Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The moment you read "at the top" and "the best terms" as meaning the same thing, the design of that screen has already scored a point on you.
No, I get what you mean. It's shown at the very top, so it must be the best, right — that's what people normally think. So let me ask: "the best terms" for whom? For someone borrowing for how many years?
Answer first. What shows up at the top is the loan that came out on top by the yardstick that site decided on. It isn't necessarily the best loan on your terms. What the yardstick is, the site writes somewhere on the screen. If it isn't written, the only thing you learn is that you don't know what order it's in.
Let's sort it out once. There are two blind spots.
One. There's only one yardstick. Even if you sort by lowest interest rate, interest isn't the only thing you pay after you borrow. When a loan whose administrative fee is "a percentage of the loan amount" sits next to one with a "flat" fee, the one ranked higher on rate can come out worse in total, depending on how many years until you finish paying it off (or sell, or refinance). And the rate shown isn't necessarily the same as your rate after you pass screening. The number one on the screen doesn't know your screening result. Get it?
Two. The ordering itself can be built. Folks like me read words by cutting them into pieces, so when it says "recommended," I go looking for the subject. Recommended by whom?
Here, the regulators are looking at the same spot. In the revision to the supervisory guidelines that the Financial Services Agency applied from November 6, 2026, a note was added: a comparison site simply posting product information received from a financial institution is not a problem. But if it processes the content, or sets up a design or algorithm so that products it wants to push come out on top, that may amount to "intermediation" under bank agency business. It also answered that even sorting by an objective yardstick like interest rates and fees, a license may be needed in some cases depending on how it's displayed and what else is written.
That's right — it's about protecting users. But read it the other way round, and this note seems to assume that the ordering can be designed, and that the design moves how people choose. Am I wrong?
So. What to do is, honestly, unglamorous. Read the explanation of the ordering. Check who runs the site, and which financial institution is the counterparty to the contract. Finally, with your own loan amount and your estimate of how many years until you let the home go or refinance, re-sort the totals of interest plus fees yourself. Number one is the entrance to the candidates. Not the conclusion. OK?
With a box of apples, they line the best-looking ones on the top layer, right? That isn't cheating; it's how the box is made. Checking down to the bottom layer by hand is the buyer's job.
Sources (in Japanese)
- 金融庁「「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針」等の一部改正(案)に対するパブリックコメントの結果等の公表について」(checked 2026-11-10)
- 金融庁「「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針」等の一部改正(案)に対するパブリックコメントの概要及びそれに対する金融庁の考え方(別紙1)」(checked 2026-11-10)
- 金融庁「主要行等向けの総合的な監督指針 新旧対照表(別紙2)」(checked 2026-11-10)