BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Is a property that gets approved for full financing a good property?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It's the other way around. Financing coming through only means the bank judged "with this person, the money we lend will come back." It didn't grade whether you'll make money.

This is the root of the misunderstanding, so I'll go carefully. What the bank looks at is the risk of a loan going bad. Even in a survey the Financial Services Agency did of lenders, 95% of banks also consider things other than the property's cash flow when assessing repayment ability — for example, the borrower's salary income. In other words, even if the property is in the red, they can lend if you can repay from your salary. Even if the property is poorly made, financing comes through if you're a good borrower. The equation "financing approved = good property" doesn't hold from the start.

One more. Look at your own BS (balance sheet) the moment you buy with full financing. Say you buy a ¥30 million property entirely with borrowed money. Even if the price doesn't fall by a single yen, selling it costs up to ¥1.056 million in brokerage commission at the cap, so you'd take home ¥28.944 million. Against a balance of ¥30 million, you're ¥1.056 million short. And on top of that, you've paid the acquisition costs separately in cash. Full financing means starting, from the first day after buying, in a state where debt remains even if you sell.

Now, the past. In 2018, the Financial Services Agency issued an order to Suruga Bank suspending new lending for investment real estate for 6 months. The reason: real estate companies were making rents and occupancy rates look higher than they actually were, and falsifying documents on deposit balances and income, and the bank's sales staff kept lending while knowing this. There were even cases where passing the screening, far from proving the property's quality, was the result of doctored documents.

The Financial Services Agency itself has also written about its concern that with this kind of lending, the risks are hard to see in the first few years. Right after borrowing, the rent comes in and nothing happens. Problems appear once vacancies and repairs start to overlap.

So what should you look at? Not whether financing comes through, but whether the property covers its repayments on its own without putting in a single yen of your salary. Can you pay the loan repayments with the cash left over after vacancies and expenses? If you can't, that's not an investment; it's a purchase you top up from your salary every month.

Conclusion. A property that gets financing is "a deal where the bank doesn't lose," not "a property where you gain." Don't mistake the screening's pass notice for the property's report card.

Just as the sweetness of oshiruko (sweet red bean soup) is decided by the amount of sugar, how easily financing comes through is decided by your annual income. The flavor of the property is something you can only check yourself.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. When I see the face of someone delighted that their full financing went through, I can't help wanting to pour them a drink. Not a celebratory drink — the kind that wakes you up.

Since long ago, many people have mistaken "they let me borrow" for "they recognized me."

It's the same as a tab at a bar. The bars where you can run a tab are, before you know it, the ones you go to most. But you can run a tab not because the bar likes you. It's because they figured you're someone who can pay. Nobody praised your taste in drink, and nobody valued the way you drink.

Back to the point. In the case where the Financial Services Agency issued its order in 2018, even the bankbook balances of borrowers with no own funds were rewritten, and the financing went through. Whether the borrowers knew probably varied from person to person. But one thing can be said: there was a system that went that far to lend to people who couldn't borrow without going that far. The fact that financing went through is, on its own, no seal of approval at all.

What I want to talk about is the down payment.

I think a down payment isn't about the amount. It's proof that, during the years you were saving, you kept passing on properties you wanted. In that time you watch the market, look at many properties, and build up the experience of "good thing I didn't buy that one." That's where your eye grows.

Full financing lets you skip this time. That in itself isn't all bad. There's logic to keeping cash on hand, and I understand wanting to start while you're young. But you can end up buying before your eye has grown.

So there's 1 thing to test. If someone told you "save up a down payment and come back," could you give up this property?

If you could, you're still calm. Go over the numbers again and check whether the property covers its repayments on its own. If you couldn't, you're just smitten. You can't see the flaws of someone you've fallen for. People have always been like that.

A drink someone else pays for tastes good too. I'll grant that. But even if you get drunk on someone else's tab, it's your own legs that walk you home.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper