BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

I have the cash, but is it dangerous to buy a home with a mortgage and invest the money on hand?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. This question has a lot of parts and looks clever, but take it apart and there are only two things inside. "Do I buy a home with a mortgage even though I have the cash?" and "Do I fix the exit at 10 years from now?" Whether it's high-risk is decided almost entirely by the second one.

First, let me debug the premise. That variable 0.3% condition is already a relic of the past. The Bank of Japan's policy rate rose to around 1.25% in September 2026, and even at major banks there are examples of variable rates in the low 1% range. Running a blueprint drawn at 0.3% as-is at today's rates is a stretch.

Let's look at the numbers. If 0.3% becomes 1.0%, the increase in interest is ¥560,000 a year, even calculated with the principal staying at ¥80 million. At 1.2%, close to today's level, it's ¥720,000 a year. Both are rough figures with the principal left unchanged, so in reality they'd be a bit smaller. For comparison, if the money on hand earned 7% a year, that would be ¥5.6 million a year before tax. But 7% is an assumption, not a promised number.

Next. This is the biggest bug. You wrote "invest the cash in NISA," but ¥80 million doesn't fit in NISA. The annual limit is ¥3.6 million and the lifetime tax-free allowance is ¥18 million. Filling it all takes at least 5 years, and the remaining ¥62 million would be held in a taxable account where about 20% is charged on investment gains. "Tax-free investing in NISA" sounds nice, but don't write it into the blueprint without checking how big the allowance is.

So, the crux of the matter. Locking in the sale at 10 years.

There are two reasons. One is the market. A design where you have to sell in a year when real estate and stocks are falling together is the same as building on the premise that something that can happen won't happen. The other is tax. The special reduced tax rate for selling your own home can't be used unless the ownership period exceeds 10 years as of January 1 of the year you sell. If you sell exactly 10 years after acquiring it, you fall short. If you bought in 2026, you can use it from 2037 onward. It can be combined with the ¥30 million special deduction, which can be used regardless of the ownership period, so the larger the gain on sale, the more this one-year gap matters.

You only need to fix one point. Rewrite "sell in 10 years" as "after 10 years, keep the property sellable at any time." Sellable means the property's price is above the remaining loan balance. Choosing near-the-station and recently built is already not a bad line, so the rest is whether you can manage things without breaking your balance sheet.

Also, have a repayment plan for the case where you don't sell. Under the Flat 35 criteria, the maximum loan term is "80 minus your age at application," so at 55 it's 25 years at most, with full repayment at 80. Private mortgages also generally have an upper age limit at full repayment.

If you ask me whether it's high-risk, here's my answer. Fix these two things, the NISA premise and the fixed sale date, and I wouldn't call it high-risk. If you don't fix them, I'd call it high-risk.

One last thing. Where are you going to live after you sell? At 65 you'll be on the side looking for a rental. Even public material shows that landlords have strong reluctance toward older people living alone. If you're making a plan to sell your home, write the next place to live on the same sheet of paper.

You know, you harvest rice because it's ripe, not because of the calendar. If you go to harvest by date, you might hit a year when it's still green.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. I'll give you the answer first. Whether it's high or low isn't decided on paper. What decides it is you, in the year stocks fall 40%, losing 4 tenths of their value.

Well, have a drink and listen.

Let me tell you about 1990. That year, total-volume restrictions were put on lending to the real estate industry, and in August the official discount rate rose to 6.0%. Until a little before that, everyone truly believed that borrowing as much as you could and buying land was the smart way. Money can be borrowed cheaply, assets go up, so borrowing is the better deal. Sounds like a theory you've heard somewhere, doesn't it?

People have always been like that. In an era when cheap money can be borrowed, those who don't borrow look like fools. When an era of rising rates comes, the ones who laughed and the ones who were laughed at trade places.

Going off on a tangent, but with drink and with debt alike, it hits you the next morning. While you're drinking, it's fun. I've been drinking for decades and that's the one thing I never learn. Well, never mind about me.

Back to the main point. Young Rita has written up the NISA allowance and the tax on selling properly. Read that. What I want to talk about is the human side.

This strategy works with normal-times numbers. If the investment return is higher than the borrowing rate, the difference is left over. As arithmetic, it's correct.

But the year it breaks is set. It's the year stocks and homes fall together. 2008 was like that. Triggered by the collapse in home prices in America, stocks all over the world collapsed together.

That year, you have ¥80 million of debt and shrunken stocks on hand. In theory, it's "don't sell, hold on." But people don't move by theory. You stare at the valuation in the middle of the night and sell at the very bottom. More people lose money by abandoning the strategy halfway than lose money because the strategy was wrong. It's the flip side of "get greedy and this is roughly what happens": get scared and this is roughly what happens.

There are two more things.

One is that a 55-year-old with ¥80 million in cash stands out. People with money attract people bringing them proposals. It's always been that way. Money that was supposed to go into investments has, before you know it, flowed into some other "great deal." Exits not written in the strategy have increased without your noticing.

The other. You in 10 years are a different person from you today. Nobody knows whether you at 65 can continue the strategy made at 55 with the same nerve. Body and spirit both change in 10 years.

So you only need to test one thing. Looking at a notice that stocks have fallen 40%, paying the monthly loan, can you still enjoy your drink?

If you can, I won't call this strategy reckless. If you can't, reduce the amount you borrow. You don't have to make it a choice between borrowing it all and betting it all, or paying it all in cash. Borrow half and pay half. Put into investments only an amount you can sleep with even when it falls. If you halve the borrowing, the burden when rates rise is also halved.

Well, you won't die. But not dying and being able to sleep are different matters. Save the toast until you've made it through one falling year.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper