BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

A property that cannot be rebuilt is cheap. Should I buy it?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Noticing the low price is a good eye. Finding a price that's off the market is the entrance to property hunting. But you're still soft. You stopped at the point where you found the number on the price tag.

I'm going to bite. "Cheap" compared with what? If you're comparing it with the land next door that can be rebuilt on, the comparison is off. That price includes the land, the building, and "being able to build again in the future." This one is missing that last piece. All that's happened is the missing piece has been taken off — nobody is giving you a bonus.

No, well, there are properties where too much has been taken off. Loans are hard to get, so buyers are narrowed down to people with cash. When there are few buyers, the price moves toward what the buyer asks. So sometimes it's a tiny bit cheaper than just the value of not being able to build. That much is right.

But of course, here's the real point. The price of this property can only be seen as the sum of two things. How many more years the building can be rented out, and the cash left over during that time. And the price of the land that remains after the building can no longer be used.

I'll set it all as assumptions. A ¥6 million detached house with rent of ¥60,000 a month. That's ¥720,000 a year, so the gross yield is 12%. If 3 in 10 (30%) disappears into expenses and vacancy, the cash left over is ¥504,000 a year. It takes about 11.9 years to get the ¥6 million back. If the building lasts another 15 years, you get it back with some to spare. If it only lasts another 10 years, the cash left over is ¥5.04 million, and the missing ¥960,000 has to be filled by the sale price of land that can't be built on. Am I wrong?

And that land's sale price is, honestly, the hardest thing to read. The likely buyers are the neighbor or some oddball who pays cash. So run the calculation once to see whether it's worth it even with the land price set to zero. In the example above, it's roughly break-even if the building lasts 12 years. Whether it lasts 12 years is the core of this purchase.

What, you could buy the neighboring land so it touches the road? Yeah, sometimes you can. There are also exceptions where building is allowed by the certification or permission of the designated administrative agency. But that depends on the neighbor and the government office; it isn't something you get to decide. Putting something you can't decide into the premise of the calculation is sloppy design. Don't you see?

So the order of looking is reversed. The building's lifespan comes before the price tag. Have an expert check the building's condition (that's the thing called an inspection), and turn the leaks, the foundation and the wear on the roof into a number: how many more years it can be rented. Does the cash left over for that many years reach the purchase price even with the land price at zero? If it does, there's room to consider it. If it doesn't, it isn't cheap — it's priced for what it is. You know?

New-crop rice, you know, tastes best freshly cooked, but only while it's in the pot. After the pot is empty, the value of that rice is decided by whether there's a paddy where it can be grown again.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm having sweet potato shochu with hot water. The aroma rises with the steam, and on a night that's turning cold, this is the thing. Ka-ka-ka-ka, that's about the size of an old man's pleasures.

What I remember is a house where I rented a room not long after I came to Japan. It was at the back of an alley barely wide enough for two people to pass. The landlord told me, "This house can't be rebuilt," and I tilted my head — a house that stands but can't be rebuilt, what a strange thing.

Well, never mind my story. The reason lies in old rules. According to material from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, the Urban Building Act was made in 1919 (Taisho 8). It applied only to large cities, but it brought in a rule requiring sites to touch a road, and a system of building lines to secure the space for roads. In 1950 (Showa 25) the Building Standards Act was made, and the road-frontage rule was carried over into this law. Under the current rule, a building's site must in principle touch a road at least 4 m wide for at least 2 m. Roads under 4 m wide, where houses had stood in rows since long ago, were saved by a system that treats them as roads if the designated administrative agency designates them (the so-called Article 42(2) roads). But there is land that slipped through even that net: land that can only reach a passage not recognized as a road. The house standing there can be used, but once it's torn down, in principle a new one can't be built. In my reading, most properties that can't be rebuilt are land that fell into the gap between a town's shape, older than the law, and rules that came later.

There is also a gate through the gap. Even without 2 m of road frontage, there is an exception where building is allowed if the site meets standards such as having a wide open space around it and the designated administrative agency recognizes there is no problem and grants permission; this required the consent of the building review board. With the amendment that took effect on September 25, 2018 (Heisei 30), a system was created under which buildings meeting certain standards need only certification, without the board's consent. The gate widened a little. But it didn't become a gate anyone can pass through. Whether you can pass depends on the width and shape of the passage and on that office's standards.

Admonition and strong liquor work well; flattery and sweet liquor hit you later. Words like "half the market price" and "high yield" are sweet liquor. They go down smoothly, so they slip right in. "This can't be built on as it is," heard at the government office counter, is strong liquor. It burns the throat. But it's the one that does you good. If you drink only the sweet one and buy, it all hits you at once on the day the building wears out.

So before you put down earnest money, go to the building guidance counter at the government office. Ask whether the passage in front of the property is treated as a road under the Building Standards Act, and if it isn't, whether there's any prospect of certification or permission. If a bitter answer comes back, that is what the discount is made of.

A toast to the bitter cup they pour you at the counter.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper