BENERU
TaxesPublished Updated

Is it true that with real estate investment, the books can show a profit while the money in hand goes down?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. That understanding is half right. The necessary expenses of real estate income are the costs incurred to earn rental income; interest on borrowing and depreciation expense are included, but repayment of the principal of borrowing is not. So as repayments progress and the principal repayment exceeds depreciation expense, the income on the books becomes larger than the money left in hand, and you end up paying tax while having little money in hand. In the industry this is called a "dead cross".

The difference between the books and the money in hand

ItemIncome on the booksMoney left in hand
Rental incomeAddAdd
Management fees, repair costs, fixed asset tax, etc.SubtractSubtract
Interest on borrowingSubtractSubtract
Repayment of the principal of borrowingDo not subtractSubtract
Depreciation expenseSubtractDo not subtract (no money goes out)

From this table, the difference between the income on the books and the money left in hand is "principal repayment − depreciation expense".

Calculation example (assumption)

Suppose you borrow ¥20 million at a 2% interest rate over 35 years, acquire newly built a building proper of ¥10 million (reinforced concrete, residential, useful life 47 years, straight-line depreciation rate 0.022) and building fixtures of ¥3 million (useful life 15 years, depreciation rate 0.067), and start leasing at the beginning of the year.

YearPrincipal repaymentDepreciation expenseDifference (amount by which income exceeds money in hand)
Year 1about ¥399,000about ¥421,000about −¥22,000
Year 4about ¥423,000about ¥421,000about ¥2,000
Year 16about ¥538,000about ¥220,000about ¥318,000

In this example, in year 4 the principal repayment (about ¥423,000) slightly exceeds depreciation expense (about ¥421,000), and from year 16 on, after depreciation of the fixtures ends, the difference widens sharply.

Order of checks

  1. Before buying, make a table setting out principal repayments and depreciation expense year by year.
  2. For the years when the difference becomes large, check whether the money in hand is enough even after paying tax.
  3. For a second-hand property, take into account that the useful life is shorter and depreciation ends sooner.
  4. For the period when the difference becomes large, compare options such as prepayment, refinancing and sale.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think a property's income and expenses should be looked at year by year in terms of the cash left over after tax, not before tax. Even if the first year's figures are good, the gap between the books and the wallet widens year after year.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Young people are quick to say, "The books show a profit but there's no money — the system is broken." The system isn't broken. They're just complaining without knowing that the depreciation rules have changed from era to era.

Let me tell you a bit of old history. According to the National Tax Agency's explanation, buildings acquired on or after April 1, 1998 (Heisei 10) were limited to the old straight-line method or the straight-line method. Turn that around and it means buildings acquired before then could also use the declining-balance method. The declining-balance method depreciates a lot in the first year and less with each year after. On the books a loss tends to come out early, and by that much, the day the loan principal repayment overtakes depreciation also comes sooner.

The next milestone is April 1, 2007 (Heisei 19). For things acquired before then, the old straight-line method calculated "acquisition cost × 90% × depreciation rate", and once 95% of the acquisition cost had been depreciated, the rule was to depreciate the rest evenly over 5 years down to ¥1. For things acquired after that, the residual value was abolished, and they are depreciated down to ¥1 by "acquisition cost × depreciation rate". If a building is ¥15 million and the depreciation rate is 0.022, that's ¥297,000 a year under the old straight-line method and ¥330,000 a year under the straight-line method. Same building, but the amount you can take off the books differs by about ¥33,000 a year.

One more: building fixtures and structures acquired on or after April 1, 2016 (Heisei 28) became straight-line only. The road of depreciating fixtures heavily early on closed there.

This jumps a bit, but it's from when I crossed by ship from Manchuria to Japan. My luggage was a single wicker trunk, and at the port I was made to write out its contents one by one. What, when, and for how much I had got it. The paper I wrote then was far more accurate than my memory. That's when I learned that a ledger is written by the rules of the day it's written.

Back to the point. Even with a second-hand property, which depreciation method you use is decided not by the year it was built but by the date you acquired it. So the shape of the gap between the books and the wallet differs for each property, depending on when you bought and what you bought. When someone says "it got hard from year so-and-so," that's about their property, not yours.

People don't change. Looking at the wallet in front of you and thinking next year will be the same — that's the same now as it was long ago. But you can learn. If you know how the rules changed, you can read which era's rules your ledger is written under. If you can read that, you can make your own guess at the year the gap widens.

Let me tell the young folks one thing. Take out the copy of last year's tax return, and read the "date of acquisition" and "depreciation method" columns of the depreciation breakdown with your own eyes. Written there are the rules that bind your ledger.

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper