BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

When should I consider refinancing my loan?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Asking "when" about refinancing, as in timing, shows a good eye. Worrying about it at a time like autumn 2026 (Reiwa 8), when rates are moving, is right. But it's still soft. There's something to look at before timing. That refinancing — who brought it up?

Talk of refinancing usually gets carried in by someone's mouth. So first, line up where each party's money comes from. For the new lender, refinancing is a business of bringing in customers from elsewhere. If the administrative fee is a fixed-rate type at 2.2% of the loan amount, that's ¥660,000 on ¥30 million. That comes in on day one, whether you come out ahead or not. If there's someone in the middle, they may be set up to be rewarded when the deal goes through. The current lender is the side that doesn't want to lose a customer. Am I wrong? Nobody's bad. They're just each looking at different numbers.

So, now the real point. The number the side recommending it shows you is usually "how much the monthly repayment goes down." Say the balance is ¥30 million, 20 years left, 2.8% interest, equal principal-and-interest payments: the monthly repayment is about ¥163,000. Make that 2.3% and restructure the term to 30 years, and it's about ¥115,000 a month. Seriously, ¥48,000 a month lower. I mean, that hits. The household budget sheet suddenly looks bright.

But add up the total interest: as is, it's about ¥9.21 million; restructured, about ¥11.56 million. The rate went down, yet the interest you pay goes up by a little over ¥2.3 million. Because the term was stretched by 10 years. Keep the same 20 years at 2.3%, and the monthly is about ¥156,000 and interest is about ¥7.46 million. About ¥1.75 million less. What's left after subtracting the administrative fee, the registration costs and the current loan's lump-sum repayment fee is the real value of the refinancing. Following me?

One more, slightly mean-spirited view. When the monthly repayment gets lighter, the ratio of repayments to income goes down, and a loan for the next property looks easier to get. If, after the refinancing talk, the next property comes up casually, think about which one was the real topic. Overthinking? Yeah, if it's overthinking, that's fine.

So the answer to "when should I consider it" is this. When, even after lining up the remaining term and recalculating, the reduction in interest clearly exceeds the costs. For that, ask the side that recommended it to produce both repayment schedules, for the current loan and the new loan, lined up over the same remaining term. A proposal talked about only in monthly amounts — you can hold off on deciding until those 2 sheets are side by side. Does that answer it?

You know roasted sweet potatoes — when you hear they get sweeter the longer they bake, you're tempted to stretch the time. But overdo it and they burn, and you're left with nothing but skin. The loan term too: the longer you stretch it, the sweeter the monthly looks, but the stretched part burns in interest. See ya.

Sources (in Japanese)

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Refinancing a loan is worth considering when the reduction in repayments from the difference in interest rates exceeds the costs of refinancing. The guide for deciding is to compare the "payback period", the total refinancing costs divided by the monthly reduction in repayments, with the remaining term of the loan. For investment loans, the lenders that will refinance are limited, and depending on the valuation of the property, you may not be able to refinance the full balance.

Main costs of refinancing

CostDetails
Administrative fee / guarantee feePaid to the new lender. There is a fixed-rate type of about 2% of the loan amount and a flat-fee type
Registration and license taxSetting up the new mortgage is 0.4% of the loan amount (claim amount); cancellation is ¥1,000 per property
Judicial scrivener's feeProcedures for cancelling and setting up the mortgage
Lump-sum repayment feeMay be charged when repaying the current loan in full early
Stamp dutyCharged on the new loan agreement

Calculation

This is the case of refinancing a balance of ¥20 million with 18 years left (equal principal-and-interest payments) from an interest rate of 2.5% to 1.8%. Costs are assumed to total ¥670,000.

ItemAmount
Monthly repayment (before refinancing)about ¥115,000
Monthly repayment (after refinancing)about ¥108,000
Monthly reductionabout ¥6,600
Total reduction over the remaining 18 yearsabout ¥1.43 million
Payback period for the costsabout 101 months (about 8 years 5 months)

The effect after subtracting the costs is about ¥760,000 over the remaining 18 years. If any of the interest rate difference, the balance or the remaining term is small, the payback period approaches the remaining term and the effect almost disappears.

Points to note with investment loans

ItemDetails
Refinancing lendersFewer lenders handle refinancing of investment loans than of home loans
Property valuationIf the valuation is below the balance, the full balance cannot be refinanced, and the difference must be repaid from own funds
Negotiating with the current lenderAnother approach is to tell them you are considering refinancing and ask about lowering the interest rate

Order of checks

  1. Check the current loan's balance, interest rate, remaining term and lump-sum repayment fee.
  2. Get the refinancing lender's interest rate and estimates of the administrative fee, guarantee fee and registration costs.
  3. Divide the total costs by the monthly reduction to get the payback period.
  4. Consider refinancing if the payback period is sufficiently shorter than the remaining term.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think refinancing should be judged by the payback period, not by the difference in interest rates. If you may sell the property partway through, you also need to check whether the costs can be recovered by the time you plan to sell.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper