This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. As a rule, you cannot use both for the same replacement purchase. You choose one or the other.
What cannot be combined
According to the National Tax Agency's explanation, to receive the home loan deduction (special deduction for housing loans and similar), it is a requirement that you have not received the following special provisions in the year you moved into the new home and the 2 years before and 3 years after it, a total of 6 years (for transfers on or after April 1, 2020 (Reiwa 2)).
- Special deduction from capital gains on residential property (the so-called ¥30 million special deduction)
- Special provision for taxation of long-term capital gains on the transfer of residential property (the so-called reduced tax rate provision)
- Special provision for replacement of specified residential property, and others
If you sell your old home and use the ¥30 million special deduction, and move into a new home during the period before or after it, you cannot receive the home loan deduction for the new home. Conversely, if you choose the home loan deduction, you cannot use not only the ¥30 million special deduction but also the reduced tax rate provision. The latter is a point that is easily overlooked.
Note that the ¥30 million special deduction does not apply unless you file a tax return.
What to compare
What you compare is "the tax reduced on the sale side" and "the total tax returned by the home loan deduction."
The sale side. The tax rate on the gain from the transfer changes with the holding period. The holding period is determined as of January 1 of the year of sale.
| Holding period | Tax rate | Breakdown |
|---|---|---|
| More than 5 years (long-term) | 20.315% | Income tax 15%, special reconstruction income tax 0.315%, resident tax 5% |
| 5 years or less (short-term) | 39.63% | Income tax 30%, special reconstruction income tax 0.63%, resident tax 9% |
As an example, take a gain of ¥30 million on the transfer. If you use the ¥30 million special deduction, the tax is ¥0. If you don't, it is ¥6.0945 million long-term and ¥11.889 million short-term.
The purchase side. If you move into a newly built or similar home in 2026 (Reiwa 8), the deduction rate is 0.7% of the year-end balance and so on, and the deduction period is 13 years as a rule. The annual deduction limit differs by the category of home.
| Category of home | Annual deduction limit | Total limit over 13 years |
|---|---|---|
| Certified long-life quality housing / certified low-carbon housing | ¥315,000 | ¥4.095 million |
| ZEH-level energy-efficient housing | ¥245,000 | ¥3.185 million |
| Housing meeting energy efficiency standards | ¥140,000 | ¥1.82 million |
The total limit over 13 years is the upper limit when all conditions are met. In practice the loan balance goes down, so the deduction gets smaller each year. Also, the deduction is only within the income tax and resident tax you paid (with a limit on resident tax).
The dividing line
Dividing the total limit back by the tax rate on the gain gives the dividing line. Calculating with the ¥4.095 million for certified long-life quality housing, the ¥30 million special deduction gives a smaller tax once the gain on the transfer exceeds about ¥20.16 million for a long-term transfer, or about ¥10.33 million for a short-term transfer.
The conditions behind these numbers are as follows.
- It is a calculation for when the home loan deduction could be used up to the limit for 13 years. If it cannot be used up to the limit, the dividing line is lower.
- They are numbers for newly built and similar homes. Second-hand homes have a different deduction period and limit, so this calculation cannot be used as is.
- They are numbers for moving in during 2026 (Reiwa 8). If the year of moving in changes, the limit changes too.
Order of checks
- Work out the gain on the transfer of the old home. For the building portion, the acquisition cost is calculated by subtracting the amount equivalent to depreciation over the period you lived there.
- Determine the holding period as of January 1 of the year of sale.
- From the category of the new home and the year of moving in, check the annual limit of the home loan deduction.
- From the amount of your income tax and resident tax, check how much can be fully deducted each year.
From here on, this is my opinion
Which to choose is decided by the combination of the year of sale and the year of moving in. I think calculating after deciding the timing of the sale and the purchase is too late. Please finish this comparison before deciding the timing.
Sources (in Japanese)
- 国税庁「No.3302 マイホームを売ったときの特例」(checked 2026-10-09)
- 国税庁「No.1211-1 住宅の新築等をし、令和4年以降に居住の用に供した場合(住宅借入金等特別控除)」(checked 2026-10-09)
- 国税庁「No.3208 長期譲渡所得の税額の計算」(checked 2026-10-09)
- 国税庁「No.3211 短期譲渡所得の税額の計算」(checked 2026-10-09)
- 国税庁「No.3202 譲渡所得の計算のしかた(分離課税)」(checked 2026-10-09)