BENERU
Management and operationPublished Updated

Why does sublease rent go down?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Sublease (master lease of the whole property) rent can go down even during the contract period. The sublease company is in the position of the "lessee" renting the property from the owner, and it is held that it can request a rent reduction under the Act on Land and Building Leases (Shakuchi Shakuya Hō). Even if you are told "rent guarantee" or "30-year master lease," the same rent will not necessarily continue for 30 years.

How a sublease works

ItemDetails
OwnerRents the property to the sublease company (lessor)
Sublease companySublets the property rented from the owner to tenants (lessee)
Rent the owner receivesNot the tenants' rent, but the rent set in the contract with the sublease company

Main reasons rent goes down

ReasonDetails
Review under the contractContracts often state that rent is reviewed at set intervals
Request for rent reductionAs the lessee, the company can request a reduction on grounds such as a fall in surrounding rents
Age of the buildingAs the building ages, the rent that can be collected from tenants falls, and that is reflected

Why it is hard for the owner to cancel

Because the owner is the lessor, cancellation by the owner is held to require just cause under the Act on Land and Building Leases. On the other hand, cancellation by the sublease company may be possible on the conditions set in the contract.

Regulation by law

Under the Act on Proper Rental Housing Management Operations, sublease operators are prohibited from exaggerated advertising and improper solicitation, and are required to give an explanation of important matters before the contract. The possibility that rent will be reduced, and the conditions for terminating the contract, are also among the matters that must be explained.

Order of checks

  1. In the contract, check the timing and method of rent reviews.
  2. Receive an explanation that rent reduction can be requested, and of its conditions.
  3. Check the conditions for cancellation by the owner and the conditions for cancellation by the sublease company.
  4. Run the numbers on loan repayment and cash flow if rent falls by 10% or 20%.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think a sublease should be signed only after assuming rent will go down and running the numbers on whether the loan can be repaid even at the lower rent. This is because the word "guarantee" often refers not to the amount of rent but to payments being made even when units are vacant.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hi, it's Jamie! Why does sublease rent go down? This is something that actually happened with my grandpa's apartment building.

When my grandpa built the apartment building, the company that built it recommended a "30-year master lease." Even if there were vacancies, a fixed rent would come in every month. They would handle all the management too. Since he had borrowed money to build it, my grandpa thought it would be a big help to have the monthly rent fixed, so he signed the contract.

For the first 10 years, the rent really didn't change. But in the 10th year, a notice came from the sublease company: "Rents in the surrounding market have fallen, so we would like to review the rent." The amount offered was more than 10% lower than before.

Apparently my grandpa got angry: "You said 30-year master lease!" But when he reread the contract, it said "the rent will be reviewed at set intervals." It said they would rent it for 30 years, but it didn't say the rent would be the same for 30 years.

And something I found out when I looked into it later: the sublease company is in the position of a "lessee" renting the property from the owner. So, just like an ordinary tenant, it can request that the rent be lowered. Ending the contract from the owner's side isn't easy.

In the end, my grandpa accepted the reduction. Loan repayments just barely kept going, but the money left in hand dropped quite a bit. After that, the rent kept going down every few years. In the end, he talked it over with the sublease company and ended the contract, left only the management to a property management company, and went back to renting directly to tenants.

Now, by law, it's required to explain, before a sublease contract, the possibility that rent will go down and the conditions for cancellation. In my grandpa's time, it seems he wasn't given that much explanation.

If I ever hear a sublease pitch, the first thing I'll run the numbers on is the case where rent falls by 20%. Whether the loan can be repaid then.

Three things I'd tell myself back then.

  • "30-year master lease" and "the same rent for 30 years" are different
  • Check the rent review and cancellation conditions in the contract
  • Run the numbers on whether the loan can be repaid even if rent goes down

The contract my grandpa left behind is now with my dad. The review clause is underlined in red, and it jumps out at you even without glasses!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper