BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Where is the danger in a borrowing plan that counts on your retirement allowance?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

This is Wang. Do you remember how much, on average, university-educated salaried workers who finished work at mandatory retirement in 2007 (Heisei 19) received? According to the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare's survey, for those who reached mandatory retirement with 20 or more years of service and aged 45 or over, it was ¥22.8 million.

Let me tell you an old story. In the 2023 (Reiwa 5) edition of the same survey, that is, for those who reached mandatory retirement in 2022 (Reiwa 4), it was ¥18.96 million for university and graduate school graduates. Even limited to 35 or more years of service, it fell from ¥24.91 million to ¥20.37 million. The education categories differ slightly, so it's a rough guide, but that works out to thinning by nearly ¥4 million in about 15 years. The share of companies with a retirement allowance system also fell from 80.5% in 2018 (Heisei 30) to 74.9% in 2023 (Reiwa 5).

The vessel itself has also been replaced. Tax-qualified pension plans, which were funded outside the company, were pressed to move to other corporate pensions and the like by March 31, 2012 (Heisei 24). The Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare writes that as of the end of December 2010 (Heisei 22), about 10,000 were still left. One of the destinations was the defined contribution pension, where the amount you receive changes with investment results. In my view, it was from around then that the amount you could state as "work through to the end and you'll get this much" began to scatter from person to person.

The timing of receipt is moving too. The mandatory retirement age for national public servants rises by 1 year every 2 years from fiscal 2023 (Reiwa 5), reaching 65 in fiscal 2031 (Reiwa 13). There is a rule that if you leave after 60 but before mandatory retirement, the retirement allowance is calculated the same way as at mandatory retirement. But the longer you keep working, the later the day you receive it slides. The picture of "receive it at 60 and repay the rest" can no longer be drawn the same way for everyone.

When greed takes hold, it mostly goes like this. The greed to make the borrowed amount one step bigger has you write money you don't have yet into the last row of the repayment schedule. On top of that, the retirement allowance is also counted on for living in old age, for helping the children, and for repairing the house. You load one sum of money with three or four roles, and you find out it's not enough on the day you receive it. At that age, there's no telling you'll be able to extend the term or refinance as you'd like.

I won't say don't rely on it. I'm saying set things up so they work even without relying on it. Mark the row of your repayment schedule for the year you plan to leave work, and calculate how much you'd need to add each month from now to repay that balance without touching a single yen of the retirement allowance. If the amount that comes out is too heavy, what's too heavy isn't the addition; it's the amount you're borrowing.

Leave enough of your retirement allowance untouched that you can open a bottle of your favorite liquor on the day you receive it. Let's look forward now to that day's toast.

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! At the general affairs window at my company, I froze with my finger tracing the retirement allowance field for me. What it said was about ¥300,000. In the repayment simulation I'd gotten from the real estate company, the age-60 row said "Retirement allowance ¥20 million (assumed)"!

It started 5 years ago, when I bought a used condominium unit at 33. I borrowed ¥20 million at 2.0% for 35 years (the rate is a rounded assumption!). The monthly repayment was about ¥66,000, and full repayment would be at 68. When I said that's a bit long, the person in charge pointed at the simulation sheet and said, "Many salaried people pay off the rest in one go when their retirement allowance comes in at 60. Effectively it's 27 years." On the sheet, the balance at age 60 was about ¥5.87 million, below that the retirement allowance of ¥20 million, and below that "about ¥14 million left in hand." It even maps out retirement! I was so impressed I filled out the application that day.

And then I didn't look at that sheet again even once in 5 years.

During that time, I changed jobs. My previous company's retirement allowance was a lump sum, and the roughly ¥600,000 I received when I left disappeared into moving and a fridge. My current company has no lump sum, only a corporate defined contribution pension. The company pays in contributions every month, I invest them, and in principle I can receive it from 60. I've been in it a little over 2 years, and the balance is about ¥300,000. What's in it is a principal-preservation type (ganpon kakuho-gata) I picked without really understanding. If the ¥12,000 a month in contributions continues until 60 and doesn't grow at all, it's about ¥3.5 million. Not only nowhere near ¥20 million, it doesn't even reach the ¥5.87 million balance!

On top of that, with a defined contribution pension, if you have less than 10 years of enrollment at age 60, the start of receipt shifts to 61 or later. I'll probably be fine. But what if I change jobs one more time?

The person in charge didn't lie. The ¥20 million was properly labeled "assumed." I just never once asked whose company's number that assumption was.

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • Believe the "retirement allowance" row in a simulation only after asking whose company's number it is
  • Check in the regulations whether your retirement allowance is a lump sum or a defined contribution pension, and from when you can receive it
  • If you change jobs, rewrite the last row of your repayment plan that same week

By the way, on the day I signed the contract, I bought 2 of the sweetest canned coffees as a reward, and put 1 in the back of a shelf "to drink on the day of the lump-sum payoff at 60." When I got back from general affairs and checked, it had passed its best-before date nearly 4 years ago. For a toast 27 years later, I'd picked a can that lasts only a little over 1 year. Not checking the expiry date of what I'm counting on is the one thing I've been consistent about since that day!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper