BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

Is "the bigger the down payment, the better" better for the bank, or for you?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. It's backwards, backwards, that order. The first one to benefit from "the bigger the down payment, the better" is probably the bank, before you.

Why? Because the down payment is the cushion that takes a price drop first. I'll set it all as assumptions. A buys a ¥24 million unit with a ¥3 million down payment, borrowing ¥21 million. B puts ¥1 million down and borrows ¥23 million. Say right after they buy, the market drops 10%, and the unit is worth ¥21.6 million. If A sells, A can pay off the loan in full. In exchange, ¥2.4 million of the ¥3 million down payment is gone. If B sells, B is still ¥1.4 million short. Wow. The one that took on the pain of the price drop first was A's down payment, and the bank wasn't hurt by even ¥1. On top of that, B still has the promise to repay, so even if the sale price falls short, the bank is unlikely to miss out on collecting. A down payment is, first of all, a mechanism that thickens the lender's safety. Get it?

No, I mean, there's real benefit for you too. Borrow less and you pay less interest. At 2.2% over 30 years, the monthly repayment is about ¥79,700 for A and about ¥87,300 for B. B pays about ¥7,600 more a month, and about ¥730,000 more interest over 30 years. Also, some lenders set different interest rates by the ratio of the loan to the purchase price. Flat 35 too changes the rate depending on whether the loan is 90% or less of the price or over 90%, and screens more carefully when it's over 90% (as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8)). B is on the over-90% side. In screening and in the rate alike, the bigger down payment goes through more easily. Am I wrong?

Let me give the answer to the question plainly. Both benefit from the down payment. But what they get is different. The bank gets "safety," and you get "interest" and "screening." And there's a price only you pay. Your cash in hand.

B holds ¥2 million more in cash than A. In exchange, B pays about ¥7,600 more every month, and more if B is past the line where the rate goes up. Put another way, it's the same as paying an insurance premium of a little over ¥90,000 a year to keep ¥2 million in hand. The water heater broke, tenants moved out one after another, the employer went shaky. If B can pay with that ¥2 million in a month like that, B's insurance worked. If nothing happens, honestly, A wins. It's not about which is right; it's a price set by what you want to be ready for. How about it? Is that worth it?

So if you're going to do something, do this. Decide on two candidate down payments, and turn the difference into "how much more you pay each month." Next to it, write the names of the events you'd want to cover with the difference in cash. If you can't write a single name, you can put that difference into the down payment. If you can, decide with your own wallet whether that premium is worth paying. Following me?

You know burdock root? The flavor is right under the skin, so if you peel it with a peeler until it's pure white, it looks nice but has no taste. Scrubbing the dirt off with a brush is just right. A down payment too isn't something you should just whittle away as much as you can. See you.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)
Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Putting in a larger down payment has advantages for both the lender and yourself, but they are different in substance. For the lender, the margin for recovering through the collateral even if the price falls becomes thicker. For you, interest decreases, and you may gain an advantage in screening and interest rate categories, while your cash in hand decreases. The starting point is to count the two separately.

What changes when you increase the down payment

Who looksWhat changesWhen you increase the down payment
LenderLoan-to-value ratio (the loan amount as a share of the purchase price)Falls, making it easier to recover by selling the collateral if payments stop
YouLoan amount, interest, monthly repaymentDecrease
YouInterest rate category, screeningMay become more favorable when you go below a loan-to-value step
YouCash in handDecreases. The down payment you paid does not come back unless you sell or refinance

[Flat 35] sets different borrowing rates depending on whether the loan-to-value ratio is 90% or less or over 90%, and states that if it exceeds 90%, it screens the certainty of repayment and other matters more carefully (as of April 1, 2026 (Reiwa 8)). Including investment loans, the treatment by loan-to-value ratio differs from lender to lender.

Trial calculation (assumptions)

Purchase price ¥32 million, own funds ¥8 million, acquisition costs ¥2.2 million, term 35 years. The interest rate is assumed to be 1.9% for a loan-to-value ratio of 90% or less and 2.0% for over 90% (constant over the whole term, equal principal-and-interest payments).

ItemDown payment ¥0Down payment ¥3.2 millionDown payment ¥5.8 million
Loan-to-value ratio100%90%about 82%
Loan amount¥32 million¥28.8 million¥26.2 million
Monthly repaymentabout ¥106,000about ¥93,900about ¥85,500
Total interestabout ¥12.52 millionabout ¥10.65 millionabout ¥9.69 million
Cash in hand after purchase¥5.8 million¥2.6 million¥0
Difference between price and loan amount if the price falls 10% right after purchase¥3.2 million short±¥0¥2.6 million to spare

The effect changes before and after the step

How the down payment is increasedDecrease in monthly repaymentDecrease in total interestCash in hand given upDecrease in interest per ¥10,000 of down payment
¥0 → ¥3.2 million (crossing the 90% step)about ¥12,100about ¥1.87 million¥3.2 millionabout ¥5,800
¥3.2 million → ¥5.8 million (after crossing the step)about ¥8,500about ¥960,000¥2.6 millionabout ¥3,700

The down payment up to crossing the step also affects the interest rate category; after crossing it, the only effect is reducing the loan amount.

Order of checks

  1. At the candidate lenders, check whether there is a step at which the interest rate or screening treatment changes with the loan-to-value ratio, and if so, at what percentage.
  2. If there is no step, or you are already below it, work out how much interest decreases per additional ¥10,000 of down payment.
  3. For each candidate down payment, check whether you could sell and pay off the loan in full even if the price fell 10% right after purchase (a guide to whether you can still move).
  4. Line up 1 to 3, and check the range where the lender's advantages and your own overlap.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the advantage in screening and the thickness of cash in hand are separate accounts. A down payment to cross an interest rate step has a large effect, while a down payment after crossing it reduces interest in exchange for giving up cash in hand. That portion should be decided by comparing how much interest decreases against the cash kept in hand, and by which one you want to make thicker.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper