BENERU
Law, contracts and systemsPublished Updated

I heard in a video that "real estate investment fraud is rampant." Is that true?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. Complaints and inquiries about aggressive solicitation for investment condominiums are confirmed in public statistics for fiscal 2013 to 2018. However, "fraud" under the Penal Code is a separate issue from solicitation prohibited by law or contracts unfavorable to the buyer. The words need to be considered separately.

Public numbers

In material published by the National Consumer Affairs Center of Japan in March 2019, the numbers of cases about investment condominiums received by consumer affairs centers are as follows (PIO-NET, as of February 28, 2019).

Fiscal yearCases
Fiscal 20132,321
Fiscal 20151,713
Fiscal 20171,557

The overall number has decreased, but the same material states that cases from people in their 20s increased about 2.5 times, from 160 in fiscal 2013 to 405 in fiscal 2018 (as of February 28, 2019). The cases received include people who signed a contract because they were afraid of persistent solicitation, people who were solicited with a promise of a rent guarantee but are running a deficit, and people who made false statements in their declarations to lenders on the business's instructions. The same material states that long or late-night solicitation is also seen. I could not confirm a tally in the same form from 2019 onward.

Differences between "fraud," "prohibited solicitation" and "unfavorable contracts"

CategoryDetailsBasis
FraudDeceiving a person and causing them to hand over propertyPenal Code, Article 246
Prohibited solicitationProviding conclusive judgments that mislead someone into thinking a profit is certain, soliciting again after a refusal, calls and visits at inconvenient times, long solicitation, and so onBuilding Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act (Takken Gyōhō), Article 47-2; Ordinance for Enforcement of the same Act, Article 16-11
Unfavorable contractNot illegal, but the income and expenses run a deficit, the rent can be reduced, and so onA matter of the contract's content

Contracts that feel like "I was deceived" include ones that fall into the second or third category. The third is the part that can be avoided by checking the numbers and clauses before the contract.

A system you can use after the contract

When a licensed real estate broker is itself the seller and you made an application to purchase (or concluded a contract without an application) at a place other than its office or the like, you can use cooling-off (Building Lots and Buildings Transaction Business Act, Article 37-2). It is done in writing within 8 days of the day you were told in writing that you can withdraw. It cannot be done after you have received the handover and paid the full price.

Order of checks

  1. Record whether, during the solicitation, there was an explanation that a profit was certain, or solicitation again after a refusal.
  2. Before the contract, redo the income and expense estimate yourself.
  3. Check the rent revision, cancellation and loan conditions in the clauses.
  4. Check the place where you made the application, and confirm whether it is subject to cooling-off.

From here on, this is my opinion

I think the question to ask is not "whether it is fraud" but "whether I checked the numbers and clauses myself." Illegal solicitation can be fought with the system, but an unfavorable contract concluded without checking is hard to recover through the system.

Sources (in Japanese)

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Once the loan is over, the whole rent becomes like a pension." Honestly, it's the line you see most often in ads for investment studio units. Who promises you, that far ahead, the building age, rent and repair costs 35 years from now? It's not written anywhere in the ad, right?

Now, the video in the question. A title like "fraud is rampant" gets views growing scarily well. If views grow, the creator gets money. All the more if the description box has sign-ups for their own course or consultations pasted in. The ad's line and the video's title face in completely opposite directions, but they're the same in that both earn off your reaction. You know?

Well, it's not that the video is all lies. Complaints about aggressive solicitation show up in public statistics too, and there's a side where it's useful as a warning. That's right, it's right, but the moment you get on board with the question "is it rampant," you're just being made to choose whose ring to stand in — the side that scares you or the side that sells to you.

So. Let's switch to a single measuring stick. "When this story turns out wrong, who takes the loss?"

If it's a new studio unit where the business itself is the seller, the upper limit on brokerage commission in the ministry's notice has nothing to do with it. That's a rule about brokerage and agency fees; the seller's profit is inside the price. The business's account closes the moment it's sold. Even if the rent drops afterward, even if the vacancy drags on, the one who takes it is the person who bought. Don't get it? The seller's profit comes out "on the day of the contract," and the buyer's profit comes out "over 35 years." The direction of time is out of line.

A sublease can be measured with the same stick. The company renting it is the lessee, so it can request a rent reduction under Article 32 of the Act on Land and Building Leases. That's why the Act on Proper Rental Housing Management Operations, from December 15, 2020 (Reiwa 2), prohibited displays about rent and other terms that differ significantly from the facts, or that mislead people into thinking they're significantly more favorable than they actually are. If they went to the trouble of stopping it by law, it's natural to read that such ads were going around.

Didn't I just say to doubt the video? Yeah, read the seller's materials with exactly the same eyes. Believing only one side is seriously the most dangerous.

How to check is simple. For each promise-like line in the brochure, write "If it turns out wrong, who pays?" in the margin, and look for the answer in the articles of the contract. A promise you can't find in the articles isn't a promise, it's an advertising slogan. Don't you think?

When the forecast for the first snow comes out, kotatsu tables and mandarin oranges sell well. The people at the counter are on the side that wants snow to fall, right? When you listen to a forecast, look at who's waiting for the snow too.

Sources (in Japanese)

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper