Yeah yeah, it's Rita. That premise is a bug. People say "you can buy with zero own funds," but there's no such thing as a purchase with zero own funds. It's just rearranging what you don't pay now into a form you pay every month later.
I mean, everyone knows that much. If you don't put in a down payment, the loan gets bigger, the interest grows, and the monthly repayment gets heavier. That's right, it is right — but then why do people do it even though they know?
The reason is fairly simple: the numbers they're shown come out "positive every month." No down payment, and yet after subtracting repayment and management fees from the rent, a little is left each month. If it looks like that, the less cash someone has, the faster they jump at it. For someone with thin savings, "you don't have to wait" works best of all. Get it?
The short answer to the question. What's been cut isn't the room; it's the "margin" that should have been somewhere in the price, the interest rate, the term or the yield. To make it look positive every month, the books are balanced in one of those.
Suppose you buy a unit priced at ¥20 million, with rent of ¥80,000 a month and a management fee plus repair reserve fund totaling ¥15,000 a month, fully financed (all the numbers are assumptions). Rent minus the management fee and so on is ¥65,000 a month. At 2.5% over 35 years, the repayment is about ¥71,500 a month, so you're about ¥6,500 out of pocket every month. But stretch the term to 45 years and the repayment drops to about ¥61,700 a month, turning into a plus of about ¥3,300 every month.
Same unit; the only thing that changed is the term. In exchange, the loan balance after 10 years is about ¥15.94 million at 35 years and about ¥17.27 million at 45 years. In exchange for ¥3,300 a month, the principal goes down more slowly, and even after 10 years you still owe about ¥1.33 million more. Well? Is that a fair trade?
It's not just the term. On the interest rate side, a premium may be added when the share borrowed against the purchase price is high (it depends on the lender). The price side is even harsher. If it's a price at which a buyer turns up even with full financing, the seller has no reason to lower it. Even if it's higher than similar units nearby, you won't notice if you only look at the monthly numbers. Yield is the same: at ¥20 million with rent of ¥960,000 a year, the gross yield is 4.8%. Sometimes that thinness is hidden by a long term.
Let me pick up the other side too. Keeping your cash instead of putting it into a down payment helps when there's a vacancy or repairs. So you can't say zero down is bad. But that's for people who can really leave the cash they kept untouched. Don't you think?
So what you look at isn't "how much is left each month"; it's the gap between the balance 10 years out on the repayment schedule and the price that unit looks likely to sell for around then. Honestly, if you look at how wide that gap is, you can mostly see which of the 4 was used to balance the books. Does that answer it?
With baked sweet potatoes, even if the skin is charred the same way, you can't tell whether the inside is honey-sweet or dry and hollow until you break it open. The more freely a potato is handed to you, the better it is to break it open before you take it. See you.