BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

With the 5-year rule and the 125% rule on variable rates, is there nothing to fear from rising interest rates?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. You only feel protected. What these rules protect is "the monthly repayment amount," not "your total payments."

Start with how it works. For example, with MUFG Bank's home loans, for a variable rate with equal principal-and-interest payments, the repayment amount doesn't change for 5 years even if the interest rate changes. That's the 5-year rule. When the repayment amount is reviewed every 5 years, even if it goes up, it's capped at 125% of the previous repayment amount. That's the 125% rule. However, the interest rate itself really does go up. Only the repayment amount stays the same; the split between interest and principal inside it changes. Equal principal payments don't have these rules, and whether they're used at all depends on the product, so check your own contract.

Let's do it in numbers. Borrow ¥40 million over 35 years at 1.2%, and the monthly repayment is about ¥116,700. Interest in the first month is ¥40,000. Suppose the interest rate rises to 2.7% after 1 year. The repayment stays at ¥116,700. But interest jumps to about ¥87,900, and only about ¥28,800 goes to principal.

Comparing the balance after 5 years: if the interest rate stays at 1.2% throughout, it's about ¥35.26 million. If it becomes 2.7% partway, about ¥37.62 million. The repayment amount is the same, yet about ¥2.36 million more remains. For 5 years, you thought you were paying, but the principal wasn't going down.

Then, review day. The repayment needed to reach full repayment in the remaining term is about ¥152,600. But under the 125% rule, the cap is about ¥145,900. The cap kicks in and it looks cheaper, but what you haven't paid off has just been pushed to the back.

What happens if it rises further? In this example, once the interest rate goes above about 3.58%, interest alone exceeds the monthly repayment. The excess is carried forward as unpaid interest. If a balance remains on the final repayment date, in principle you pay it in one lump sum on that day.

Conclusion. The 5-year rule and the 125% rule are a cushion that delays a jump in the repayment amount. They're not a mechanism that erases the cost of rising interest rates. The most dangerous thing is not noticing, while you're sitting on the cushion, that the principal isn't going down.

So there's 1 thing to do. On each year's repayment schedule, look at how much the balance went down. Even if the repayment amount is the same, if the balance is going down more slowly, that's the warning light.

It's like driving a car without looking at the fuel gauge, so it always looks full. The fuel light usually comes on late.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. When it comes to mechanisms for putting things off, I have opinions of my own. After all, I'm a master at putting off a hangover until the next day.

First, an old story. The Government Housing Loan Corporation (Jūtaku Kin'yū Kōko) had, from fiscal 1979 (Showa 54) to fiscal 1999 (Heisei 11), a mechanism that made repayments lighter for the first 5 years. At first it was called step repayment, and from fiscal 1993 (Heisei 5) it got the name "yutori repayment" (easy repayment).

Here's what it was. For the first 5 years, the repayment amount was calculated on the premise of repaying over 50 years. In fiscal 1993 (Heisei 5) and fiscal 1994 (Heisei 6), 75 years. That made the monthly repayments lighter. But from the 6th year, the principal not repaid during those 5 years was added on. In the Board of Audit's calculation example, the repayment from the 6th year is about 1.5 to 1.7 times that of the first 5 years.

In its report for fiscal 2004 (Heisei 16), the Board of Audit wrote that a correlation could be seen between yutori repayment and an increase in delinquencies. The Corporation, too, changed its screening partway. From fiscal 1997 (Heisei 9), it began checking whether the monthly income criteria were met using the repayment amount without yutori repayment.

Let me be clear: the mechanism is different from today's 5-year rule and 125% rule. With yutori repayment, it was decided from the start that the repayment would increase. The 5-year rule is a mechanism that delays changes in the repayment amount when interest rates rise.

But the structure on the human side is the same. People who decided based on "I can pay the current repayment amount" get into trouble 5 years later.

You see, people assume their self 5 years from now is richer and more patient than their self today. My salary should have gone up, things should have worked out by then. Fun things get moved earlier, hard things get put off. I'm the same, so I can't talk big.

So do yourself what the Corporation did partway through. Assume the repayment has risen to 125%, and see whether your current household budget can handle it.

If it can, you don't need to be overly afraid. If it can't, start putting the difference into a separate account every month from now. If rates don't rise, it all becomes savings. You won't lose.

A hangover doesn't disappear even if you put it off. It comes the next morning, without fail. And is it only me who feels it comes with interest?

Read a little deeper