BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Are the loans shown at the top of a mortgage comparison site listed in order of the best terms?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

3 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. The moment you read "at the top" and "the best terms" as meaning the same thing, the design of that screen has already scored a point on you.

No, I get what you mean. It's shown at the very top, so it must be the best, right — that's what people normally think. So let me ask: "the best terms" for whom? For someone borrowing for how many years?

Answer first. What shows up at the top is the loan that came out on top by the yardstick that site decided on. It isn't necessarily the best loan on your terms. What the yardstick is, the site writes somewhere on the screen. If it isn't written, the only thing you learn is that you don't know what order it's in.

Let's sort it out once. There are two blind spots.

One. There's only one yardstick. Even if you sort by lowest interest rate, interest isn't the only thing you pay after you borrow. When a loan whose administrative fee is "a percentage of the loan amount" sits next to one with a "flat" fee, the one ranked higher on rate can come out worse in total, depending on how many years until you finish paying it off (or sell, or refinance). And the rate shown isn't necessarily the same as your rate after you pass screening. The number one on the screen doesn't know your screening result. Get it?

Two. The ordering itself can be built. Folks like me read words by cutting them into pieces, so when it says "recommended," I go looking for the subject. Recommended by whom?

Here, the regulators are looking at the same spot. In the revision to the supervisory guidelines that the Financial Services Agency applied from November 6, 2026, a note was added: a comparison site simply posting product information received from a financial institution is not a problem. But if it processes the content, or sets up a design or algorithm so that products it wants to push come out on top, that may amount to "intermediation" under bank agency business. It also answered that even sorting by an objective yardstick like interest rates and fees, a license may be needed in some cases depending on how it's displayed and what else is written.

That's right — it's about protecting users. But read it the other way round, and this note seems to assume that the ordering can be designed, and that the design moves how people choose. Am I wrong?

So. What to do is, honestly, unglamorous. Read the explanation of the ordering. Check who runs the site, and which financial institution is the counterparty to the contract. Finally, with your own loan amount and your estimate of how many years until you let the home go or refinance, re-sort the totals of interest plus fees yourself. Number one is the entrance to the candidates. Not the conclusion. OK?

With a box of apples, they line the best-looking ones on the top layer, right? That isn't cheating; it's how the box is made. Checking down to the bottom layer by hand is the buyer's job.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first.

The ordering on a comparison site is not set by law as "in order of the best terms." The operator decides what to sort by. Being shown at the top only shows that it came out on top by that site's criteria; it does not show the order of total repayment for each borrower.

What is decided, and how

A business that conducts, on behalf of a bank, "agency or intermediation for the conclusion of contracts for the lending of funds or the discounting of bills" is bank agency business (Banking Act, Article 2, paragraph 14, item 2). A bank agent is a person who conducts bank agency business with a license from the Prime Minister (Article 52-36, paragraph 1 of the same Act) (paragraph 15 of the same Article). A mortgage is a contract for the lending of funds.

How far something counts as intermediation is set out in VIII-3-2-1-1 of the Financial Services Agency's "Comprehensive Guidelines for Supervision of Major Banks, etc." (commonly called the supervisory guidelines). The "contracts for the acceptance of deposits, etc." referred to here include the lending of funds (VIII-3-2-1-1(1)). On November 6, 2026, a note about comparison sites and similar was added, and it has applied from the same day.

What to compare

What the comparison site doesThe supervisory guidelines and the FSA's viewBasis
Simply reposts product information received from a financial institutionNot a problemNote to VIII-3-2-1-1(3)②(a)
Processes the product information received and posts itMay amount to intermediationSame as above
Sets up a design or algorithm so that products it recommends are shown at the topMay amount to intermediationSame as above
Sorts by objective indicators such as interest rates and feesJudged on the individual facts. Depending on how it is displayed and what else is written, a license may be needed in some casesAnswer No.18 in the results of the public comment

Where the answer splits

Whether something amounts to intermediation is to be judged substantively, case by case, according to the actual circumstances (note to VIII-3-2-1-1(2)), and no uniform standard is given (Answers No.13 and No.18). From the reader's side, the dividing lines are the following 3 points.

