BENERU
Selling and exitPublished Updated

Is it dangerous to buy a home on the assumption of selling it in 10 years?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Buying on the assumption of selling" isn't dangerous in itself. Buying without thinking about the exit is far more dangerous. If there's a bug, it's that the assumption is written as a date: "10 years from now."

First, the tax calendar. Tax when you sell real estate isn't judged by how many years have passed since you bought, but by "how many years you had owned it as of January 1 of the year you sold." If it's over 5 years as of January 1, it's long-term; 5 years or less, it's short-term, and the tax is calculated separately. The special reduced tax rate for selling your own home requires over 10 years as of January 1. So if you bought in 2026, it becomes long-term from 2032 onward, and the reduced tax rate can be used from 2037 onward. If you do "buy and sell in 10 years" by the calendar, you fall just short of the reduced tax rate.

That said, it's not fair to scare you too much here. If you sell your own home, there's a special deduction of up to ¥30 million that can be used regardless of the ownership period. If the gain on sale fits within that range, the calendar gap hardly matters. It only matters when the price rose a lot.

Next. A bug that's often overlooked. Do you think "if I sell at the price I bought, the profit is zero"? The acquisition cost of the building, even for your own home, is calculated by subtracting the amount corresponding to depreciation expense over the period you owned it. In other words, even if you sell at the same price you bought, a profit can arise on paper. The assumption that "it's my home, so depreciation has nothing to do with it" breaks here.

And costs. When you sell, there's a brokerage commission. The upper limit, if the sale price exceeds ¥4 million, is sale price × 3% + ¥60,000, plus consumption tax. If you sell for ¥60 million, the upper limit is ¥2.046 million. Together with the acquisition costs when you buy, subtract up front the amount that gets shaved off just by going in and out.

So, fix one point. Rewrite "sell in 10 years" as "the conditions under which it's OK to sell." The condition is that the sale price minus costs exceeds the remaining mortgage balance. If you're ready to move whenever a year that meets this condition comes, you can wait even if year 10 is a bad year.

Conclusion. Buying on the assumption of selling isn't dangerous. Locking it in by date is something I'd call dangerous.

One last thing. Where you'll live after selling is also part of the conditions. There's public material showing that landlords have strong reluctance toward older people living alone. Put the plan for the next place to live into the selling plan as a set.

A machine breaks down less if you stop it with a sensor rather than a timer. Timing a sale is the same: what you watch isn't the calendar, it's the needle on the gauge.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm having warmed Shaoxing wine. It's a wine aged for years in jars, but aging it longer doesn't necessarily make it better. That year's rice, how the brewery did, the condition of the jar. You age it ten years, open it, and sometimes it's not as good as you thought. The talk of aging a house ten years and selling it is somewhat similar, perhaps.

What I remember is the air in the days when land prices kept rising. Around me, everyone said land was something that goes up. But land prices peaked in 1991 (Heisei 3) and fell for 15 years in a row. It was in the 2007 (Heisei 19) Land Price Publication that they turned upward, mainly in urban areas, and in the year after the next, in the 2009 (Heisei 21) Land Price Publication, they fell again across all uses. That's how the City of Yokohama looks back on it in its land price guide. Someone who bought in 1991 (Heisei 3) and sold ten years later sold partway down the slope. For someone who bought in 1997 (Heisei 9), ten years later fell on the year things finally turned up. Even the same "ten years" was completely different depending on which ten years you drew.

Within ten years, not just the market but the tax rules change too. With the 2004 (Heisei 16) revision, the tax rate when you sell land or buildings held for a long time was lowered to 20% including resident tax. That applied to transfers on or after January 1, 2004 (Heisei 16). In the same revision, the path to offsetting losses from selling land or buildings against other income such as salary was closed. For your own home, a new system was created that lets you carry the loss forward to the following years, limited to the amount by which the remaining mortgage exceeds the sale price. The rules you had in mind when you bought are already different rules when you sell. That's how long ten years is.

When I crossed the sea and came to Japan, on the ship I wrote in my notebook a list of what I'd do when I arrived. When I got here, the language and the prices of things were completely different from the notebook, and I couldn't use even half of what I'd written. I didn't throw the notebook away, but I rewrote more than I added.

Back to the main point. I won't say that buying on the assumption of selling in ten years is dangerous in itself. What's dangerous is assuming that the price movements of the last ten years and the tax rules on the day you buy will continue for the next ten years. After ten years of steady rises you think it'll rise, and after ten years of steady falls you think it'll fall. In my view, people have always been like that.

So there's one thing to do before buying. In MLIT's Real Estate Information Library, find the Land Price Publication points near the home you're thinking of buying, and line up their prices for many years. You'll see in numbers how ten years of rises and ten years of falls have alternated on that land.

Nobody can read the next ten years. Because you can't read them, the wine tastes good. To ten years nobody can read, cheers.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper