BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

If properties are expensive, can I buy cheaply by haggling hard on everything?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. When I came over from Manchuria, I was still a young fellow. I grew up being told in the markets over there that anyone who buys at the asking price doesn't know a thing, so even after coming to Japan I haggled at the greengrocer's and made the lady's eyes go round. That's when I learned it's uncouth to haggle in a shop with price tags. But the price tag on real estate is one you're allowed to negotiate. That's what makes it interesting.

Let me tell an old story. As far as I saw, in the old days a buyer had almost no way of knowing what nearby properties had actually sold for. That began to change in 2006 (Heisei 18). From April 27, 2006 (Heisei 18), the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism began publishing actual transaction prices on its website. They were gathered by sending questionnaires to buyers based on registration information, and at first 17,609 cases in places such as Tokyo's 23 wards, Yokohama and Osaka were posted, processed so the properties couldn't be identified. Then on April 1, 2024 (Reiwa 6), the "Real Estate Information Library" went into operation, and anyone could see on a smartphone not only transaction prices but even information based on REINS closing prices.

What you have to watch out for is that those numbers don't belong only to buyers. Sellers and brokers look at the same numbers when they set prices. The gap of "the other side may not know the market" has become a good deal smaller than in the old days. Even if you haggle hard on everything, a seller who watches the market will see right away that it's a number with no basis.

Let me talk about drink. Kaoliang is a distilled spirit made from sorghum, the drink of my hometown. Shaoxing wine is a brewed wine named after Shaoxing in Zhejiang, and there's a tradition of making it in the year a daughter is born and opening it when she marries. Some people drink Shaoxing wine with rock sugar dropped in, but there are those who say that's a way of covering up a harsh wine. The stuff from a good jar is tasty without adding anything. Prices are the same. A property that the seller will let go even after a big cut often has a harshness they want to hide with sugar.

People have always been like that. There are those who want to buy cheap and those who want to sell high, and both sides want to come out ahead. Thinking "fire enough shots and one will hit" is human nature too. But the one that hits may be the wine with its harshness hidden.

So where are the properties whose price comes down a lot? Not in the number on the price tag, but in the seller's circumstances. It's been unsold for a long time, they urgently need cash, it's become more than they can handle. What you look at isn't the price tag, it's the seller's clock.

Before you make an offer, ask the broker this. "Since when has this property been on the market, and has the price ever been lowered?" A property that hasn't moved for half a year and has been cut 2 times, and one that only went up last week — the same 10%-off offer carries completely different weight.

You won't die from being turned down. With haggling, the learning starts after you're turned down. Kakakaka.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I've tried negotiating a big price cut too. I read online that "the limit price (sashine) is important" and got all fired up.

A second-hand studio unit I found on a property portal site, ¥15 million. I told the broker's person in charge, "I'll buy it for ¥12 million." 20% off! I didn't have any particular basis, it was more like "let's just say it strongly for now."

The person in charge passed it on to the seller. The reply was "nothing to consider." Well, yeah, I thought. But I didn't give up, and I made offers on other properties the same way, at 20% off. 5 properties, 10 properties.

Then, at around the 11th, the person in charge said to me, "Jamie, do you have any material you could use to explain to the seller why it's that amount?"

I couldn't say anything. I remember my face getting hot. I hadn't looked into what places nearby were actually selling for, or when that unit would need repairs. I was just saying "it feels expensive, so lower it."

The person in charge went on to tell me this: "If the amount has a basis, sometimes the seller will consider it. For example, what similar units nearby have recently closed at."

So I changed my approach. I looked up nearby transaction prices in the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Real Estate Information Library. I also checked the balance of the repair reserve fund and the plans for major repairs. Then I said, "Nearby closings are around this much, and the repair plans are like this, so how about this amount?" Not all of it went through, but the price came down by several hundred thousand yen.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Attach a basis, such as nearby transaction prices, to the amount of the price cut
  • Rather than firing off lots of offers, look into each one before making an offer
  • Get the person in charge to see you as "a customer who can close a deal"

By the way, the people in charge I contacted for the first 10, they didn't send me any property information for a while after that. Well, of course not! I told myself, wiping my glasses!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper