BENERU
Repairs and buildingsPublished Updated

Is a condominium with a low repair reserve fund a good deal?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Low repair reserve fund = good deal." That premise is a bug. What's low is "this month's amount," and whether it's a good deal is decided by "how much you pay in total," so the yardstick you're comparing with is off from the start.

I mean, everyone knows the general point. A low reserve fund goes up later. In the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's fiscal 2023 (Reiwa 5) Comprehensive Survey of Condominiums, too, the graduated-increase method is 47.1% and the equal-contribution method is 40.5%. Condominiums whose contributions fall short of the plan are 36.6%, and those with a shortfall of more than 20% are 11.7%. Up to here, everyone makes the "I knew that" face when told, right?

So why do people do it even knowing that? That's what I'll dig into.

First, the selling side. What gets compared in new-build sales is "how much a month," the loan plus the management fee plus the reserve fund added together. Start the reserve fund low and that total looks light. Next, the buying side. For people who plan to sell in the first few years, the later increase doesn't show up on their own bill. Then the owners' association. Increases are decided at the general meeting, but the ministry's guidelines say that with a method premised on a future rise in the burden, there are cases where agreement can't be reached when they try to raise it, and the reserve fund ends up short. In other words, nobody is doing anything wrong, yet it's a design where everyone's interests line up on "cheap for now." Get it?

Let's look at it in numbers. The guidelines give a guide that, under the graduated-increase method, the first amount should be at least 0.6 times the reference amount for equal contributions, and the last amount within 1.1 times. Suppose that for a 40㎡ unit the reference amount is ¥300 per 1㎡ per month; then the reference is ¥12,000 a month. Start at 0.6 times and it's ¥7,200 a month; end at 1.1 times and it's ¥13,200 a month. Even staying within the guide, the last amount is more than 1.8 times the first. Put the other way, a plan that starts lower than this guide either has a bigger increase later, or runs short somewhere. Keeping up?

But let me be fair here. The method of starting low and raising it isn't necessarily bad across the board. If the steps for raising it are written into the plan and the general meeting has properly decided them, the building is just "on schedule." What's really scary is the building that couldn't raise it in the year it was supposed to.

To answer the question plainly. Cheapness itself is not proof of a good deal. What decides whether it's a good deal is whether that building's general meeting has so far passed the planned increases.

There's one way to check. Before buying, have the brokerage firm show you the minutes of the general meetings for the past several years. In the years a motion to revise the reserve fund came up, was it passed, or was it rejected or postponed? If rejections keep coming, that cheapness may not be advance notice of an increase but advance notice that the work will be delayed. Does that answer it?

You know the yuzu bath on the winter solstice — float the yuzu whole and the scent is weak, but cut them up and put them in and it rises all at once. The reserve fund too: just staring at the amount on the surface, you won't smell what's inside. Put in the knife called the minutes, and see what comes out.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! This one is something I picked thinking "What a deal!" and then held my head over later.

When I was looking for a second-hand studio unit, there were two units with almost identical conditions. Both were 25㎡, with rent of ¥70,000 a month. The management fee was the same too, ¥8,000 a month. The only differences were the price and the repair reserve fund. Unit A was ¥12 million with a repair reserve fund of ¥2,000 a month, and Unit B was ¥13 million with ¥7,000 a month.

Taking the fixed asset tax as ¥50,000 a year, I calculated the cash left over. A was ¥670,000 a year, which is 5.58% divided by the price. B was ¥610,000 a year, 4.69%. A was cheaper, had a lower reserve fund, and a higher yield. I chose A without hesitation! I thought I'd come out ¥60,000 a year ahead from the reserve fund difference alone.

The person in charge even said, "A's appeal is that the burden of the management fee and so on is light." Yeah, the current amounts really were light.

Then in my second year after buying, a notice of the general meeting came from the owners' association. The motion was "Revision of the repair reserve fund." From ¥2,000 a month to ¥12,000 a month. That's 6 times!

When I hurriedly read the long-term repair plan properly, it had been a plan to raise it in steps every few years from the very beginning. I had the documents right there in hand, but I'd only looked at the row with the current amount.

Recalculating after the increase, A's cash left over is ¥550,000 a year, and the yield is 4.58%. It ended up lower than B's 4.69%. I was supposed to have bought it ¥1 million cheaper, but on yield it got overtaken. And whether I voted for or against at the general meeting, my one vote wasn't going to change anything.

According to the ministry's survey, nearly half of condominiums use the method of raising it in steps. It wasn't an unusual story at all.

There are 3 things I'd like to tell the me of back then.

  • For the repair reserve fund, look at the "amounts from now on" in the long-term repair plan, not the current amount.
  • Calculate the yield again with the amount after the increase.
  • Ask the person in charge why the reserve fund is low. If the only answer is "because it's a good deal," look one step further.

But you know, it's not all bad. Because the reserve fund has properly started to build up, it looks like the work on the outer walls can finally go ahead as planned. If the building lasts longer, that should help the value of my unit too! When I told my mom, she asked, "Did you calculate that from the start?" and I laughed it off!

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper