BENERU
TaxesPublished Updated

If I make a profit selling my home, is it taxed?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. For your own home, there's a system that lets you get away without it. But "not taxed" and "don't have to do anything" are different stories.

First, the shape of the calculation. The gain on sale is the sale price minus the acquisition cost and transfer costs. The acquisition cost is based on the price you bought at, but for the building part, the amount corresponding to depreciation expense over the period you owned it is subtracted. Even for your own home. Transfer costs include things like the brokerage commission. If you don't know what you bought it for, you can use 5% of the sale price as the acquisition cost, but 5% is pretty small, so don't throw away the contract from the purchase.

Let's look at numbers. Say you bought for ¥50 million, and assume the amount corresponding to the building's depreciation is ¥6 million. The acquisition cost is ¥44 million. Sell for ¥60 million, take the brokerage commission at the upper limit of ¥2.046 million, and the gain on sale is ¥13.954 million. You sold for ¥10 million more than you bought, yet the profit on paper is bigger than that. The depreciation part is doing the work.

Here's the special rule for your own home. If you sell the house you live in, you can deduct up to ¥30 million from the gain on sale regardless of the ownership period. In this example, the taxable capital gains become zero.

But step outside the conditions and things change. A house you lived in just to get the special rule, temporary housing, or a vacation home doesn't qualify. It also can't be used if you sell to someone with a special relationship, like a parent and child or a married couple. And this is important. To use the special rule, you need to file a tax return. Even if the result is zero, it doesn't become zero by staying quiet.

What if you can't use the special rule? If you held it for over 5 years as of January 1 of the year of sale, it's long-term: income tax 15% and resident tax 5%, plus the special reconstruction income tax of 2.1% of the income tax. That's 20.315% combined, about ¥2.835 million in the earlier example. If 5 years or less, it's short-term: income tax 30% and resident tax 9% plus the special reconstruction income tax, 39.63%, about ¥5.53 million. Just the number of years you owned it makes nearly a twofold difference.

So, the easiest landmine to step on. When you move from one home to another. If you used the ¥30 million special rule in the year you moved into the new home, the year before, or the year before that, you can't get the mortgage tax deduction on the new home. The same goes if you sell the old house and use the special rule between the year after you moved in and year 3. You can think you've erased the tax on the sale and end up losing the new home's deduction entirely. Which is better depends on the amounts, so line up both numbers before choosing.

Conclusion. Even if you make a profit selling your home, if it fits within the ¥30 million special rule, the capital gains aren't taxed. But you need to file, and if you're moving to another home, it collides with the mortgage tax deduction. The more it looks like zero tax, the more you should check the wiring.

Even if the receipt says ¥0, it still has to go through the register. Tax works that way too.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Whether you're taxed if you make a profit selling a home, you'd want to know, right? I once nodded along to that "it shouldn't be taxed" and knocked over a whole plan.

What I own is a second-hand studio unit. A unit I bought in my late 20s to rent out to people. A few years ago, when I was looking for a home to live in myself, someone at work said at lunch, "Even if you sell a house, it's zero tax up to ¥30 million." I nodded, "Huh!" I could put the money from selling the studio entirely into the down payment on a new home. I decided that, started preparing to put it up for sale, and even made a funding plan for the second-hand condominium I wanted to live in!

Then someone who wanted to buy appeared, and around the time we were talking about arranging the contract, I opened the National Tax Agency's page just in case, and it said the special rule applies to "a house you currently live in." My glasses were old, so I took them off, wiped them, put them back on and read it again. The words didn't change! I had never lived in that studio for a single day. It wasn't my home.

On top of that, my profit calculation was sloppy too. The acquisition cost isn't just the price I paid; for the building, the depreciation is subtracted. While I was renting it out, I'd been taking depreciation as an expense every year, so the acquisition cost had become smaller by that much. Say I bought it for ¥15 million, the accumulated depreciation is ¥2.5 million, and I sell for ¥17 million (it's an assumption). The brokerage commission at the upper limit is ¥627,000. The profit is ¥17 million − ¥12.5 million − ¥627,000 = ¥3.873 million. I'd held it for over 5 years, so the tax rate is 20.315%, and the tax is about ¥787,000. Where I'd assumed zero, a hole of about ¥787,000 opened up!

The down payment plan collapsed on that hole, and I passed on the second-hand condominium I wanted to live in. I also stopped selling the studio, and I'm still renting it out.

What the person at work said wasn't wrong as a story about a house you live in. It was me who nodded without checking whether my studio counted as that "house." The funding plan I built on the premise of zero was wrong from the first line.

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • When you hear "zero tax," first check which house it's talking about. A unit you've never lived in isn't your home
  • For a unit where you've taken depreciation as an expense, a profit can arise even if you sell at the price you bought. Work out the acquisition cost yourself before selling
  • Plan how to use the sale money on the take-home amount after tax

By the way, I still use the glasses I wiped that time. If the words don't change no matter how many times you wipe, then the one who has to change is me, the reader!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper