BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

If you wait until your annual income goes up, do your borrowing terms really get better?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. And, and, and here it is: "I'm getting a raise next year, so I'll borrow after that." The classic bit that comes up practically every year when the talk turns to credit.

No, I mean, the logic holds. If your annual income goes up, the upper limit on annual repayment goes up too. That's right, it's right — but this story only weighs one side of the scale.

Let me rearrange the two choices. It's not "wait, or now." It's "which is bigger: what increases in 1 year, or what decreases in 1 year."

What decreases is, at its core, age. Borrowing Flat 35 as a yardstick, the upper limit on the term is the shorter of "80 minus your age at application" and 35 years (as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8)). Up to 45 it stays at 35 years; from 46, the limit gets 1 year shorter for each year older.

Let me put it in numbers. All assumptions. Annual income ¥6.2 million, annual repayment on all borrowing up to 35% of annual income, interest rate for screening 3%. At 46, the term is 34 years, and the guide to what you can borrow is about ¥46.22 million. Wait 1 year, you're 47, and if your annual income goes up ¥150,000 to ¥6.35 million, the term is 33 years and it's about ¥46.52 million. The increase is only about ¥300,000. The ¥150,000 raise is almost entirely eaten by 1 year of term. With no raise, it actually goes down by about ¥790,000. Get it?

The same ¥150,000 is a different story at 40. The term stays at 35 years, so about ¥46.99 million becomes about ¥48.12 million, an increase of about ¥1.14 million. At 52, it's about ¥41.07 million to about ¥41.09 million, pretty much flat. In this example, it takes a raise of ¥110,000 at 46, and ¥150,000 at 52, just to balance 1 year's worth of shrinkage. The older you get, the thinner the amount you can win back with the same raise.

So.

Here I'll bite the other side too. Once you see that waiting barely increases your limit, don't you tend to swing to "then I have to borrow now while I can"? That's also missing one side of the scale. What this calculation shows is only that the reason to wait for a raise is weak. It says nothing about the reason to borrow being strong. A shrinking limit doesn't hurt one bit for someone who wasn't going to borrow in the first place. OK?

"Didn't you just declare that it decreases with age?" Yep. But there really are people who gain by waiting. People up to 45 whose term doesn't shrink, people with big raises, people who make progress on a down payment or paying off other borrowing while they wait. On the other hand, a plan that counts on a raise that "should" come tends to rest on super flimsy grounds. A raise is a projection; age is certain. Am I wrong?

So what you do is three lines. Your current age and annual income; 1 year older with the raise; 1 year older with no raise. Work out the guide to what you can borrow for these three and line them up. The difference between the second and third lines is the amount you're betting on the raise. Honestly, if that difference is smaller than you thought, your reason to wait isn't the raise but somewhere else.

You know small turnips? Expose them to the first frost and they get sweeter, but get greedy and leave them in the field too long, and they get hollow, spongy pockets inside. Waiting is worth it until the frost comes. The day you pull them, look at the field and decide yourself.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Me too, exactly that! I'm right in the middle of waiting, thinking "I'll buy my 2nd unit after I'm promoted and my annual income goes up"!

It started last fall. My promotion to chief was informally decided, and when I told a senior colleague in the cafeteria, they said, "Congratulations! As chief, your annual income will go up by ¥500,000, right? Then the amount you can borrow will go up by about ¥5 million too." I said "I see!" and nodded big, with a piece of fried chicken still in my chopsticks. I didn't do any calculating. Right there I decided to put off the 2nd unit for 1 year, went home, and wrote "Next fall: 2nd unit" on the calendar.

And this spring I got promoted. I looked at my pay slip and was shocked. My base pay and position allowance went up, but the overtime pay line was gone! At my company, apparently there's no overtime pay from chief up. Overtime pay came to about ¥400,000 a year, so in terms of annual income, it only went up by about ¥180,000.

It still went up, it did! I told myself, and the other day I went to a bank counter to ask about it. That's where the second shock came. "In screening, as a rule we look at the previous year's income on documents." The withholding tax slip for the year I was promoted covers 3 months before the promotion and 9 months after. The year that shows my full post-promotion annual income is next year's, and that comes out at the start of the year after next. What I meant as a 1-year wait was a 2-year wait!

"Promoted, but my annual income is basically flat? So only my title changed!" I blurted out, calling myself out, and the person at the counter smiled and turned to the next page: "Now, next, about your other borrowing." Brushed right past!

At home, I calculated my senior's "¥5 million" myself. Assuming up to 35% of annual income can go to repayment, with a screening rate of 3% over 35 years, a ¥500,000 increase raises it by only about ¥3.79 million. With my ¥180,000, it's about ¥1.36 million. My senior's number was a rough guide, and my senior did nothing wrong. The one who nodded and then never once punched a calculator was me.

Also, if the bank I borrow from has an upper limit of 75 on age at full repayment, I can only take a 35-year loan until 40. Wait 2 years, and I start worrying about another hourglass too.

There are three things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • Calculate a raise not by how the gross amount grows, but by annual income after subtracting things that disappear, like overtime pay
  • What screening sees is the previous year's annual income. First count which year's documents the raise will show up on
  • When someone says "It'll go up by ¥◯ million," take out a calculator on the spot

I crossed out "Next fall: 2nd unit" on the calendar with a double line and rewrote it as "Spring of the year after next: calculator." A calculator in my schedule... what am I even doing!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper