Vacancy is not a risk
Is vacancy really a risk? We separate costs that can be expected to occur from swings that cannot be read precisely, and think about how to reflect each in the income and expense plan of a real estate investment.

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.
Good day.
When you listen to explanations of income properties, there are words that always come up.
Vacancy risk. Repair risk. Interest rate rise risk.
All of them are important topics. But there is something a little off about the way they are lined up.
Because among them are things that are not risks.
Here, I use the word risk to mean "something that may or may not happen."
Then what about vacancy?
A property held for 20 years without a single move-out is a little hard to imagine. Tenants leave someday. Whether it takes 1 month or 2 until the next one is found, I cannot tell, but we know that vacancy itself will happen.
Repairs are the same. Water heaters break, and exterior walls deteriorate. You cannot tell when, but they do not stay unbroken forever.
Something you know will happen is not a risk but a cost.
If it is a cost, you can subtract it in advance.
Separating them changes how you handle them
What is good about separating them here?
The way you deal with each is different.
Costs are estimated and built in. From annual rental income, 5% for vacancy and arrears, so many tens of thousands of yen for operating expenses. If you calculate it that way from the start, the plan does not fall apart even when a vacancy actually occurs. It is within expectations.
Risks, on the other hand, cannot be built in. You cannot put a precise number on something you do not know, so instead you look at it as a range.
If the vacancy rate you assumed becomes 15% instead of 5%, what happens to income and expenses? If interest rates rise by 1 percentage point, how much more is the repayment? If both happen at the same time, how much a year goes out of your own pocket?
Whether you can withstand this range is your preparation for risk.
Costs are subtraction; risks are checking the swing. They are different tasks.
If you are told "there is vacancy risk" and it ends with "I see," you feel as though both have been dealt with together. In reality, nothing has been done about either yet.
Still, is it just a matter of words?
You may have thought this: isn't it just a question of what you call it?
Half of it is. Even if you call it vacancy risk, there is no problem as long as it is properly built in.
But when the words are sloppy, the calculation is usually sloppy too.
The word risk carries the nuance of "it might not happen." So you unconsciously estimate it small. If you treat vacancy as "something that might not happen," the figures assuming full occupancy become the foundation of the plan as they are.
If you treat it as a cost, you cannot avoid subtracting it.
Just changing what you call it adds one subtraction. That is all it is, but that one subtraction changes the numbers quite a lot.
There are 2 things to check.
Is that "risk" something you know will happen, or something you do not know?
If it is something you know, at what amount did you build it in? If it is something you do not know, how far can it swing before you can no longer withstand it?
When I take the train from Shinagawa, it is usually a few minutes late somewhere every morning.
I am used to it by now, so I leave home 5 minutes early. Not because the delay is a risk. I know it will happen, so I simply add it from the start.
What causes trouble is the other kind. A few times a year, an accident involving a person stops the trains for 40 minutes. That is not something you can add to your schedule in advance.
The 5 minutes each morning can be built into the time it takes to get ready. The 40 minutes cannot, so on that day you can only give up or think of another way.
Both are "being late," but they are different things.


