BENERU
Selling and exitPublished

Can I sell a property that still has a loan on it?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Th-th-th-there it is, the "you can't sell a property that still has a loan on it" theory. The classic worry when selling. But this one is off from the way the question is framed. It looks like a choice between "can sell" and "can't sell," but inside it's just a subtraction.

Let's start from the spec. A property bought with a loan usually has a lender's mortgage on it. Buyers won't buy it with the mortgage still attached, so on the settlement (closing) day, you repay the whole loan with the money received from the buyer, and remove the mortgage the same day. So there's only one condition.

Sale price − (costs of selling) − remaining loan balance ≧ 0

If this holds, you can sell normally even with a loan remaining. If it doesn't hold, you can sell if you fill the shortfall with money on hand. If you can't fill it, you can't sell as things stand. It looks like there are 3 answers, but they're all about the sign of this formula. Get it?

Let's put in numbers. From here on, it's an assumption. Sale price ¥18 million, remaining loan balance ¥17 million. It's ¥1 million above, so plenty of room, you'd think. I mean, you would think that.

The cap on the brokerage commission is 3% of the sale price + ¥60,000, plus consumption tax. (¥18 million × 3% + ¥60,000) × 1.1 is ¥660,000. The stamp on the sale contract, for a contract made by March 31, 2027 (Reiwa 9), is reduced to ¥10,000. The fee for repaying the whole loan early depends on the lender, so here I'll put it at ¥30,000. The registration to remove the mortgage and the judicial scrivener's fee, let's also say ¥30,000.

¥18 million − ¥660,000 − ¥10,000 − ¥30,000 − ¥30,000 − ¥17 million = ¥270,000.

What looked like ¥1 million of room became ¥270,000. Am I wrong? And on top of that, if it sells for more than you paid and you make a profit, tax on the capital gains (transfer income) gets subtracted from this too.

Now flip it: what if the sale price is ¥17.5 million? The brokerage commission is (¥17.5 million × 3% + ¥60,000) × 1.1 = ¥643,500. ¥17.5 million − ¥643,500 − ¥10,000 − ¥30,000 − ¥30,000 − ¥17 million is minus ¥213,500. If you can't come up with this little over ¥210,000 yourself, you can't remove the mortgage. A difference of just ¥500,000 in the sale price flips the sign. Seriously, a razor's edge. OK?

As a last resort when you're short, there's also a voluntary sale (nin'i baikyaku), where the lender agrees to release the mortgage, but the debt you couldn't repay remains.

"Hey, you said 'usually' earlier," you say? For someone who has finished repaying, the remaining loan balance is just zero, and the formula is the same.

So what you do is put your own numbers into this formula. The remaining loan balance from your repayment schedule, the sale price from the actual closed prices of similar units, and the costs by asking the lender and the brokerage firm about each item above, one by one. Right?

Persimmons, you know, even with the same skin color, you can't tell whether one is astringent or sweet until you cut it. Same with property: it's not whether it looks "sellable" from the outside, it's cutting it open with the formula, and the sign decides. Ciao.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Whether a property with a loan still on it can be sold isn't decided on the day you sell. Half of it is decided on the day you buy.

Let me tell an old story. A few years after I started living in Japan, everyone was saying "land never goes down." According to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's White Paper on Land, in the Tokyo area in 1987 (Showa 62), both commercial and residential land rose more than 60% from the year before. But land prices in the 3 major metropolitan areas turned downward in 1991 (Heisei 3), and the regional areas followed in 1992 (Heisei 4). Residential land in the major metropolitan areas only turned upward again in 2006 (Heisei 18). A column in the white paper says that the land price index for the 3 central wards of Tokyo, with 1985 (Showa 60) as 100, was about 380 in 1991 (Heisei 3) and fell to about 65 by 2001 (Heisei 13). Those who borrowed to the hilt and bought when prices were high couldn't reach the money they borrowed even if they sold. Since they couldn't take off the mortgage, they couldn't sell even if they wanted to.

Coming down the years, in 2018 (Heisei 30), the Financial Services Agency asked banks, shinkin banks and credit cooperatives about their financing for investment real estate. The results compiled in March 2019 (Heisei 31) state that there are cases of businesses who bring loan customers to banks inflating the purchase price. If you borrow an amount matched to an inflated price tag and buy, from the day after you buy, the debt is above what the property is worth. When people notice that, it's usually on the day they try to sell.

Long ago, I too bought a bottle of kaoliang liquor from my homeland at a terribly high price. I thought, since it's the taste of Manchuria, its value won't go down. Some years later, I thought I might part with it and took it to a liquor shop, and the same liquor was on the shelf at half the price. Sell it and I lose; keep it and I want to drink it. In the end, my wife and I emptied it together that night. Kakakaka.

Well, never mind my story. When you sell a property with a loan remaining, what decides it is the difference between the remaining loan balance and the price it can sell for. That difference is mostly decided by the waves of land prices and the price tag at the time you bought. What you can do once it's time to sell is less than you'd think.

Admonishing words and strong liquor work well, but flattering words and sweet liquor hit you later. When you try to sell, you'll hear 2 voices: "It can still sell high," and "This is how much balance remains." The first is sweet to the ear. The second is bitter. But what decides whether you can sell is the bitter number.

Before you decide to sell, lay the sale contract from when you bought next to the loan agreement (kinsen shōhi taishaku keiyaku, "kinshō") from when you borrowed, and check the difference between the purchase price and the amount borrowed, in other words how much of your own money you put in at the start. The smaller that difference was, the more bitter the numbers on the day you sell. Listening to a high appraisal can wait until after you know that.

Start with a bitter cup and save the sweet one for last. With that in mind, cheers.

Read a little deeper