BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished Updated

If I do real estate investment, should I use a loan?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Using a loan can raise the ratio of cash left over to your own funds. However, that holds only while the property's yield exceeds the weight of the loan repayments. Whether you should use one is decided by the numbers when the weight of repayments changes.

Indicators to compare

IndicatorCalculation
Property yield (net)Cash left over after subtracting vacancy and expenses from rent ÷ purchase price
Loan constant (K%)Annual repayment (principal and interest) ÷ loan amount
Cash left over relative to own funds(cash left over − annual repayment) ÷ own funds

The key point is to compare including not only interest but also principal repayment. If the property yield exceeds the loan constant, the more you borrow, the more the cash left over relative to your own funds increases. If it falls below, the more you borrow, the more it decreases.

Example calculation

All numbers are assumptions. Suppose a ¥20 million property with ¥900,000 a year of cash left over after vacancy and expenses (a net yield of 4.5%). Acquisition costs are not considered.

CaseAnnual repaymentAnnual cash left overRatio to own funds
Purchase in cash (own funds ¥20 million)None¥900,0004.5%
Borrow ¥18 million at 2% for 35 years (own funds ¥2 million)About ¥716,000About ¥184,000About 9.2%
Same loan, interest rate of 3%About ¥831,000About ¥69,000About 3.4%
Same loan, interest rate of 4%About ¥956,000About −¥56,000About −2.8%
Interest rate stays at 2%, cash left over falls to ¥700,000 a yearAbout ¥716,000About −¥16,000About −0.8%

The loan constant at 2% for 35 years is about 4.0%. The gap with the property yield of 4.5% is only about 0.5 percentage points. If the interest rate rises by 1 percentage point, or the cash left over falls by 20%, the gap reverses.

Conditions for borrowing

  • In a survey published by the Financial Services Agency in March 2019 (Heisei 31), 95% of banks took borrowers' salary income and the like into account in financing for investment real estate.
  • Personal credit information is also checked in screening. If repayment delinquency continues for a certain period, it is registered with credit bureaus as default information (an "adverse event").

Order of checks

  1. Work out the property's net yield using cash left over that you calculated yourself.
  2. Work out the loan constant from the loan conditions.
  3. Work out the numbers for when the interest rate rises by 1 to 2 percentage points and when the cash left over falls by 20%.
  4. Check against your funds on hand whether you can pay the out-of-pocket amount in every case.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think whether to use a loan should be decided not by a high ratio of cash left over to own funds, but by whether you can withstand it when the gap reverses. With a property where the gap is small, borrowing enlarges the risk before the profit.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! For this question, I bought with a loan and a senior colleague at work bought in cash, so comparing the two of us makes it easy to see.

What my senior bought in cash was an old studio unit in a regional area. There's no monthly repayment, so when rent comes in, it stays in hand as is. Months with a vacancy are in the red, but with no debt, my senior said they sleep soundly at night.

What I bought with a loan was a second-hand studio unit a bit closer to the city. The price was ¥20 million, and the down payment was only ¥2 million. I borrowed the remaining ¥18 million at 2% for 35 years.

The person in charge told me: "If you borrow, leverage works for you. With a ¥2 million down payment you can own a ¥20 million property." I thought that sounded so cool! When they calculated it for me, the cash left over after subtracting expenses from rent was ¥900,000 a year, and the repayment was about ¥716,000 a year. What remains is about ¥184,000 a year. More than 9% of the ¥2 million down payment. Much more efficient than buying in cash, they said.

So I got completely carried away. ...And up to here, it really was exactly as they said.

Then, in year 2. A tenant moved out, and it took 3 months until the next person was found. The repayment kept coming every month during that time. The cash left over that year was negative. Part of my bonus went straight to repayment. The same year, my senior's unit was also empty for 1 month, but with my senior's cash unit, it was just "a bit less this year." Yet with my loan unit, I had to add to the repayment from my salary.

That's when I realized. Leverage doesn't only work in the direction of increase. When the cash left over drops because of a vacancy, that drop hits harder by as much as you borrowed. I worked out later that it's the same when interest rates rise. If the interest rate goes to 3%, the ¥184,000 a year of cash left over drops to about ¥69,000.

There are 3 things I want to tell the me of back then.

  • When you hear the word "leverage," have them show you the numbers for when it works in reverse too.
  • Check that you could pay the repayment from your salary even in a year when the vacancy lasts 3 months.
  • Calculate for yourself the cash left over if the interest rate rises by 1%.

Now, every time a repayment date comes, I remember my senior's "With no debt, you can sleep." If you borrow, keep it to an amount that lets you sleep soundly!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper