BENERU
TaxesPublished Updated

When I sell an investment property, how is the tax calculated?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. The tax when you sell an investment property is calculated separately from salary and other income (separate taxation). What drives the tax amount are three points: the calculation of the acquisition cost, the holding period, and the treatment of a loss on the transfer.

Formula

Capital gains (transfer income) = sale amount − (acquisition cost + transfer costs)

  • Acquisition cost: the purchase price, purchase commission, equipment costs, improvement costs and so on. For the building, it is the amount after subtracting the equivalent of the depreciation over the holding period.
  • Transfer costs: brokerage commission, stamp duty on the sale contract, eviction payments made to tenants when selling, building demolition costs and so on.
  • If the acquisition cost is unknown, or if the actual acquisition cost is less than 5% of the sale amount, 5% of the sale amount can be used as the acquisition cost.

A point easily overlooked: depreciation

Depreciation expensed while renting is subtracted from the building's acquisition cost when you sell. Because the building's value on the books has gone down, capital gains become larger by that amount.

Here is an example. All the numbers are assumptions.

  • Purchased with the building at ¥20 million and the land at ¥10 million
  • Accumulated depreciation up to the sale is ¥8 million
  • Sold for ¥30 million, with transfer costs of ¥1 million

The acquisition cost is (¥20 million − ¥8 million) + ¥10 million = ¥22 million. Capital gains are ¥30 million − ¥22 million − ¥1 million = ¥7 million. Even if you sell for the same price you bought at, there are ¥7 million of capital gains.

Tax rates

The holding period is determined as of January 1 of the year of sale.

Holding periodTax rateTax for the example above
More than 5 years (long-term)20.315%about ¥1.422 million
5 years or less (short-term)39.63%about ¥2.774 million

If there is a loss

A loss on the transfer of land or buildings can be offset against capital gains on other land or buildings. A loss that still cannot be fully offset cannot be offset against salary income or other income.

For a loss on the transfer of your own home, there is a special provision that allows offsetting against salary income and other income under certain requirements. However, it covers residential property and cannot be used for investment properties.

Order of checks

  1. In the contract at purchase, check the breakdown of the values of the building and the land.
  2. From each year's tax return, work out the accumulated depreciation.
  3. Check the holding period as of January 1 of the year of sale.
  4. Estimate the transfer costs.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think considering a sale should start not from the expected sale price but from the calculation of the acquisition cost. If you look only at the sale price while forgetting that depreciation has lowered the acquisition cost, you will misjudge the expected take-home amount.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "What is this?" — that was my first thought. You sell at the price you bought for, and there's tax. You didn't lose anything, and it's treated as profit. It's a system that makes you go "wow" out loud.

The general point is just as stated. Depreciation expensed while renting gets subtracted from the building's acquisition cost when you sell. On the books, the building has become cheaper, so capital gains swell by that much. Up to here it's written in tax books too, and anyone buying for investment has heard it at least once.

So why do people do it even knowing that? They know it comes back when they sell, yet every year they're happy that depreciation "saved tax." If it comes back, isn't there no reason to be happy?

So, here's the real point.

What depreciation reduces is income that's added together with salary and so on. That's progressive taxation: income tax has brackets from 5% to 45%, and the 10% per-income levy of resident tax goes on top. On the other hand, the capital gains that swell when you sell are taxed separately, and if you've held it more than 5 years as of January 1 of the year of sale, it's 20.315%. In other words, depreciation isn't a magic trick that erases tax. It's a system that moves income from a high-tax-rate wallet to a low-tax-rate wallet. Don't get it? I'll do it in numbers.

All assumptions. Say you depreciate ¥600,000 a year, ¥6 million over 10 years. For someone with a 23% income tax rate, including the 2.1% surcharge on income tax that's about 23.48%, and about 33.48% together with resident tax. The tax erased by ¥6 million is about ¥2.009 million. If there's a profit on the sale, the swollen ¥6 million is taxed at the long-term 20.315%, about ¥1.219 million. The difference, about ¥790,000, stays in hand. That's the reason people do it knowingly, right?

But it's not fair without looking at the other side too. For someone with a 5% income tax rate, it's about 15.11% together with resident tax. The tax erased is about ¥906,000, and the roughly ¥1.219 million at sale is bigger. You end up paying about ¥313,000 more. And if you sell within 5 years or less, it's the short-term 39.63%. If you depreciated ¥2.4 million over 4 years and sold, even for someone with a 23% rate, against the roughly ¥804,000 erased, the tax at sale is about ¥951,000. Hold on a sec, right?

So with the tax when you sell an investment property, calculating only the year of sale shows you just half. At what tax rate did you use depreciation while you held it? Only when you line that up next to it is it decided whether you gained or lost. Someone with a high tax rate selling after more than 5 years — that's the combination where it works best. For people with low tax rates or who sell short-term, depreciation is closer to a bill that was pushed back. Which side are you on?

You know the mandarins on the kotatsu — if you eat the sweet ones first, only the sour ones are left at the end. Depreciation too: for every sweet one you ate first each year, the sour ones come around all together in the year you sell. What? You like sour ones, so it's fine? Oh, really. Then count down to the bottom of the box before you eat.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper