Wang here. Do you remember the end of 1988 (Showa 63)? In the tax reform that December, one unusual rule was added to inheritance tax. A special provision that land bought within 3 years before death would be counted in the inherited estate not at a cheap valuation such as road-rating land values (rosenka), but at the very price it was bought for.
Let me tell you some history. When land prices were soaring, counting land at road-rating land values came out much cheaper than the price it was bought and sold for. So if you borrowed money and bought land, the debt could be subtracted in full, and the land was counted cheaply. Inheritance tax went down by the difference. A court judgment wrote that the aim of this special provision was to curb tax avoidance using the gap between actual value and road-rating land values, and to curb buying land with borrowed money for speculation. The idea that borrowing reduces your taxes had already spread so far back then that the country took action.
Let me tell you about my wife. Once, at the liquor shop, I heard that buying in bulk makes each bottle cheaper, and I came home hugging a whole case of big isshōbin sake bottles. My wife looked at the case and said, "Each bottle may be cheaper, but the money you paid has gone up, hasn't it?" I had nothing to say back. That being counted cheaply and coming out ahead are different things, I learned in the kitchen.
Back to the story. Later, when land prices fell sharply, this special provision bared its fangs in the opposite direction. The land had become cheaper than the price it was bought for, yet tax was counted at the purchase price. On October 17, 1995 (Heisei 7), the Osaka District Court held that applying this special provision even in cases where it would impose a tax greater than the value of the inherited real estate was not intended, and found the reassessment unlawful. However, the Osaka High Court overturned that judgment on April 14, 1998 (Heisei 10). The special provision itself was abolished in the tax reform for fiscal 1996 (Heisei 8).
But the story doesn't end there. On April 19, 2022 (Reiwa 4), the Supreme Court found lawful a reassessment that recalculated tax at a valuation higher than the valuation under the circular, in a case where a person who died at age 94 had borrowed money and bought real estate. Under the circular's valuation, inheritance tax would have been zero; recalculated, it was a little over ¥240.49 million. Even as the shape of the rules changed, the country has turned its eyes again and again to the move of creating a valuation gap with debt.
This is roughly what happens when you get greedy. If you borrow and buy with nothing on your mind but cutting taxes, then whether prices fall or the way tax is counted changes, the debt alone stays as it is.
There's just one thing worth trying. When you hear a pitch to borrow and buy, assume the inheritance comes in a year when that property's value has fallen 20% or 30% below the purchase price, and set the remaining debt next to the property's value. If the household doesn't tip over with that, the pitch is worth listening to.
With liquor too, if I hear it can be laid down cheaply and buy the whole barrel, my liver gives out before the barrel does. Ka-ka-ka-ka.
Sources (in Japanese)
- 裁判所「相続税更正処分取消請求控訴事件(平成10年4月14日 大阪高等裁判所判決)」(checked 2026-10-15)
- 裁判所「相続税更正処分取消請求事件(平成7年10月17日 大阪地方裁判所判決)」(checked 2026-10-14)
- 裁判所「相続税更正処分等取消請求事件(令和4年4月19日 最高裁判所第三小法廷判決)」(checked 2026-10-15)
- 国税庁「財産評価基本通達 第1章 総則」(checked 2026-10-14)