BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished Updated

Why do interest rates differ between lenders? Should I just pick the lowest one?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Interest rates differ between lenders because each one has a different cost of raising money, a different view of the risk of the borrower and the collateral, and a different target customer base. Also, the lender with the lowest interest rate is not necessarily the most favorable in terms of total repayment or monthly cash flow. You need to compare them including fees, loan term and the rules for reviewing the interest rate.

Why interest rates differ by lender

FactorDetails
Cost of raising fundsThe more cheaply a lender can gather deposits, the easier it is to offer a low interest rate
View of riskHow the borrower's annual income and employer, and the collateral value of the property, are assessed differs
Strategy and customer baseWhether to lend at a low rate to a top-tier segment with strict conditions, or to widen screening and add to the rate
Product designThe combinations differ, such as raising fees to lower the interest rate

The rates used as a base

Interest rate typeMain baseHow it moves
Variable rateThe short-term prime rate and others. Affected by the Bank of Japan's policy rateChanges in the policy rate are reflected through the short-term prime rate, and the rate is reviewed periodically
Fixed rateAffected by long-term interest rates (such as the 10-year government bond yield)Tends to reflect movements in market interest rates

Items to compare besides the interest rate

ItemWhat to check
Loan processing feeA fixed amount, or a percentage of the loan amount
Loan termA shorter term raises the monthly repayment
Prepayment feeWhether one is charged, and how much
Interest rate reviewHow often it is reviewed, and whether there is a cap rule on the repayment amount
Group credit life insuranceWhether it is included in the interest rate or added on top

Order of checks

  1. From the loan amount, interest rate and loan term, calculate the monthly repayment and the total interest.
  2. Add the fees and compare the total amount paid.
  3. Compare the monthly repayment with the rent you take home, and check the cash flow.
  4. Also calculate the repayment if the interest rate rises by 1%.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think you should not choose a lender on a low interest rate alone. With borrowing for investment, both the total interest and the monthly cash flow are material for the decision.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I got new glasses! I was so happy I ordered a sweet caramel latte at the café by the station, and the steam turned my lenses pure white in an instant! I took a sip without seeing anything and burned my tongue!

So, about interest rates. The reason I chose the loan on my current condominium unit was really simple. At a study group of investor friends, everyone was using the same plan from the same bank. "It's 1.2%." "Mine's 1.2% too." If everyone's doing it, it can't be wrong! So I got an application form right there.

Then came the monthly debit in the month I entered year 4. It had gone up by ¥11,000!

That plan was designed so that the rate discount was large only for the first 3 years, and smaller from year 4. Suppose the bank's standard rate stays at 2.6%: for the first 3 years it's 1.4% off, so 1.2%, and from year 4 it's 0.2% off, so 2.4%. Borrowing ¥20 million over 35 years, the monthly repayment goes from about ¥58,000 to about ¥69,000. It was written clearly in the contract. I just hadn't read it.

The same bank also had a plan with 1.0% off from start to finish, in other words 1.6%. With that one, it's about ¥62,000 a month. It's about ¥4,000 a month more for the first 3 years, but if the standard rate doesn't change, total interest over 35 years is about ¥6.13 million. My plan is about ¥8.76 million. That's a difference of more than ¥2.6 million!

Apparently there are lots of reasons interest rates differ between lenders, but what I learned firsthand is the difference in "how it's designed to look." Some plans make the first number look small, and some take off the same amount the whole way. The plan with the lowest number on display isn't necessarily the cheapest across all 35 years.

Plus, everyone at the study group and I have different incomes, different properties and borrowed at different times. Nobody could have known whether everyone's 1.2% fit my 35 years.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • "The same interest rate as everyone else" is a number that came out of everyone else's conditions. Look at the document issued for your own conditions
  • Before signing, ask in which year the size of the discount changes
  • Compare the repayment after the preferential rate ends with the rent you take home

Now when I read a contract, I make sure to wipe my new glasses first! The latte that day wasn't the only thing I was looking at through fogged-up lenses!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper