BENERU
Management and operationPublished

Does a sublease eliminate vacancy risk?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It doesn't go away. The vacancy risk hasn't disappeared. You've just put a price on it and left it with a company. And that price sits in a contract that can be rewritten later.

Start with the mechanism. A sublease is a setup where the company rents the whole property and sublets it to tenants, right? The Act on Land and Building Leases also applies to the contract between the owner and the company, so the company can request a rent reduction regardless of the contract's terms. Even if there's a clause saying "no reduction for a certain period," that doesn't change under an ordinary lease. The only exception is a fixed-term building lease with a special clause saying there will be no reduction.

But it's not as if they can reduce it for any reason. A reduction can be requested when burdens such as taxes change, when economic conditions change, or when the rent has become unreasonable compared with the rents of similar properties nearby. More vacancies, or the company's business struggling, aren't grounds on their own. And even if a request is made, the owner doesn't have to accept it. You negotiate, and if it can't be settled, it ultimately goes to court.

Even so, there's a structural loophole here. If the reason vacancies increased is "the local rent market went down," that rides straight onto the third condition. Vacancy risk comes back in a different shape, as rent-reduction risk.

Let's look at numbers. For a property that brings in ¥6 million a year when fully occupied, assume a master lease rate of 85%; what you receive is ¥5.1 million a year. The ¥900,000 difference is the fee for leaving vacancy risk with the company. Converted to a vacancy rate, that's 15%. If you'd rent it out yourself and keep the vacancy rate below that, then before even thinking about management fees, the math says you're buying overpriced insurance.

Also, behind the word "guarantee" there are three holes. Some contracts set exemption periods when rent isn't paid, such as the first few months of a new building or the advertising period after a tenant leaves. Some contracts make the owner bear costs such as major repairs. And there are contracts where the company can cancel during the term, while for the owner to refuse renewal requires just cause. The one holding the key to the exit is the company.

So, who is the structure built to benefit? It's common for sublease companies to team up with construction or sales companies to solicit, and that's why the law treats those companies as "solicitors" too and prohibits exaggerated advertising and improper solicitation. There's even a rule that if you write "rent guarantee," you have to write right next to it that reductions can happen. The fact that the rules are this detailed is itself the result of a flood of disputes.

Conclusion. A sublease isn't a mechanism that erases vacancy risk. It's a mechanism that exchanges vacancy risk for rent-reduction risk and cancellation risk. Look at the exchange rate and the fee, and if you still want it, sign.

Finally. When you read the contract, before the rent amount, read the clauses on reductions, cancellation and exemptions. The amount changes later, but how it changes is all written in the clauses.

You thought you were renting out the roof, but the leak repairs are on you. Check before you sign that the contract isn't like that.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I really get this question. I once thought exactly the same thing.

When I was just starting out, I went to an information session for a new apartment building. The person in charge was really pleasant, and told me, "We'll lease the whole building for 30 years. Even if there are vacancies, we'll pay the rent." At that moment I was truly relieved! If the worry about vacancies goes away, there's no better deal than this, I thought. On the train home, I already felt like an owner.

But as I read the draft contract I took home, that relief slowly deflated.

The first thing was that it said the rent could be reviewed. I found out later that even with a sublease, the Act on Land and Building Leases applies to the contract between the owner and the company. Under an ordinary lease, the company can ask for a rent reduction when, for example, the surrounding rent market goes down. "A 30-year master lease" didn't mean the same rent for 30 years.

The second was that there was an "exemption period" where no rent comes in for the first few months.

The third was that it was written so the company side could cancel partway through.

I don't remember hearing any of these at the session. Well, maybe they did say them. Maybe I was just relieved by the words "master lease" and "rent guarantee" and didn't listen properly after that. ...Probably that one!

Now, under the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's guidelines, if you advertise a "rent guarantee," you have to write right nearby that the rent may be reduced. I think the fact that the rules go that far means there were lots of people like me who were relieved by the words alone.

In the end, I didn't sign that time. Not because I made some admirable decision, just because I didn't have enough for the down payment!

So my answer to this question is "the worry about vacancies didn't go away." It had changed shape into a worry about the rent going down and a worry about the contract being cut off.

There are three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • The very moment you feel relieved by the explanation is when to take the contract home.
  • Before the rent amount, underline the places that talk about reductions, cancellation and exemptions.
  • Ask the person in charge, "Have you ever lowered the rent before?" If they seem to find it hard to answer, that's an answer too.

The person in charge really was a nice person. I still don't doubt that. But whether a contract a nice person recommends is a good contract for me was a separate matter.

Read a little deeper