Is it true that "salaryman landlords lie dead in heaps"?
"Leave-it-to-us investment" is an advertising phrase, and the premise that "salaryman landlords lie dead in heaps" is not happening. Most people who feel they have failed were not deceived; they simply do not understand the structure of the returns.

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.
I answered this question on a Q&A site.
"Salaryman landlords" who swallowed real estate success books whole lie dead in heaps. What do you think of the far-too-dark tactics of the real estate industry, which targets "leave-it-to-us investment"?
I will answer as a specialist.
Since it says people swallowed "books" whole, I did a little searching, and there certainly are books with titles that have that kind of air. As this question itself already concludes, I think not "swallowing it whole" is the way to protect yourself. Exactly so.
Now, that the "far-too-dark tactics of the real estate industry" refers to "targeting 'leave-it-to-us investment'" is something you can't tell without reading a bit between the lines.
Book titles are provocative because "otherwise people won't pick them up."
That is what catchphrases are, so they have to be written so that people think they look even a little interesting or useful.
The purpose of a book is "to sell," not to convey correct information to you.
There may be a correlation in which correct information raises the book's reputation and as a result it sells, but that is something readers have to judge for themselves.
These days, getting a book published is something you can do if you pay. There are probably also businesses that publish books as a way of building credibility.
In other words, I think it is clear that "leave-it-to-us investment" is advertising copy, and that what matters is the body of the book. It is the same as English conversation materials saying "easy, anyone can learn."
"Dead in heaps" is not happening
Then why are salaryman landlords lying dead in heaps coming into being?
The answer is that "salaryman landlords lying dead in heaps" has not happened at all. There is a misperception of the facts here.
By the way, the reason I decided to write an answer to this question is that many people were concerned about it. I thought, so there are people concerned even about something like this. I am writing in the hope of contributing something. But I can't help thinking: what do the people who are concerned want to know?
I suppose it is the "far-too-dark tactics of the real estate industry."
Then I wonder, what are these far-too-dark tactics? I even sense something like a wish that they be far too dark.
Surely it is because there are far-too-dark industry tactics that salaryman landlords lying dead in heaps are coming into being. I think many people expect that kind of episode there. Somehow, they want it to be so.
Now, going back, let me tell you the reality once again.
The salaryman landlords described here as lying dead in heaps are very few. There are surely not nearly enough of them to be called dead in heaps.
The premise of the question is not happening as an event.
It is an image of "this sort of thing seems likely," and, if anything, a wish that it were so.
What failure really is: lack of understanding
"Almost all" of those who think they failed at real estate investment simply lack understanding. Purely because their understanding falls short, they are just making a fuss that they must have been deceived.
They were told "leave it all to us," left it, and are just making a fuss that they took a "loss."
It goes without saying, but they are investing.
Who is doing it? Why, the person who invested, of course. Even if they cry that they were made to do it, objectively it is something that person did on their own.
Making a fuss because it did not turn out as they wanted is wrong. It is something they themselves should do as the main actor, so naturally they should learn.
Let me repeat it once more.
"Almost all" of those who think they failed at real estate investment simply lack understanding.
As far as I can see, the majority have actually not lost anything.
They just don't understand.
They simply don't understand the structure of the returns of real estate investment.
For example, among everyone who does real estate investment, the people who dabble in a regional apartment building and go bankrupt—there are no statistics, but in my own sense of it—easily fall below 1% as a proportion.
You would not call this dead in heaps.
There seem to be cases where people who bought a newly built studio condominium and have out-of-pocket costs make a fuss that they were defrauded, but there is hardly anyone who goes as far as bankruptcy from the out-of-pocket costs of 1 unit.
If anything, they have room to build assets from here on, so first of all they should study. Selling in a panic is precisely what locks in the loss, so they should not do it.
And businesses that handle apartment buildings and businesses that handle studio units are completely different things. You cannot lump them together.
"I didn't know" does not cut it
What people who invested without studying and were deceived say is something like the following.
I didn't know the repair reserve fund would keep going up, I didn't know rent would go down, I didn't know repairing equipment would cost money, I didn't know tenant placement would cost advertising fees.
Exactly. They don't know. This is what is called lack of understanding. It is like thinking that the monthly out-of-pocket amount is your investment profit. That too is lack of understanding. It is not "I didn't know"; these are things you must know.
Investment profit is how much your net worth increases.
People without experience probably won't understand even if they read these. That is exactly the point.
They don't understand.
Because they don't understand, they believe things told through images.
They believe what is being made a fuss of in the news.
They don't really trust the opinions of people who actually run income properties, which you also see on online Q&A sites, and instead gather opinions that make a fuss of "it must be fraud!" in order to convince "themselves for not taking it on."
I don't quite understand what the "far-too-dark tactics of the real estate industry" are. There are some, right? Come on, surely some pitch-black ones. After all, it's the real estate industry, where all kinds of demons and goblins dwell, so how could there not be? I suppose it is an assumption like this.
I understand very well that there are people somehow stirring up anxiety. If you are interested in income properties and want to come into contact with solid information, first of all, do not swallow rumors whole.
Raising your financial literacy is, more than anything, what will clear away your anxiety.


