expense ratio. A's cash left over is ¥5 million × 0.8 × 0.7, which is ¥2.8 million. Divided by the price, 5.6%. B is ¥4 million × 0.95 × 0.85, which is ¥3.23 million. 6.46%. The ranking flips.

Of course these are assumed numbers. But that gross yield is a number that looks at nothing about vacancies or expenses isn't an assumption; it's a matter of definition.

And one more bug. A high gross yield means the price is cheap relative to the rent, right? When something is cheap in the market, there's often a reason. Building age, location, a backlog of repairs. A high yield might not be a reward but a price tag the market put on risk. If you can't explain the reason for that price tag yourself, the buyer side doesn't have enough information.

Think about the exit with the same yardstick. A property bought at a high yield, if the next buyer also prices it by yield, can only be sold at a high yield too, that is, at a low price. What you thought you gained at the entrance may come back to you at the exit.

By the way, in MLIT's sublease guidelines too, yield displays where you can't tell whether it's gross or net, and ads that show a gross yield without saying there are expenses, are listed as examples of problematic displays. Material that makes only the gross yield look big deserves an extra level of suspicion for that alone.

Conclusion. A high gross yield isn't a reason to buy. It's a reason to investigate. What you should look at is the number after subtracting vacancies and expenses. And whether you can check that number's assumptions yourself.

You don't know the real specs until you open the settings screen all the way to the back. Don't decide on the first line of the catalog.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Let me answer this one. Because I bought one. A property with an 18% gross yield.

Sorting a property site by "highest yield first" is fun, right! I love looking from number 1 in the ranking down. That's where I found a studio unit nearly 40 years old, reached by bus from a regional station. The price was ¥3 million and the rent ¥45,000 a month. That's ¥540,000 a year, so the gross yield was 18%.

The person in charge told me, "It's normal for old properties in regional areas to have high yields," and I went, I see! ¥3 million, I can buy it with cash. So I went and bought it.

So, what happened?

Six months after I bought it, the tenant moved out. It took 5 months until the next person was found. In the meantime, ¥250,000 to fix up the unit, and an advertising fee of 2 months' rent, ¥90,000, to have the next tenant found.

Let me calculate year 1. Rent came in for 7 months, ¥315,000. What went out was the management fee and repair reserve fund of ¥180,000 a year, fixed asset tax of ¥40,000, plus the ¥250,000 for repairs and the ¥90,000 advertising fee, for a total of ¥560,000. Net, a loss of ¥245,000. It was supposed to be 18%, and year 1 was negative!

By the way, even if it had been occupied the whole year, ¥540,000 minus ¥180,000 and ¥40,000 is ¥320,000. Divided by ¥3 million, that's 10.7%. Not a bad number, but quite different from 18%. That's when I first understood in my bones that gross yield is just the full-occupancy rent divided by the price, and doesn't include management fees, taxes or vacancies.

And when the tenant left, I noticed there weren't that many people who wanted to rent this unit. Far from the station, old, and quite a few empty units around it too. The price being low and the yield high had a proper reason.

Maybe a ranking by highest yield is lined up from the top in order of "properties that have a reason to be cheap."

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • When you see a gross yield, work out the number yourself after subtracting the management fee, repair reserve fund and fixed asset tax.
  • First, look up yourself "if the tenant leaves, how many months until the next one is found?" Even just looking at the number of empty units around makes a difference.
  • Have the cost of fixing up the unit and the advertising fee ready in advance, for one round.

I still own that unit. Right now there's a tenant and the rent is coming in properly. So 18% wasn't a lie. Only in the months it's full!

Read a little deeper