BENERU
Market and macroPublished Updated

Should I buy while real estate prices are still rising?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm warming a ten-year-old Shaoxing wine. It's one I bought by the case in a hurry at the end of last year, when I heard the price was going to go up.

Let me tell you an old story. In June 1987 (Showa 62), the government amended the National Land Use Planning Act and brought in a system called "monitored areas." It made people file notifications even for the sale of small plots of land, to hold down speculative deals. If the government went as far as amending a law to rein in speculation, there must have been that many people running after it. That's my own reading, mind you.

Even so, it didn't stop, and in March 1990 (Heisei 2) lenders were asked to hold the growth of their lending to the real estate industry at or below the growth of their lending overall. That's what they call the "total volume restriction." According to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's 2019 (Reiwa 1) White Paper on Land, land prices in the three major metropolitan areas turned downward in 1991 (Heisei 3), and the long decline continued until commercial land in the major metropolitan areas turned upward in 2005 (Heisei 17) and residential land in 2006 (Heisei 18). For residential land, that's 15 years.

From the introduction of monitored areas until land prices started to fall was about 4 years. In those 4 years there must have been plenty of people who bought "while they still could." While prices are rising, the reasons they'll keep rising are the ones you hear most clearly.

When I showed my wife this case of Shaoxing wine, she said, "You say you bought it before the price went up, but the bottles you bought last autumn are still on the shelf." I shot back, "The longer you let it age, the better it gets." She said, "You're not aging it. You're forgetting it." Kakakaka. I had nothing to say to that.

Looking at the 2026 (Reiwa 8) Land Price Publication, the national average for all uses rose for 5 years in a row. On the numbers, prices are indeed pointing up. But looking at how things went from the end of Showa to the start of Heisei, it's better to treat the mood of a rising period and the speed once prices start to fall as two separate things. The start of a rise shows up in the numbers, but where the ceiling was, you only know when you look back later. In the year monitored areas were introduced, and in the year the total volume restriction was imposed, land prices still hadn't fallen. They started to fall after that.

People don't change. But they can learn. The urge to run while prices are rising is surely the same for the people of 1987 (Showa 62) and the people of Reiwa. The difference is that the people of Reiwa can read in a white paper what happened next.

If it were me, I'd find the Land Price Publication point near the property I'm thinking of buying and line up its values from the oldest year I could go back to. How many years that point rose, how many years it fell, and when it fell, how many years it took to come back. After looking at those numbers, I'd think about whether I could wait that long.

Just one word for the young ones. Wine you were rushed into buying usually ends up asleep at the back of the shelf. Before the price rise, count how many years you can hold the thing yourself, and then buy.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "What is this?" — that was my first thought. "Better to buy while prices are rising" — it doesn't say whose mouth that came out of at all. The words are walking around on their own. So before the content, I look at the wallet of the person saying it.

When you buy a property, let's line up the people who get paid. The seller gains more the higher it sells. The brokerage firm gets a commission when the deal closes. As the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's guidance for consumers says, the cap on the commission is set by rates based on the purchase price; for a ¥50 million property the cap is ¥1.716 million including tax. If the same property goes up 10% to ¥55 million, it's ¥1.881 million. The lender earns more interest the more it lends.

There's something in common here. For all of them, money moves at the moment you "buy" or the moment you "borrow." Even if the price falls after you buy, the commission doesn't come back, and the sale price doesn't go back. If you wait, nobody gets a single yen in the meantime. Am I wrong? So "while you still can" is a perfectly logical thing for the person saying it to say. Not out of malice — just as a matter of how the system works.

I mean, that doesn't make the person saying it a liar. It's a fact that the market is rising, and some people say it genuinely thinking of the customer. It's right, it's right — but when the direction of the words and the direction of the pay point the same way, you discount the weight of those words a little. That's the buyer's etiquette.

If I stopped here, I wouldn't deserve the name sharp-tongued debugger. So, which way is your own wallet pointing? The buyer gains in two cases: when the rent keeps things running while you hold it, and when you sell for more than you paid. The first one is decided by your property's numbers. The second one is decided by the next buyer's circumstances. "While prices are rising" is a bet on the second one. This is the important part. Keeping up?

And let me pick up the other side too. The risk of being left behind if you wait is totally real. If prices keep rising, a property you could have bought goes out of reach. Honestly, waiting has a cost too. So I'm not saying "wait" either. What I want to say is that the timing is decided by your own property's numbers, not by someone's "while you still can."

How to check. For the deal you're about to make, write down everyone who receives money, and line up side by side how much each of them receives "when you buy," "when you don't buy," and "when you buy and the price falls." If the third column stays the same amounts as the first column, and you're the only one who takes the hit from the price drop, then filling in that column is your job. Starting to see it?

You know new-crop rice — the price goes up the moment the "new crop" tag goes on, but the one putting the tag on is the shop, and the one cooking and eating it is you. Not the words on the tag — taste it from your own bowl before you buy. Ciao.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper