BENERU
Basics and getting startedPublished

Is a yield of 8% high compared with a bank deposit?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. That premise is a bug. The question "is 8% high compared with a deposit" — the two numbers you're lining up don't come out of the same spec in the first place.

You're right, I get what you mean. Next to a deposit interest rate, 8% looks like it's in a different league. And the textbook answers like this: "The yield is high because the risk is high." Yeah, as a general statement, that's correct. It's correct, but everyone already knows that, right? So why do people do it even though they know? Unless you dig into that, this question doesn't move a millimeter.

Let me line up the specs. A deposit interest rate is interest added at a promised rate to the principal you deposited. The face value of the principal doesn't move. The 8%, on the other hand, is usually the gross yield: the annual rent assuming full occupancy divided by the asking price. It's not a promise; it's a projection of "if these conditions are all met." The denominator, the price, is what the seller put on it, and the numerator, the rent, assumes full occupancy. Get it? One is a contract, the other is counting chickens before they hatch. They just both have a "%" attached; the specs inside are wildly different.

So why do people do it even though they know? Well, there are real reasons. One is borrowing. You can buy a property even with little of your own funds, so if it goes well, the growth relative to your own funds goes way beyond 8%. But if it doesn't, the shrinkage goes way beyond 8% too. The other is that 8% sounds like "it grows by 8% every year." But the denominator, the price, starts moving the day after you buy. Even if you receive 8% a year in rent, if the price has fallen 10% when you sell, that works out to a bit more than 1 year of gross rent disappearing. Deposit interest doesn't have this swing in the denominator. That's the body of the bug.

So what do you compare it with? The gap between 8% and a deposit is the reward for taking on hassles like vacancies, falling rent, repairs, falling prices, and not being able to sell right away when you want to. So the question gets replaced: not "is it high," but "is the reward enough for the hassles this property carries." Still with me?

The way to check is plain. Line up the yields at which properties at the same station, about the same age, and about the same size are listed for sale. If the others are around 6% and only this one is 8%, the market dislikes something about it to the tune of those 2 percentage points. Look for what that something is — lots of vacancies, wear on the building, or sloppy management. If you find the reason and can still take it on, that 8% makes sense as a reward. If you can't find it, you just haven't looked hard enough. Am I wrong?

"But you just said it's not about high or low"? Yeah, I said that. But let me use "high" just once. A yield higher than its surroundings is usually sold together with the reason it's high. Honestly, the reason is the main product. Right?

You know yudofu — in the pot they all look like the same white squares, but whether it's silken or firm makes all the difference to whether it falls apart the moment you scoop it. 8% is a white square too: you don't know what's inside until you scoop it. What? Whether yudofu goes with ponzu or soy sauce is what really matters? Oh, OK.

Sources (in Japanese)

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. I remember well the day I crossed the sea, came here, and opened a bankbook at a bank for the first time. The young woman at the counter told me about interest, but my Japanese was still shaky, so I just caught the numbers and was impressed. Is a yield of 8% higher than a deposit? To think about that question, you have to add: compared with a deposit from when?

Let me tell an older story. In August 1990 (Heisei 2), the Bank of Japan's official discount rate was 6%. According to the Bank of Japan's explanation, in the era of regulated interest rates, deposit rates and the like were linked to the official discount rate. When the official discount rate moved, deposit interest moved with it. Hearing 8% in times like that, there surely wasn't the dazzle of it being in a different league from deposits.

Then in 1994 (Heisei 6), interest rate liberalization was completed, and the direct link between deposit rates and the official discount rate disappeared. The official discount rate fell to 0.5% in September 1995 (Heisei 7) and to 0.1% in September 2001 (Heisei 13). From then on, for a long time, deposit interest was next to nothing. It was in this era of low interest rates that the figure 8% came to look dazzling.

The promise on the deposit side has changed too. In April 2002 (Heisei 14), time deposits and the like were removed from full protection, and in April 2005 (Heisei 17), the payoff system was fully lifted. Today, for interest-bearing deposits, up to ¥10 million of principal per person per financial institution, plus its interest, is protected. Deposits have a line drawn too, marking the protected limit.

In Manchuria where I was born, liquor meant kaoliang liquor. A strong liquor made by fermenting and distilling sorghum; it's not unusual for it to be over 50 degrees. Shaoxing wine is brewed from glutinous rice, not distilled, and sells on the years it has aged in the jar. Line up the strength alone and kaoliang liquor is about 3 times as strong. But nobody gulps kaoliang liquor from a Shaoxing wine bowl, and nobody sips Shaoxing wine from a little kaoliang cup. A figure for strength is read as a set with how you drink it.

Back to the subject. The rate at which the Bank of Japan lends to financial institutions — now called the basic loan rate — has risen to 0.5% in August 2024 (Reiwa 6), 1.00% in December 2025 (Reiwa 7), and 1.50% in September 2026 (Reiwa 8). Deposit interest won't necessarily stay as it was in the low era. Loan interest rates move with the same wind. The gap between 8% and a deposit widens and narrows with the times. Meanwhile the 8% is a figure worked out from the price on the day you bought and the rent on that day, and if rent falls afterward, it falls along with it.

Times change, but people's habits don't. People want to decide high or low by the number lined up next to it. My reading is that more people jumped at the same 8% when the official discount rate was 0.1% than when it was 6%. Even with the same property, the heart moves with the number beside it.

When you hear 8%, before comparing it with a deposit, write on paper by how many percentage points the yield after subtracting expenses and vacancies exceeds the interest rate you'll borrow at.

Kaoliang liquor comes in small cups, so you end up having cup after cup. More than one night, I've lost count of the degrees and been carried home by my wife. Kakakaka.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper