BENERU
Cash flow and yieldsPublished

Which expenses should I include when calculating net yield?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Answer first. Include all the money it costs to own and operate the property. What you don't include is loan repayments and depreciation. Mix these in and the numbers get buggy.

First, the premise. Net yield has no unified definition. From one document to the next, what was subtracted and what it was divided by are all over the place. So don't trust a net yield someone else worked out until you've seen the formula. When you work it out yourself, use the same formula every time.

The expenses to include are roughly these. The management fee paid to the property management company, fixed asset tax and city planning tax, repair costs and restoration costs (when tenants leave), insurance premiums such as fire insurance, electricity and cleaning costs for the common areas, and the advertising fee for recruiting tenants. For a condominium unit, the management fee and repair reserve fund paid to the owners' association are included too.

What not to include. Loan repayments aren't the property's earning power; they're a matter of how you borrowed. Depreciation is an expense for tax calculation, and no money goes out. These 2 aren't about yield; they're about the cash flow of the cash left over. Do that as a separate calculation.

Taxes, a little more carefully. Fixed asset tax has a standard rate of 1.4% of the assessed value, and city planning tax is capped at 0.3%. They can differ by municipality, so in practice check your tax statement. Land with a house on it has a special provision: for small-scale residential land up to 200 m², fixed asset tax is calculated on 1/6 of the assessed value, and city planning tax on 1/3.

Let's try it in numbers. A ¥50 million whole apartment building, ¥5 million a year at full occupancy, 10% gross. Assume a 10% vacancy rate, so actual rental income is ¥4.5 million. Assume the management fee and repair costs are each 5% of income: ¥225,000 each. Assume the land's assessed value of ¥15 million is all small-scale residential land, the building's assessed value is ¥12 million, and the tax rates are standard: fixed asset tax and city planning tax come to ¥254,000. Also put in, as assumptions, ¥100,000 for insurance, ¥60,000 for utilities in the common areas, and ¥150,000 for recruiting costs. Expenses total ¥1.014 million, and the cash left over is ¥3.486 million. Divided by the price, about 6.97%. A gross 10% shrinks this far.

One more. The number also changes depending on whether the denominator is the purchase price or the total including acquisition costs such as brokerage commission and registration costs. With acquisition costs of ¥3.5 million, dividing by ¥53.5 million gives about 6.52%. It's not about which one is correct. Keep it consistent between the properties you're comparing.

Finally. Make every expense figure something you can check yourself. The management fee from the contract, taxes from the tax statement, insurance from the quote. Using the expense ratio the seller gave you as is, is like describing your own machine with someone else's benchmark.

Conclusion. Include all the money it costs to operate; don't include the loan and depreciation. Fix the formula and measure with the same yardstick every time. Only when you can do that does yield become a number you can use for comparison.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Let me tell you about me relying completely on a handy app.

Around when I started looking for properties, I installed a free yield calculator app. You enter the purchase price, the rent and the management fee, and it instantly gives you the gross yield and the net yield. Its review stars were really high too, and I thought that as long as I had this, I'd be fine!

I tried it on a certain second-hand studio unit. Price ¥18 million, acquisition costs of ¥1 million when buying, rent ¥90,000 a month, ¥1.08 million a year. The management fee and repair reserve fund were ¥15,000 a month, ¥180,000 a year.

The net yield the app gave was 4.74%. That's the ¥900,000 of rent minus the management fee, divided by ¥19 million, the price plus acquisition costs. It was lower than the 6% gross yield, but since it said "net," I thought this was the real number.

But later I noticed. That app had a field for the management fee, but no field for fixed asset tax, no field for vacancies, and no field for the fee paid to the property management company. Things with no field to enter them can't possibly be in the calculation, right?

I added them myself. Fixed asset tax of ¥60,000 a year. If a tenant moves out and it's vacant for 1 month, ¥90,000 of rent doesn't come in. The fee to the property management company is 5% of rent, ¥54,000 a year. Subtracting all of this, the cash left over is ¥696,000, and the yield is 3.66%.

It was more than 1 percentage point different from the app's 4.74%!

The app wasn't wrong. It was just properly calculating its own version of "net." I was the one who read the word "net" on my own as "the real number with everything subtracted."

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • When you see a "net yield," check what's been subtracted.
  • Assume expenses that have no input field aren't in the calculation.
  • Add fixed asset tax, vacancies and the property management company's fee yourself.

I still use that app. It really is handy! But now I write a note next to the number it gives: "fixed asset tax and vacancies not yet included."

Read a little deeper