BENERU
Selling and exitPublished Updated

If I sell an investment property at a loss, can I offset it against my other income?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Even if you sell an investment property at a loss, that loss (transfer loss) cannot be offset against other income such as salary income. It cannot be carried forward to the following year or later either. If, in the same year, you sold other land or buildings at a profit, it can be offset against that profit. Only when you sell your own home is there a special provision that allows offsetting against other income and carrying forward under certain conditions.

How a transfer loss is treated

CaseOffsetting against other incomeCarrying forward to the following year or later
A loss on selling investment land or buildingsNot possibleNot possible
In the same year, there is a gain on selling other land or buildingsCan be offset against the gain—
A loss on selling your own home (under certain conditions, such as buying a replacement)Possible (special provision)Possible for 3 years (special provision)

Capital gains (transfer income) from land and buildings are taxed separately from salary and other income (separate taxation), so the system only lets losses and gains be netted within that category.

Calculating a transfer loss

ItemDetails
Sale amountThe sale price
Acquisition costThe purchase amount minus the accumulated depreciation of the building
Costs of sellingBrokerage commission, stamp duty, etc.
Transfer gain or lossSale amount − (acquisition cost + costs of selling)

Trial calculation

The case of a condominium unit bought for ¥20 million and sold 10 years later for ¥15 million. Assume the building's accumulated depreciation is ¥4 million and the costs of selling are ¥600,000.

ItemAmount
Acquisition cost¥20 million − ¥4 million = ¥16 million
Transfer gain or loss¥15 million − (¥16 million + ¥600,000) = −¥1.6 million

It was sold for ¥5 million less than the purchase amount, but the loss for tax purposes is ¥1.6 million. This ¥1.6 million cannot be offset against salary income.

Order of checks

  1. Calculate the acquisition cost from the sale contract and the depreciation records.
  2. Add the costs of selling and work out the transfer gain or loss.
  3. Check whether, in the same year, there is a gain on selling other land or buildings.
  4. Even if there is a loss, check with the tax office or a tax accountant whether a capital gains return is required.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the idea that "if I sell at a loss, I will get tax back" is wrong for investment property. When thinking about when to sell, you should calculate the money left in hand on the assumption that no tax comes back even if there is a loss.

Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! If you sell real estate at a loss, can you offset it against your other income? This is a story from when my father sold an old condominium unit.

Even before inheriting my grandfather's apartment building, my father owned one small condominium unit. He'd bought it nearly 30 years ago, and the building was quite old. When the tenant moved out, he took that as the moment to sell.

The price when he bought it was about ¥20 million. The price it sold for was a little over ¥10 million. My father said, "I lost ¥10 million. But the loss can be offset against my salary from the company, so I should get tax back." At the time, my father was still working at a company, and his salary was fairly good.

I thought that was how it worked too. I'd heard that when rental income runs a loss, it can be offset against salary, so I figured selling at a loss was the same.

But when we asked a tax accountant before the tax return, we were told 2 things.

First, a loss from selling investment real estate can't be offset against salary. It's treated differently from a loss on rental income; profits and losses from selling land or buildings are calculated separately. It can't be carried forward to the next year either. If, in the same year, you sold other land or buildings at a profit, it can be netted against that profit, but my father didn't have any sale like that.

Second, in the first place, in the tax calculation it wasn't a ¥10 million loss at all. Subtract nearly 30 years of depreciation from the purchase price, and the acquisition cost on the books gets quite small. Compare that with the sale price, and there was hardly any loss. The building's share of the apparent loss had, apparently, been used little by little as expenses in calculating 30 years of rental income.

My father was a bit disappointed. He'd thought tax would come back, and had apparently even made plans to go on a trip with that money. But the tax accountant laughed and said, "On the other hand, you won't owe any tax either."

There are 3 things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • A loss from selling investment real estate can't be offset against salary
  • Whether it's a loss is calculated using the acquisition cost after subtracting depreciation
  • Before selling, check whether tax will be owed or come back

In the end, my father went on the trip anyway. I hear the tax that didn't come back came out of his savings.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper