BENERU
TaxesPublished Updated

When buying a replacement home, should I choose the ¥30 million deduction or the home loan deduction?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. As a rule, you cannot use both for the same replacement purchase. You choose one or the other.

What cannot be combined

According to the National Tax Agency's explanation, to receive the home loan deduction (special deduction for housing loans and similar), it is a requirement that you have not received the following special provisions in the year you moved into the new home and the 2 years before and 3 years after it, a total of 6 years (for transfers on or after April 1, 2020 (Reiwa 2)).

  • Special deduction from capital gains on residential property (the so-called ¥30 million special deduction)
  • Special provision for taxation of long-term capital gains on the transfer of residential property (the so-called reduced tax rate provision)
  • Special provision for replacement of specified residential property, and others

If you sell your old home and use the ¥30 million special deduction, and move into a new home during the period before or after it, you cannot receive the home loan deduction for the new home. Conversely, if you choose the home loan deduction, you cannot use not only the ¥30 million special deduction but also the reduced tax rate provision. The latter is a point that is easily overlooked.

Note that the ¥30 million special deduction does not apply unless you file a tax return.

What to compare

What you compare is "the tax reduced on the sale side" and "the total tax returned by the home loan deduction."

The sale side. The tax rate on the gain from the transfer changes with the holding period. The holding period is determined as of January 1 of the year of sale.

Holding periodTax rateBreakdown
More than 5 years (long-term)20.315%Income tax 15%, special reconstruction income tax 0.315%, resident tax 5%
5 years or less (short-term)39.63%Income tax 30%, special reconstruction income tax 0.63%, resident tax 9%

As an example, take a gain of ¥30 million on the transfer. If you use the ¥30 million special deduction, the tax is ¥0. If you don't, it is ¥6.0945 million long-term and ¥11.889 million short-term.

The purchase side. If you move into a newly built or similar home in 2026 (Reiwa 8), the deduction rate is 0.7% of the year-end balance and so on, and the deduction period is 13 years as a rule. The annual deduction limit differs by the category of home.

Category of homeAnnual deduction limitTotal limit over 13 years
Certified long-life quality housing / certified low-carbon housing¥315,000¥4.095 million
ZEH-level energy-efficient housing¥245,000¥3.185 million
Housing meeting energy efficiency standards¥140,000¥1.82 million

The total limit over 13 years is the upper limit when all conditions are met. In practice the loan balance goes down, so the deduction gets smaller each year. Also, the deduction is only within the income tax and resident tax you paid (with a limit on resident tax).

The dividing line

Dividing the total limit back by the tax rate on the gain gives the dividing line. Calculating with the ¥4.095 million for certified long-life quality housing, the ¥30 million special deduction gives a smaller tax once the gain on the transfer exceeds about ¥20.16 million for a long-term transfer, or about ¥10.33 million for a short-term transfer.

The conditions behind these numbers are as follows.

  • It is a calculation for when the home loan deduction could be used up to the limit for 13 years. If it cannot be used up to the limit, the dividing line is lower.
  • They are numbers for newly built and similar homes. Second-hand homes have a different deduction period and limit, so this calculation cannot be used as is.
  • They are numbers for moving in during 2026 (Reiwa 8). If the year of moving in changes, the limit changes too.

Order of checks

  1. Work out the gain on the transfer of the old home. For the building portion, the acquisition cost is calculated by subtracting the amount equivalent to depreciation over the period you lived there.
  2. Determine the holding period as of January 1 of the year of sale.
  3. From the category of the new home and the year of moving in, check the annual limit of the home loan deduction.
  4. From the amount of your income tax and resident tax, check how much can be fully deducted each year.

From here on, this is my opinion

Which to choose is decided by the combination of the year of sale and the year of moving in. I think calculating after deciding the timing of the sale and the purchase is too late. Please finish this comparison before deciding the timing.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The fact that you're able to be torn over which to choose means your eye for observation is good. You've properly noticed that you can't take both for the same replacement purchase. But it's still not sharp enough. With this question, before it becomes a choice between two, there's one more fork in the road.

Let me say it first. You only need to choose when you make a profit selling your old home.

Here's why. If you make a loss on the sale, the ¥30 million deduction has no part to play in the first place. Instead, there's a special provision for offsetting and carrying forward a loss on the transfer when you replace your own home, and the National Tax Agency clearly writes that this provision and the home loan deduction "can be used together." There are conditions, like having a home loan with a repayment period of 10 years or more on the new home, but for people who make a loss, the choice between two doesn't exist from the start. Get it? What you look at first isn't the deduction table, it's whether the sale of the old home comes out plus or minus.

So, then. The story of people who make a profit.

The ¥30 million deduction is settled in a single tax return for the year of sale. It's a one-time payment that makes the tax for the year of sale disappear. The home loan deduction is installments over up to 13 years, and every year comes with conditions. That you keep living there until December 31 of that year, and that your total income is ¥20 million or less as a rule. In a year your income goes over, that year's share is skipped. If you stop living there, it stops from that year on. And since you can only deduct up to the tax you paid, in years with little tax, the limit goes unused. Honestly, one is cash in your hand and the other is a promise that runs for 13 years. How about it? Does that add up?

So is the ¥30 million deduction the right answer every time? No, that's wrong too. Look from the other side and it goes like this. Suppose the gain on the transfer is ¥3 million and the holding period is more than 5 years. The tax without using the special provision is about ¥610,000 at 20.315%. Even if the limit is ¥30 million, only about ¥610,000 of tax disappears. On the home loan deduction side, depending on the category of home, the limit is a few hundred thousand yen a year. For someone with a small profit, the size of the number ¥30 million is just appearance. The size of the limit and the tax that actually disappears are two different things.

So what you compare isn't the deduction limits, but amounts that also factor in how likely your current life is to continue for 13 years. Job transfers, ups and downs in income, moves to match your kids going to school. Only you can estimate this, right? It's not in the system's tables.

If the profit is big and you can't read where you'll be living 13 years from now, what's in your hand is stronger. If the profit is small and you intend to put down roots there, the installments are worth going after. That's seriously the dividing line.

Take one in-season Pacific saury now, or sign up for a dried-fish subscription that runs 13 years? The subscription looks like more, but if you move, it stops arriving. Which is better is decided not by the fish but by your address. See you.