BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

If where I live or how I work is likely to change within 10 years, what is the point of owning real estate?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me ask you one thing first. In 10 years, where do you want to be, and how do you want to be working? If all you can say is "it'll probably change," that's already half the answer.

Next, where the people giving you answers stand. People who say "Investment properties are exactly for people who get transferred a lot. The rent comes in wherever you live" are often on the side that gets paid when a sale goes through. The bank wants to lend to you now, with your solid employer. The voices saying "If you're moving, renting is the only choice" carry nothing themselves for having said it. None of them is lying. But depending on where you are in 10 years, the only one of them who takes the loss is you. OK so far?

Let's sort out the spec. First, the story splits on whether it's your own home or a unit you rent out. If it's a unit you rent out, the unit doesn't move even if you move, and you can hire management even from far away. What matters is how you work, more than your address. If you go independent and your income swings, both your ability to cover vacant months and how you're viewed the next time you borrow change.

If it's your own home, every time you move you'll decide whether to sell or rent it out. If you sell, there's a toll. Suppose the acquisition costs when buying and the commission when selling together come to 10% of the price: for a ¥30 million unit, that's ¥3 million. If you let it go within a few years, the question is whether you can win that back. If you make a profit on the sale, there's also the tax line. According to the National Tax Agency's explanation, if the period you'd held it as of January 1 of the year of sale is 5 years or less, it's short-term capital gains, with income tax of 30% and resident tax of 9%; over 5 years, it's 15% and 5% (the special reconstruction income tax is separate). But if it's your own home, there's a special provision that lets you deduct up to ¥30 million from the profit regardless of how long you held it (with conditions, such as selling by the end of the year that contains the day 3 years after you stopped living there). The 5-year line mainly matters when selling a unit you rented out. Not following?

Well, let me pick up the side of the point of owning too. You can keep holding it and rent it out after you move. A place to come back to remains. It can also be a shield in periods when rents go up. That's right, it is right, but that's talk that assumes "you can move without having to let it go."

And, frankly, this is the most important part. The price of being light on your feet doesn't appear on the table. Being able to move right away to a city where a good opportunity came up, being able to wrap things up right away to fit your family's circumstances. If you set it to zero because you can't put a number on it, the table looks clean and the contents are sloppy. Things that don't become numbers, you leave not as zero but as a "blank." Am I wrong?

So if you're going to get your hands moving, write out your plans for the next 10 years, with how likely each move is. Like "transfer in 3 years, 70%." Then, for the year with the highest likelihood, work out the cash left over once if you sell and once if you rent it out. If both are amounts you can accept, there's a point to owning. If both are painful, that blank is bigger than you thought. Does that answer it?

Hot pots — a big earthenware pot is the best in winter when lots of people gather around it, but for someone living alone who moves a lot, it's heavy and breaks, and it's more than you can handle. A small pot is lighter on your feet. What? Rice porridge cooked in an earthenware pot tastes like an earthenware pot in any city? Oh, really. Then pay for that taste, hauling effort and all.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

This is Wang. Young people these days picture themselves 10 years ahead too much with their current address and their current employer. 10 years is long. In my case, every 10 years the town I lived in and the liquor I drank both changed.

Let me tell an old story. According to the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications' Report on Internal Migration in Japan Derived from the Basic Resident Registration, in 2021 (Reiwa 3), for the first time since 2014 (Heisei 26), when counting began to include foreign residents, the people leaving Tokyo's special wards outnumbered the people coming in. The net outflow was 14,828 people. Counting Japanese nationals only, it was the first time in 25 years, since 1996 (Heisei 8). The Statistics Bureau's commentary says the number of people moving out had increased for 7 years in a row, and increased greatly in 2020 and 2021 (Reiwa 2 and 3) in particular. As I recall, it was around the time ways of working that didn't require going to the office every day spread.

But in 2023 (Reiwa 5), the same special wards ranked first among all municipalities in the country for net inflow. 53,899 people. The wave that went out came back to the incoming side in 2 years. With a single change in how people work, where tens of thousands of people live moves, and moves back again. How many people called that 10 years ahead? I don't know a single one.

A story about the bar I frequent. I kept a bottle of kaoliang liquor there. One year, the bar moved 2 stations away. A third of the bottle was left. When I counted the train fare to go get it, it was more than the value of the liquor left. I went anyway. When I went, I was so nostalgic that I put in another bottle and came home. Keeping a bottle at a bar is like making a promise to yourself to keep going to that bar.

Now then. Owning a home has something in common with keeping a bottle. What you own holds you back in itself. From the day you decide to move, whether you sell or rent it out, it takes months to settle. In the meantime, your body is in the new place and your wallet in the old one.

Remonstrance and strong liquor work well, but flattery and sweet liquor hit you later. "The rent comes in wherever you live." "Rent is money thrown away; own, and it's an asset." They go down smoothly, and they're half true. But neither phrase includes the weight of not being able to move on the day you want to move. The bitter words, "If you may move within 10 years, look first at how long it takes to let go," are the ones that work later. Owning isn't bad in itself. The only difference is between owning knowing the weight and owning without knowing it.

Before you own, spend about a month watching how many weeks the listings for similar units for sale and for rent near that property stay up. If it's a town where many units disappear quickly, your feet won't grow heavy even when the day to move comes. If it's a town where they stay up forever, that number of weeks becomes the price tag on your lightness of foot.

With liquor and with houses alike, owning only as much as you can carry in your arms is the stylish way. If you buy a jar too big to carry, buy the resolve for the day you leave it behind along with it. Kakakaka.

Read a little deeper