  1. Whether the ordering is based on indicators such as interest rates and fees, or on the operator's recommendation
  2. Whether the interest rates and fees shown are the financial institution's information as is, or have been processed by the operator
  3. Whether the operator recommends or explains a particular loan as its own view

Conditions behind the numbers

  • The revision to the supervisory guidelines was published on November 6, 2026 and applied from the same day. The FSA says that as long as appropriate steps toward improvement are being taken, it will not immediately treat it as a problem if improvements are not complete as of the publication date (Answer No.1).
  • The new note is written in general terms such as "acceptance of deposits, etc." and "products," and does not name mortgages (the example in Answer No.18 of the public comment is also deposit interest rates). However, "acceptance of deposits, etc." in the guidelines includes the lending of funds (VIII-3-2-1-1(1)).
  • The supervisory guidelines are the supervisory view. They do not define what the ordering means for users.
  • The ranking by interest rate and the ranking by total repayment do not necessarily match. Between a loan whose administrative fee is set as a rate on the loan amount and a loan with a flat fee, which total is larger can switch depending on the number of years until full repayment or refinancing.

Order of checks

  1. Read the explanation of the ordering on the screen (what it is sorted by, and whether there are labels such as "recommended" or "PR")
  2. Check the operator's name and see whether it is on the FSA's list of bank agents and financial service intermediaries (a site that simply reposts does not need a license, so not being listed does not in itself mean there is a problem)
  3. Check the name of the financial institution that will be the counterparty to the contract
  4. Read the notes on the rate shown (under what conditions the rate applies, and whether it changes with screening)
  5. Re-sort the totals of interest and fees combined using your own loan amount, loan term and the number of years you expect until you let the home go

From here on, this is my opinion

The ordering is the result of how the operator chose and presented information. The November 2026 revision assumes that this presentation can move users' choices. I think it is reasonable to use comparison sites as a place to gather candidates, and to decide not by ranking but by the total calculated on your own terms.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! You'd think the one shown at the very top is the best loan, right? I thought so too! Actually, it's because I thought so that I'm writing this now.

When I was looking into refinancing my mortgage, I re-sorted a comparison site by "lowest interest rate first." I re-sorted it myself, properly! Pretty good, right? Number 1 had a rate of 1.20%, number 2 had 1.30%. With a 0.1 percentage point difference, there's no reason to hesitate. I went straight from number 1's screen to applying, and refinanced.

When I looked back over the documents later, number 1's administrative fee was "2.2% of the loan amount," and number 2's was "a flat ¥55,000." ...I think it was written somewhere on the screen. I probably just didn't scroll!

So I redid the calculation. These are made-up numbers for illustration: a balance of ¥20 million, 35 years, equal principal-and-interest payments, the rate never changes, and all other costs are the same. Monthly repayment is ¥58,340 for number 1 and ¥59,296 for number 2, a difference of ¥956. If you repay it all over 35 years, the total of interest and fees is about ¥4.94 million for number 1 and about ¥4.96 million for number 2, so number 1 is about ¥17,000 less. So far, number 1 wins!

But I'd been saying for a while that I wanted to move in about 10 years. If you sell in 10 years, the interest and fees for those 10 years are about ¥2.56 million for number 1 and about ¥2.35 million for number 2. Number 2 is about ¥200,000 less. That means the ¥440,000 fee I paid at the start can't be earned back in 10 years.

The ranking doesn't know how many years I plan to keep the home. Obviously!

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • The yardstick I sorted by was just one. Neither the fees nor how many years until I let the home go are in that yardstick
  • Work out the total not only by "how many years you borrow for" but by "how many years until you sell or refinance"
  • Before going on to apply, scroll down to the fee section

Thanks to that, now whenever I open a comparison site, I've got the habit of first scrolling all the way to the bottom. My finger has gotten really strong! ...As for the loan, I'm still borrowing with number 1, though!

Read a little deeper