BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

Why don't rich people buy lots of houses and live off the rent?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Good eye. Rich people lining up 20 detached houses and living elegantly off the rent — you really don't hear that story much. Noticing that is sharp. But it's still soft. If you've noticed it, you have to cut it one step further.

The usual answer goes like this. Houses break one at a time, they go vacant, they take work. You need debt too. So people don't do it. Yeah, that's right, it's right, but that only explains half of it. Because there are people who know about the work and the debt and still actually buy lots of houses. So why do they do it even though they know?

Let me put numbers here. All assumptions. Buy a second-hand detached house for ¥8 million in cash, and if the rent is ¥70,000 a month, that's ¥840,000 a year. Say ¥250,000 a year disappears to fixed asset tax, repairs and the occasional vacancy, and ¥590,000 is left. Line up 20 of these, and the starting money is ¥160 million and the cash left over is ¥11.8 million a year.

Now, here's where it splits. Someone holding ¥160 million in cash can live for quite a while without rent in the first place, right? In other words, "people who can buy 20 houses in cash" don't need to live off rent, and "people who want to live off rent" don't have the cash to buy 20 houses. Inside the question, the people who want it and the people who can buy it are passing each other by. A bit tricky? Well, hang in there.

So who does it even though they know? Not rich people buying houses, but people trying to get rich through houses. They don't have enough cash on hand, so they use the system where a bank lends against the house as collateral. A house is a tool that's most useful to people who don't have money. Well, I mean that as a compliment too — you can't grow savings with debt, but with a house you can. That's why they do it even if it costs them work. There's a real reason. Get it?

Put the other way, that's not "living," it's "a business." A job running 20 roofs, 20 water heaters and the turnover of tenants. If you were expecting even a teeny bit of elegance, discount that.

Here's the answer to the question, briefly. Rich people don't buy lots of houses and live off the rent because they don't need rent anymore. If someone who wants to live off rent does it, it becomes a business using debt. Decide first which position you're thinking from. Honestly, once that's decided, the books you read and the numbers you look at change too. Following me?

Roasted sweet potatoes, right — when you buy one from a stall, the price of one includes the firewood and the waiting time. If you decide to roast 20 at home, that's already a sweet potato shop. Do you want to eat, or do you want to sell? Ciao.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Let me start from the time I came across the sea. When I came to Japan from Manchuria, all I could carry was one bag I could hold in my hand. I left the house and the fields behind. There comes a day when things you can't move are the same as things you don't have, even if you own them. That one thing was burned into my young head.

What I remember is a time when all I heard were voices saying land prices would go up forever. Reading back through the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's White Paper on Land, in March 1990 (Heisei 2) a measure was taken asking lenders to keep the growth of lending to the real estate industry at or below the growth of their total lending — the so-called total volume restriction. New lending to the real estate industry fell from ¥10,441.9 billion in 1989 (Heisei 1) to ¥6,715.2 billion in 1993 (Heisei 5). Land prices in the center of Tokyo peaked in 1991 (Heisei 3), and land prices in the three major metropolitan areas started falling that year.

One more thing: from January 1992 (Heisei 4), a land value tax, charged just for owning land, also began. It has been suspended from the taxation dates of 1998 (Heisei 10) onward, mind you.

On the ship leaving Manchuria, I kept just one small bottle of sorghum liquor tucked in my coat. I was told to cut down my baggage, so I left a piece of clothing and kept the liquor. Thinking about it now, that was my first reallocation of assets.

Back to the story. Japan tasted the weight of owning many properties all at once at the start of Heisei. Houses and land you increased by borrowing — even when their value falls, the interest doesn't wait. What came after that was the 2000 (Heisei 12) revision of the Act on Investment Trusts, and the opening of the J-REIT market the following year, in September 2001 (Heisei 13). The investments of investment trusts widened to real estate, and it became possible to own buildings without holding them yourself, pooled in the form of securities and entrusted to others.

So today's rich people have a way to get rent-like income without holding 20 roofs. This is my view, but that is the biggest difference between then and now. Back then, if you wanted rent, you had no choice but to own a house yourself. Now you can choose how to own. If you still own many houses yourself, that means you chose a business where you take on the work yourself.

Even when the times change, people's habits don't. This is also my view, but the more prices keep rising, the louder the voices saying "you can't have too many houses" become. I've seen that once.

Try just one thing. Take one chart of land price trends in Heisei from the White Paper on Land, and look at it with your own eyes. If you count how many years it lasted from peak to trough, you'll understand in your gut the weight of holding many properties.

Well, understanding it won't kill you. Holding 20 without understanding it will shorten your life far more.

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper