BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished Updated

Why do people say "real estate investment is for salaried workers above all"?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Do you remember March 1990 (Heisei 2)? Young people may not have been born yet.

That month, the state asked lenders to keep the growth of lending to the real estate industry below the growth of lending as a whole. What people call the total volume restriction. Land prices kept rising, and neither lenders nor borrowers could stop. The tap was tightened, and in 1991 (Heisei 3) land prices in the major metropolitan areas began to fall. According to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's White Paper on Land, residential land in the major metropolitan areas turned upward in 2006 (Heisei 18). It kept falling for about 15 years.

Coming down through time, in March 2019 (Heisei 31), the Financial Services Agency compiled the results of asking banks and others about financing for investment real estate. Read it and the true nature of "for salaried workers above all" shows clearly. It describes high-leverage investment in which salaried workers and others buy land and building together to build assets. When assessing the ability to repay, 95% of banks take the customer's salary income into account. It even says that some look at repayment by combining rent and salary, so that lending that couldn't be repaid from the property's rent alone gets through. Worse still, among the businesses connecting customers to banks, there were some who altered bankbooks and withholding tax statements to make customers' assets and income look larger than they really were.

In other words, it's like this. The reason office workers are said to have an advantage in real estate isn't that the properties are good. It's that they have a salary — a source of repayment that comes in exactly every month — so it's easy for the lender to lend. That's all there is to it. Then people appeared who tried to make them use that ease of lending to the full, and even inflated the paperwork.

I too once, long ago, got flattered at a regular bar — "Mr. Wang, you can really hold your drink" — and nearly emptied a whole isshōbin bottle. When you're told you're strong, you want to show how strong you are. The next morning, when I looked at the bill, there was even drink on it I had no memory of drinking. The owner said, "The strong ones never remember." He got me there.

Well, never mind my story.

When you get greedy, it usually goes like this. You mistake the amount you're told you can borrow for the amount it's fine to borrow. The stronger the backing of a salary, the longer a property's weakness stays hidden. While it's hidden, you buy a second, then a third. Before 1990 (Heisei 2), and before the 2019 (Heisei 31) survey, in my view, the tap opened too far when the greed of lenders and borrowers meshed.

I'll say just one thing. Gather the bankbook and withholding tax statement you submit to the bank with your own hands, without handing them to anyone, and keep copies identical to what you submitted. If your income is being described in numbers you don't know, you can no longer measure that loan with your own ruler.

With drink, the day you're told you're strong is the day you most need to count your cups. Salary is the same. Kakakaka.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! "Real estate investment is for salaried workers above all." That was exactly me! I'm one of the people who started because of that one line!

What hit hardest was this line from the person in charge: "For company employees, even if there's a loss, the tax on your salary comes back through your tax return, so it's practically break-even." Break-even! That means I won't lose! — is how my head translated it on its own.

Actually, that part is half true. According to the National Tax Agency's explanation, a loss from real estate income can be offset against other income, like salary. This is called offsetting losses against other income. Company employees have tax taken from their salary in advance, so the offset amount comes back through the tax return.

But what comes back wasn't "the full amount of the loss." Only the loss times my own tax rate.

My first year went like this. Because of vacancy and repairs, the money that left my bankbook exceeded the rent by ¥240,000 a year. The loss on the books, including depreciation, was ¥400,000 (the numbers are rounded). If my tax rate is 10% income tax and 10% resident tax, then even if all of it could be offset, about ¥40,000 of income tax comes back and the next year's resident tax drops by about ¥40,000. About ¥80,000 in total. ¥240,000 goes out and ¥80,000 comes back. Far from break-even, that's ¥160,000 out of pocket!

What's more, there's a rule that the part of the loss corresponding to interest on borrowing used to buy the land can't be offset against salary. Even a condominium unit has a share of land, so not all of my loss could be offset. What came back was less than ¥80,000.

The person in charge didn't lie. "The tax comes back" is true. It was my ears that converted break-even into "all the money comes back." I could borrow because I had a salary, and I could bear the out-of-pocket because I had a salary. I think that part is a company employee's strength. But that salary also brought along a feeling of "it's fine even with a loss"!

Three things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • The tax that comes back is the loss × your own tax rate. The loss itself doesn't come back
  • The part for interest on borrowing used to buy the land can't be offset against salary
  • When you hear "break-even" or "a good deal," ask in numbers how many yen go out and how many come back each year

When I told this to the greengrocer guy in the Koiwa shopping street, he laughed: "Even a cabbage only gets cheaper by what's on the discount sticker." Just like a ¥200 cabbage doesn't become free, a loss only gets smaller by your tax rate. Now I calculate even the number on the sticker before buying a cabbage!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper