BENERU
Market and macroPublished

How different are the prices on property portal sites from the prices properties actually sold for?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Let me ask first. Do you want to buy from here? Want to sell? Or do you just want to know the market? You might think "hold on a sec," but depending on the answer, what you'd use "how different" for changes completely.

Answer first: there's no fixed difference. The price on a portal site is the price the seller hopes for, and the sold price is the price settled after negotiation. The difference between them changes every time with the property, the timing and the seller's circumstances. Even if you memorize one "roughly X%," that number won't fit the unit in front of you.

The reason is that the portal price isn't "the market," it's "the starting point." Sellers list high, watch the response and lower it. Brokerage firms that want to be given the job of selling sometimes give high appraisals too. So the listed price often already has room to come down built in. What's more, units that sold quickly disappear from the site, and units that didn't sell stay listed for a long time. The list you look at every night is a sample skewed toward the higher end of the market. Don't get it?

But, you know, there are opposite situations too. A unit in good condition at a popular station can be settled at the full price the very week it's listed, or the price can go up when several buyers overlap. So locking in "the market is X% off the portal price" is a different bug. The accurate version is: there are units that come down and units that don't.

So how do you check? On the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Real Estate Information Library, pick out several transaction prices for units in the same district with similar size and age. The timing is by quarter and the street number isn't shown, so don't compare pinpoint with a single case; look at it as a range. Then note down since when the unit you're interested in has been listed on the site, and whether it was lowered along the way. Honestly, this note works best. A unit that's been listed a long time and never lowered is either a seller who's bullish or one who's in no hurry. Don't you think?

Back to my first question. If you want to buy, use that range as the basis for negotiation. If you want to sell, set your price by looking at where your unit sits within the range, not at the asking prices around you. If you list too high and stay listed a long time, that itself becomes a mark of an unsold unit, and you end up lowering it anyway. If you just want to know the market, the portal is the place to see "what's for sale now," and "what it sold for" is something you look at somewhere else. Does that answer it?

You know taro? If you judge the size with the skin on, it's a size smaller once you peel it. The portal price is the weight with the skin on, and the sold price is the weight after peeling. What? Your taro was still big after peeling? Oh, OK. That's the same as a unit at a popular station. It happens sometimes.

Sources (in Japanese)

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! Have you ever seen a "bargain property ranking" in a real estate app? I have. And I bought the No. 1 property!

Back when I was looking for a condominium unit, I opened the app every morning on my commuter train. The ad copy said, "AI judges the market — see bargain properties at a glance." One morning, No. 1 was an 18-year-old studio unit for ¥15.8 million. "About ¥2 million below the local market!" it said in red. Looking at units for sale in the same area, they were lined up in the ¥17 million to ¥18 million range. This is the real deal! I thought, and I sent an inquiry on my lunch break.

I did a viewing and submitted a letter of intent to purchase that same week. I didn't negotiate the price. I mean, it was already ¥2 million below the market. I felt like if I haggled, someone else would grab it.

About half a year after buying, I opened the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Real Estate Information Library for the first time. When I looked at transaction prices for studio units in the same district with similar size and age, many were from the high ¥13 million range to the ¥14 million range. The ¥15.8 million I paid was nearly ¥1 million higher than the very top of that range!

When I later read the app's explanation carefully, the "local market" was a guide based on the prices of units for sale at the time. The price of a unit for sale is the price the seller hopes for. It was just comparing hoped-for prices with each other and showing "bargain" — it wasn't comparing with what units actually sold for. The moment I saw the words "No. 1," I lost any interest in reading that explanation.

The rent comes in fine, and I like the unit. But when I sell, it'll probably get a price close to the range of transaction prices. The nearly ¥1 million I overpaid I can only win back little by little from the rent while I own it.

When I told my mom this story, she laughed and said, "You've always only ordered things that say 'Today's recommendation,' haven't you?" Ever since, every time we meet at New Year's she asks, "So, which is the next No. 1?"

Three things I'd tell myself back then:

  • Check whether the "market" in "cheaper than the market" is asking prices or transaction prices
  • Before sending an inquiry, look at several transaction prices with similar conditions in the Real Estate Information Library
  • Even if it looks like a bargain, negotiate at least once using the range of transaction prices as your basis

Now I try not to open the app's rankings. To my mom's "Which is the next No. 1?" I always answer, "Somewhere around the middle of the transaction prices"!

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper