BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

A condominium unit or a whole apartment building — which should I buy first?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Ka-ka-ka-ka. When I'm asked about the first move, a condominium unit or a whole building, it makes me glad. The time you spend unsure is the most fun. But while it's still fun, it's good to know one thing: how the rules for "owning a building together" have changed.

Let me tell an old story. The law on sectional ownership, where one building is owned room by room, was made in 1962 (Showa 37). According to a condominium timeline compiled by Kawasaki City, the 1983 (Showa 58) amendment made a big turn from unanimous agreement to majority vote. With the 2002 (Heisei 14) amendment, major repairs became possible with a majority in favor. And according to Ministry of Justice materials, with the amendment that took effect on April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8), except for resolutions involving disposal of sectional ownership rights such as rebuilding, resolutions of the meeting are now decided by a majority of those present, including those who cast votes by proxy or by a voting form. Owners whom a court has recognized as having an unknown whereabouts are removed from the base of the resolution. For rebuilding, too, while the principle of four-fifths (4/5) remains, 3/4 is now enough if there are circumstances such as insufficient earthquake resistance.

When I took a ship from Manchuria, everyone passed sake around on the deck. Splitting a single isshō bottle among 10 people, we argued over who would drink how much. In the end, the eldest decided, "One sip each, in the order you put your lips to it." I was the youngest, so by the time it came to me, only a finger's depth was left at the bottom. What everyone owns, everyone decides. The cup of someone who doesn't speak up about how things are decided ends up with nothing in it.

Well, never mind my story. The flow of these 60 years has been a path from a jointly owned building that "can't decide and decays" toward "decide and move." Buying a condominium unit means buying one vote in that place where decisions are made. Under the current rules, in resolutions other than rebuilding, the voice of someone who doesn't even submit a proxy isn't counted. A whole building, on the other hand, isn't one vote — it's all of it. The roof and the outer walls: nobody can stop you, but in exchange, nobody will stop you either.

Remonstrance and strong drink work well, but flattery and sweet drink hit you later. "A whole building has a higher yield." "A condominium unit is less hassle." Both are words that go down easy. A condominium unit is less hassle because you've entrusted the hassle of deciding to others, and if the rules of the one you entrusted it to change, what you entrusted changes too. A whole building's yield is high because the price includes carrying that hassle of deciding, and the pain when it goes wrong, all by yourself.

So if you keep a condominium unit as a candidate, before buying, ask the property management company whether that building's management bylaws have been revised to fit the 2026 (Reiwa 8) amendment, or whether a revision has been brought up at the general meeting. From the speed and content of the reply, you'll see that building's power to decide.

Young one, think of your first unit as tuition for learning how decisions are made, more than as profit. You can choose your class only before you pay.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! A condominium unit or a whole building. What I own is a studio condominium unit, but a senior colleague at work owns a whole used wooden apartment building. Put our two stories side by side and the difference is easy to see!

First, my condominium unit. It's just one unit, so the price was within reach, and the property management company and owners' association take care of the building. I thought, this is easy. But in the 2nd year after I bought it, an increase in the repair reserve fund was decided at the general meeting. My one vote didn't change anything. That's when I learned what it means not to be able to decide things about the building yourself. Reading the notice of the increase, I felt like my own unit wasn't really mine.

Next, my colleague's whole building. My colleague bought it thinking, "It's great to be able to decide everything yourself." A wooden apartment building, 25 years old, with a gross yield of 16%. Much higher than a condominium unit.

Then, in the 3rd year after buying, the outer walls needed painting. The estimate was ¥1.2 million (that's an assumption). With a condominium unit, that would come out of the repair reserve fund, but with a whole building it comes out of your own wallet. On top of that, whether to do it, which contractor to use, when to do it — my colleague had to decide all of it. The freedom to decide turned out to be the same as the responsibility to decide. Calling in 3 contractors and comparing estimates, researching types of paint, handing out notices of the work to the tenants. My colleague said 3 weekends were lost to it. I thought a condominium unit, where the owners' association does it all, suits me better.

For a property with rent of ¥2.4 million a year, an expense of ¥1.2 million is half a year's rent. The 16% gross yield figure didn't include this expense.

What I figured out comparing our two stories wasn't which one is the better deal, but which kind of trouble you can take on. A condominium unit is the trouble of not being able to decide. A whole building is the trouble of having to decide.

3 things I'd tell myself back then.

  • For a condominium unit, read the owners' association's long-term repair plan and the general meeting minutes before buying
  • For a whole building, put the repair costs for the roof and outer walls into the yield calculation from the start
  • Decide which one by "which trouble can I take on," more than by yield

By the way, my colleague agonized and agonized over the color of the outer walls, and ended up choosing the same color as before. Being able to decide everything yourself is surprisingly tiring, it seems! And me, I can't even decide how many sugars to put in my coffee every morning!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper