BENERU
Law, contracts and systemsPublished Updated

Is it OK to go to a meeting from a real estate investment ad that offers an expensive gift card?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. Asking about the risks first gets full marks. But if I grade the whole thing, it's 50 points — half of it's off. The risk doesn't start inside the meeting; it starts the moment you send the application form.

Everyone knows the general point. The money for the gift card is paid in the end by the person who buys a property. It's like the peanuts served as the cover snack at an izakaya — they come out looking free, but they're on the bill all right. That's right, it's right — but people who know it still apply as normal, don't they? So then. Why do they do it even though they know?

Because the gift card is a sure few tens of thousands of yen you get today, and the loss is a vague amount, "someday, maybe." People tend to weigh a small, sure gain more heavily than a large, vague loss. On top of that, the people applying think they're on the side that won't buy. You know? That's the core of what's off.

You'd think a meeting is a place where you size up the company. Actually it's the reverse — it's a place where they assess you. Annual income, employer, years of service, current borrowing, savings. All of them are material for measuring how much someone would lend you. And you're going to tell them that in exchange for a gift card. Well, you could say just don't answer, but a meeting where they don't ask about that pretty much doesn't exist.

Also, the one running the ad isn't necessarily a company that sells properties. Sometimes it's a lead-generation site that collects applications and passes them on to several companies. Then the people calling you won't be just one company. So before you apply, read the terms of use and the privacy policy for the name of the company running it, and who it says your personal information will be given to. If you can't find a Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business license number, it may not be the seller itself. Get it?

Let me line up some numbers too. According to the National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan, in complaints and inquiries about investment condominiums from people in their 20s, the average contract purchase amount in fiscal 2018 was ¥27.76 million. Compared with a gift card worth a few tens of thousands of yen, that's three digits more. That's the gap between the bait and the size of the fish they want to catch.

Let me pick up the view from the other side too. There's the opinion that hearing a company out once is a good learning experience. That's true. But if it's for learning, I think you can hear more in a setting with no gift card attached, from a position where you're not being assessed. Right?

You know, fragrant olive calls people from far away with its scent. But get close and it doesn't bear fruit. The strength of the scent and the size of what you get are two different things. Smelling it from a little way off on an autumn walk home is just about right.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.11.11)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! A gift card for a meeting — I actually went to get one once. Without thinking much about it.

I found it in an online ad. "¥20,000 gift card for an online meeting." I was interested in real estate investment, and ¥20,000 just for hearing them out seemed like a good fee for learning. I applied right away.

The person in charge of the meeting was really pleasant. They asked about my annual income and savings, and showed me material saying, "This property is perfect for you, Jamie." It was supposed to be 1 hour, but before I knew it 2 hours had passed. Partway through I started to say, "Maybe it's about time…", but I thought, well, I'm getting ¥20,000, and couldn't say it.

At the end, the person in charge said, "We'll send the gift card after the second meeting."

Huh, it's not just one? I thought. When I reread the ad carefully, it said "for those who meet the prescribed conditions" in small print. I really agonized over whether to go to the second one. Another 2 hours, for ¥20,000. And the second one was bound to get more specific.

In the end, I didn't go to the second one. When I sent word declining, I got a few phone calls after that, but once I said clearly, "I won't be considering it," they stopped. I didn't get the gift card, but I got away without buying a property. Looking back, I think that was the best learning fee of all.

Later I tried doing the math. Even if the company hands ¥20,000 to everyone who comes to a meeting, it makes the money back if a few people buy. That cost is paid by someone, somewhere, who buys a property. Thinking about it that way, that ¥20,000 wasn't free.

Here are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Read all the conditions for receiving the gift card before applying
  • If you go to a meeting, decide in advance how long you'll stay and that you "won't decide on the spot"
  • When you decline, say clearly, "I won't be considering it"

By the way, I still have the material from that time. When I compared the property's price with today's market, the gap was way more than a ¥20,000 gift card could cover! The gift card? I never got it, so the coffee during those 2 hours was on me!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper