BENERU
Repairs and buildingsPublished Updated

Where do you look to spot a poorly managed condominium building?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "Leave the management to the professionals. Zero effort for owners." A line you see in ads for investment condominiums. That the effort is zero is right, it's right, but what becomes zero is the effort, not the role of deciding. The property management company is the side that takes on work from the owners' association, and the ones who decide whether to raise the repair reserve fund and when to do the work are the unit owners who vote at the general meeting — in other words, the owners themselves.

I'll say it first. A poorly managed condominium is a condominium that keeps putting off decisions about money. Dirty hallways and the garbage area are just the results showing up on the surface.

The reason is in the numbers. In the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's fiscal 2023 (Reiwa 5) Comprehensive Survey of Condominiums, 36.6% of condominiums have reserves short of the long-term repair plan, and 11.7% are short by more than 20%. As for the savings method, the graduated increase method, which starts cheap and is raised in stages later, is 47.1%, more than the 40.5% for the equal savings method. A plan that raises things in stages is, put another way, a plan that assumes "a future general meeting will vote in favor of the increase." You know?

And that general meeting. In the same survey, the average attendance rate is 88.5% including submitted proxies and written votes. Look at that alone and it's impressive. But the rate of owners who actually showed up in person is just 24.6%. That stings.

Let's sort out the spec. Where you tell them apart is the gap between plan and results. In a year where the long-term repair plan said "raise the reserve to this much this year," did it actually go up? If not, look at the general meeting minutes to see whether the motion was voted down or never put forward at all. In the report on important matters (jūyō jikō chōsa hōkokusho), look at the reserve balance and the status of arrears together. The survey shows 30.1% of condominiums have units in arrears for 3 months or more, so rather than whether there are arrears or not, the clue is in how the write-up shows the owners' association dealing with them. Get it?

Well, there's the opposite view too. Lots of proxies — isn't that because things are running well and nobody has complaints? That's possible. Honestly, a condominium where everyone shows up every time is the rare one. So I won't judge by attendance rate alone. What I look at is whether painful motions, like increases, pass when they come up. A condominium where painful motions pass is working even with lots of proxies. A condominium where painful motions vanish every time is shaky even with high attendance. Am I wrong?

"Didn't you just say 'zero effort' is right?" you ask? Yeah. Zero effort is fine. But the one hour of reading several years of minutes before buying — only the owners themselves can do that. Does that answer it?

You know how, when you start smelling fragrant olive, oden starts lining up next to the convenience store register? However fancy the ingredients, a pot where the broth isn't topped up gets weaker and weaker in flavor. With condominiums too, look at how the broth gets topped up before you look at the unit.

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Ritsu SakakibaraFinancial product examiner

This is Ritsu Sakakibara. I will give the conclusion first. The state of a condominium's management can be checked with three documents: the report on important matters (jūyō jikō chōsa hōkokusho), the long-term repair plan and the general meeting minutes. In addition, whether it has been certified under the "Management Plan Certification System," in which local governments certify condominium management plans, is also material for judgment.

Documents to check and what to look at

DocumentWhat to look at
Report on important mattersAmounts of the management fee and repair reserve fund, reserve balance, status of arrears, history and schedule of major repairs, planned increases in the management fee, etc.
Long-term repair planPlan period, timing of reviews, scheduled repair work and its cost, planned increases in the reserve
General meeting minutesDiscussion of revising the repair reserve fund, response to arrears, change of property management company, attendance rate
Management bylawsRestrictions on use, whether pets and private lodging (minpaku) are allowed, rules for repairs to exclusive areas

Management Plan Certification System

Under the Act on Advancement of Proper Condominium Management, this is a system in which a local government certifies an owners' association's management plan when it meets certain standards. The certification standards include preparing and reviewing a long-term repair plan, setting the amount of the repair reserve fund, and holding general meetings.

Warning signs

SignWhat it may mean
Many arrears in the repair reserve fundFunds for future repairs will fall short
The reserve balance is far below the planA lump-sum levy or a large increase in the reserve is possible
The long-term repair plan has not been reviewed for a long timeRising construction costs are not reflected
Low general meeting attendance, with many proxiesUnit owners have little interest, and motions tend to be decided without enough consideration

Order of checks

  1. Obtain the report on important matters through the brokerage firm.
  2. Check the long-term repair plan and the general meeting minutes for the last several years.
  3. Check whether it has received management plan certification.
  4. Compare the reserve balance with the plan and check whether there is a shortfall.

From here on, this is my opinion

When choosing a condominium unit, I think you should check the state of the owners' association's operation before the condition of the unit. You can fix the inside of a unit yourself, but the management of the whole building cannot be changed by one person.

Sources (in Japanese)

Read a little deeper