BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished Updated

Why do so many people choose a variable rate for their home loan?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Last week I got new glasses. It's amazing how much the world changes when you can see well. I could even read the nutrition label on a sweet convenience-store café latte, I was shocked by the amount of sugar, and I bought it anyway!

So, variable rates. Why does everyone choose them? In my case, the answer was really simple. Because the number 1 on a comparison site's ranking was a variable rate.

When I bought the second-hand condominium unit I own now, I looked up loan interest rates and found a ranking of interest rates for investment loans, and the number 1 had the smallest figure. "If it's number 1, it can't be wrong!" I thought, and applied for that bank's variable rate. I didn't look at the difference from fixed, what it was linked to, or how many times a year it was reviewed. I think before I got new glasses, my mental eyesight was about 0.1 too.

What I found out later was that the rate in the ranking was the figure for people with the best conditions, and the rate I got was higher than that. Also, my loan was linked to the short-term prime rate, and that short-term prime rate had been moving. Looking at the Bank of Japan's statistics, the mode of the major banks' short-term prime rate was 1.625% on September 2, 2024 (Reiwa 6), and 2.375% on August 3, 2026 (Reiwa 8). It rose 0.75% in less than 2 years.

Suppose you borrow ¥20 million over 35 years with equal principal-and-interest payments and the interest rate goes from 1.9% to 2.65% — the monthly repayment goes from about ¥65,000 to about ¥73,000. That works out to nearly ¥8,000 more a month. For what's left of the rent on 1 condominium unit, that's an amount that just blows it away!

It's not that the ranking is bad. That number 1 was number 1 for "cheapest right now," not number 1 for "fine even if rates go up." I just assumed on my own that they were the same. I think the reason everyone chooses variable is also that it looks cheapest when you compare. It really does look cheap. But that's today's price, isn't it?

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • The rate in a ranking may be the figure for people with the best conditions. Look at the rate you'll actually get, in writing
  • Before applying, ask what it's linked to and how many times a year it's reviewed
  • Calculate once, with your own loan amount, how much more a month you'd pay if it rose 0.75%

With my new glasses, I can properly read even the small notes at the very bottom of a ranking table. They were written there when I had my old glasses too! The shop clerk said, "You've raised the prescription quite a bit," but what I should have raised was my prescription for checking!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm having my sake warmed nurukan-style. About body temperature is right. Heat it too much and the aroma flies off. So — why the variable rate is chosen so much.

What I remember is the time when, for home loans, the state's Government Housing Loan Corporation lent directly to individuals. What changed that was the system. In October 2003 (Heisei 15), a mechanism started that buys long-term fixed-rate loans issued by private banks and turns them into securities (today's Flat 35). In March 2007 (Heisei 19), the corporation withdrew from direct lending to ordinary individuals, and in April it was reorganized into the incorporated administrative agency, the Japan Housing Finance Agency. We moved from an era when the state lent money itself to an era when it supports private loans from behind.

In material from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, of new lending in fiscal 2008 (Heisei 20), the variable type was 36.9%, and fixed rates over 10 years, fully fixed rates and Flat 35 combined were only about 10%. Then in the agency's January 2026 survey, 75.0% of people who borrowed from April to September 2025 chose the variable type — though that's down 4.0 percentage points from the previous round. The ways of counting differ, so you mustn't simply line them up, but it's certain the lead role has changed hands. Through the long period of low rates, variable had the lightest monthly repayment. The reason it's chosen, in my view, was and is "the lightness right in front of you."

Let me talk about drink. The kaoliang liquor I learned in Manchuria is a strong spirit distilled from fermented sorghum — it burns your throat. Shaoxing wine, which I learned after coming to Japan, is brewed from glutinous rice and aged in jars. The longer it ages, the darker its color and the smoother its edges. Even among "Chinese liquor," some hit you all at once and some take their time. Interest rates are similar: when they rise, they sometimes come all at once, like kaoliang.

Back to the main point. Looking at the Bank of Japan's statistics, banks' short-term prime rate was 4.25% in January 1989 (Heisei 1), and by the start of 1991 (Heisei 3) it was 8.25%. It rose 4% in about 2 years. And right on January 23, 1989 (Heisei 1), the way the short-term prime rate was set changed to a method based on banks' overall funding costs. Even when the way it's set changes, when it rises, it rises.

People don't change. But they can learn. Reaching for the cheaper option is human nature, and nothing to blame. Choosing variable is not a mistake in itself either. But the fact that the short-term prime rate rose 4% in about 2 years at the start of Heisei is left in numbers in the Bank of Japan's tables. What's left, anyone can read.

A word for the young. Before you stamp your seal, trace the rows from 1989 (Heisei 1) to 1991 (Heisei 3) in the Bank of Japan's short-term prime rate table with your own eyes. Then, check in the contract's clauses when and how far your repayment is set to change if a rise like that came, and only then borrow.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper