BENERU
Management and operationPublished

What should an owner look at when screening tenants?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Tenant screening checks whether the applicant can keep paying the rent and will live there following the rules of the contract. Specifically, this means the ratio of rent to income, the employer and length of employment, the guarantee company's screening result, the number of people who will live there, and so on. In practice, the property management company or brokerage firm collects the documents and adds its opinion, and the owner makes the final decision. Refusing solely on the grounds of nationality or age should be avoided.

Main items checked in screening

ItemWhat to check
IncomeWhether the rent is about 1/3 of monthly income or less (a guide)
Employer and length of employmentWhether the income is likely to continue
Guarantee companyWhether the applicant passed the guarantee company's screening. The scope of the guarantee (rent, restoration costs, etc.)
Joint and several guarantorThe person and their income, when not using a guarantee company or when requiring one in addition. For an individual guarantor, the guarantee is invalid unless the contract sets an upper limit on the guarantee (maximum amount) (Article 465-2 of the Civil Code)
Number of occupantsWhether it suits the size of the unit. Who other than the contracting party will live there
Identity verificationID, confirmation of employment
How the application came aboutThe applicant's manner as seen by the brokerage firm's staff member

Cases where the decision is easy to get stuck on

CaseHow to think about it
Income is somewhat low, but the applicant passed the guarantee company's screeningCompare the scope of the guarantee company's guarantee with the loss if the vacancy continues
Self-employed or freelanceCheck several years of income using tax returns and similar documents
Elderly applicantThere are options such as monitoring services, or deciding in advance how the contract and belongings left behind will be handled if the tenant dies
Applicant of foreign nationalityCheck the period of stay, an emergency contact, and whether language support is available

Points to note when refusing

ItemDetails
ReasonAvoid refusing solely on the grounds of nationality or age. There is a case in which payment of compensation for emotional distress was ordered for refusing tenancy solely on the grounds of nationality
DisabilityRefusing tenancy on the grounds of a disability is considered unfair discriminatory treatment under the Act for Eliminating Discrimination against Persons with Disabilities (the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's guidelines for response)
How to communicateThere is no obligation to explain the reason for refusal in detail, but communicate it courteously through the brokerage firm

Order of checks

  1. Ask the property management company what items it checks in screening and the guarantee company's conditions.
  2. When an application comes in, look at the ratio of rent to income, the employer, and the guarantee company's result.
  3. If you are unsure, compare the scope of the guarantee with the loss if the vacancy continues.
  4. Tell the property management company your decision, and confirm the contract conditions.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think what should be weighed most heavily in screening is the ability to pay the rent and the scope of the guarantee company's guarantee. Rather than refusing across the board based on an applicant's attributes, checking whether the loss can be contained through the guarantee arrangement also leads to fewer vacancies.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! You don't know what to look at when screening tenants. That was exactly me! And without knowing, I jumped at an ad that said "you don't need to look."

After my first tenant moved out, I found an ad on my phone for a tenant screening service. "We produce a score from the application information. Owners just look at the result!" I read it while drinking a sweet coffee and thought, this is it! Income, employer and so on, I didn't feel like I could judge any of that even if I looked. I asked the person at the property management company to get that score for me too.

An application came in. The score was the 2nd-highest rank. The explanation said "the likelihood of rent payments falling behind is low." I looked only at that, and without turning to the 2nd page of the application form, I replied, "Yes, please go ahead!"

Then, 3 months after move-in. A letter came from the owners' association. "It appears a dog is being kept in the unit. The management bylaws prohibit keeping pets." I choked on my sweet coffee!

When I hurriedly looked over the application form again, it was written right there in the remarks field. "1 small dog. Would like a unit where pets are allowed." The broker's staff member thought I had read the remarks and agreed. Well, of course — I was the only one who hadn't read it.

It's not that the scoring service is bad. What it looks at is whether the person seems able to keep paying the rent. Whether their way of living fits the building's rules isn't part of the score. I had turned the ad's "just look at the result" into "you don't need to look at anything else" all on my own.

With a condominium unit, people who rent and live there also have the same obligation as the owner to follow the management bylaws regarding how the building is used. That's a rule in the Act on Building Unit Ownership. In other words, if you let in someone whose way of living doesn't fit the bylaws, the tenant is the one who ends up in trouble, and the one bowing to the owners' association is me, the owner.

In the end, six months later the tenant moved to a place where they could live with their pet. Even though the rent was never late once. Because they were a good tenant, I still feel bad about it. It took 1 month until the next person was found, and ¥70,000 of rent didn't come in.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • The score is a guide to "can they pay," and it doesn't check whether they fit the building's rules
  • Read the application form yourself, all the way to the remarks field
  • Tell the broker the rules in the management bylaws (pets, musical instruments, etc.) at the application stage

These days, when an application form arrives, I put my sweet coffee at the edge of the desk before I read it. If I choke, the papers turn brown!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper