Yeah yeah, it's Rita. I get that your heart moves when you see the number 15%. Lined up next to studio units in the city center that are said to have gross yields of 4–5%, of course it catches your eye. I get it. And here's where I turn on you: the one who knows that feeling best isn't you, it's the selling side.
The first thing to look at isn't the property. It's what the person who made and presented this number gains. The seller gains if it sells high. The brokerage commission has a cap set according to the sale price, so the broker also gains if it sells high and fast. So what's the quickest way to make a yield look high? Write the rent high. Get it?
Gross yield is just annual rent divided by the price. So it's a completely different story depending on whether the rent on top of the fraction is the market rate or a rent arranged in order to sell. Let's go with made-up numbers. An apartment building with 6 units for ¥14.4 million, all units at ¥30,000 a month and fully occupied, ¥2.16 million a year, a gross yield of 15%. But if the market around it is ¥25,000 a month, the rent drops each time a tenant turns over, and at ¥1.8 million a year it's 12.5%. If 2 more units don't fill, it's ¥1.2 million a year, falling to 8.3%. 15% is a snapshot of the most convenient day: full occupancy, with current rents continuing.
I mean, I'm not trying to make the seller the villain. Some people want cash because of an inheritance, some let go for reasons in their main business. That's right, there are plenty of sales with good reasons. But the question doesn't go away: why go out of your way to let go of something that produces 15% every year? If it really keeps yielding 15%, holding it should be the better deal, right?
If I stopped here, it would ruin my name as the sharp-tongued debugger. Looking at incentives isn't for doubting; it's for narrowing down what to check. If there's someone who wants the rent to look high, what you check is what's inside the rent. Get the list showing each unit's rent and move-in date (the rent roll), and see whether only the units filled right before the listing have high rents, and whether there are conditions making the first few months free. Wow — if a list comes out where every unit moved in within the last 1 year, that 15% may be a number someone arranged.
"Didn't you just say the selling side knows best?" Yes. That's why, honestly, all you can do is recalculate the numbers written by the people who know best, using your own yardstick. Replace the rent with the market rate from local listing ads, put in a few vacant units, and work out the price at which you'd still want to buy. The number that's left there is the yield for you. Am I wrong?
Chestnuts, you know — sometimes the burr is big and the shell is glossy, and when you split one open, it's worm-eaten. Putting the best-looking chestnuts at the front of an autumn shop is the seller's skill. The one picking them up should split one before putting them in the basket. Right?