BENERU
Financing and interest ratesPublished

What does "borrowing while interest rates are low is a good deal" overlook?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

This is Wang. Tonight it's sweet potato shōchū with hot water. The liquor shop had a sale on big isshō bottles, so I carried 2 of them home while they were cheap. On the way home, I realized something. Even if the price goes down, the amount my liver can take in one night hasn't grown by a single drop. Being able to buy cheaply and being able to drink it all are different matters.

What I remember is just after New Year in 2016 (Heisei 28). On January 29, the Bank of Japan decided to introduce "Quantitative and Qualitative Monetary Easing with a Negative Interest Rate." In substance, it applied an interest rate of minus 0.1% to part of the current account deposits that financial institutions hold at the Bank of Japan, and it was applied from the reserve maintenance period starting February 16. Money that shrinks while it sleeps — I'd never heard of such a thing.

That year, in the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism's Building Construction Statistics, construction starts of rental housing were 418,543 units, up 10.5% from the year before, the 5th year of increase in a row. In March of the same year, the Bank of Japan put together a report on lending by regional financial institutions to the rental housing business. After writing that the recent increase in rental housing was partly pushed by the circumstances of those who build, such as wealthy people's asset management and their demand for tax savings, it wrote that the supply and demand and the profitability of rental housing depend, besides the differences between properties, on long-term circumstances such as the population and number of households of the location. So it is important for lenders to check the income and expense outlook property by property, it wrote. It was pressing the point even on the lenders.

3 years later, in 2019 (Reiwa 1), construction starts of rental housing were 342,289 units, down 13.7% from the year before, the 2nd year of decrease in a row. After the wave of building all at once, pushed by cheap money and the demand for tax savings, receded, what was left differs from place to place where things were built, as I see it.

It reminds me of when I crossed the sea from Manchuria. At the port, a rumor went around that "the fare for the next ship is going up," and everyone rushed to the cheapest ship. I got on too. The overloaded ship rocked and rocked, and for 3 days and 3 nights I clung to the deck railing and threw up the whole way. I remember the fare was cheap, but for a while I couldn't remember the name of the port we arrived at. A ship chosen by its price doesn't tell you where it will arrive or how much it will rock.

Back to the main point. Interest rates are equally cheap for everyone who borrows. In cheap periods, many people buy and build the same things for the same reason. Where the difference comes is which unit you own, where, and when you can let it go. And if you borrow at a variable rate, only today's rate is cheap; repayments from here on are decided by the interest rates from here on.

When fear takes hold, it usually goes like this. Those who are afraid of interest rates going up hurry before they go up, and close the eyes they look at properties with. The reason they hurried may be interest rates, but what they live with for decades is the unit.

When you get a sales drawing, try covering with your hand the boxes where the interest rate and the monthly repayment are written. Sleep a night with them covered, and if the next morning you still want that unit, go ahead with it. If you no longer want it, what you'd fallen for wasn't the unit but the interest rate.

Letting one year of cheap interest rates pass won't kill anybody. I nearly died on a cheap ship, and here I am sipping shōchū.

(Updated 2026.10.18)
RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. That premise is buggy. "Borrowing while interest rates are low is a good deal." This formula has only one input field: "interest rate."

I'll say it flat out first. What low interest rates make cheaper is only "the price of borrowing." The price you buy at, the price you sell at, and whether you can hold up when interest rates rise are all left in separate fields.

3 reasons. The first, the price you buy at. I'll set everything as assumptions. Someone who can repay ¥120,000 a month over 30 years can borrow about ¥37.3 million at a 1% interest rate, and about ¥32.5 million at 2%. In periods of low interest rates, every buyer's wallet swells at the same time. From the seller's side, it's a period when plenty of people can buy even if the price tag goes up. In other words, part of the gain from cheap interest rates is, frankly, already on the price tag. Get it?

The second, the price you sell at. When you sell 10 years from now, the buyer on the other side borrows at the interest rate of that time. If that's 2%, the same ¥120,000-a-month person can borrow about ¥4.8 million less. The fact that you borrowed at 1% isn't passed on to the buyer by a single yen.

The third, the strength to hold up. With a variable rate, "while it's low" is also while your own repayments are low. ¥35 million over 30 years is about ¥113,000 a month at 1%, and about ¥129,000 at 2% from the start. Can you keep paying a difference of roughly ¥17,000 a month even in years when rent doesn't go up? Am I wrong?

Well, let me pick up the other side too. "Then if I borrow low at a fixed rate, it doesn't matter if rates go up." That's right, it is right, but what fixed protects is only the monthly repayment. It doesn't protect the price you sell at, the age of the unit, or similar units multiplying around it. And fixed rates are often higher than variable rates in the same period. Unless you look at both the range it protects and its price, you can't decide whether it's a good deal.

If I stopped here, it would shame my name as the sharp-tongued debugger.

The easiest thing to overlook is the property itself. People who decided "I'll buy because interest rates are low" have reached the conclusion before seeing the unit. And in periods of low interest rates, many people buy and build at the same time for the same reason. Where too much got built is found out years later, by the number of vacancies. Interest rates are equally cheap for everyone, but the quality of a unit and how easy it is to sell differ one unit at a time. That's where the difference comes. Seriously. A bit tricky? Well, hang in there.

So if you're going to get your hands moving, calculate standing on the seller's side. Set the interest rate of the buyer 10 years from now at 1% higher than today, and work out how much that person can borrow at the same monthly amount. Then see whether that unit, 10 years older, looks like it would sell at that amount. If it looks like it would sell, the low interest rate is a bonus. If it doesn't, the low interest rate is nothing more than a discount at the entrance. OK?

New-crop rice — just having "new rice" on the bag makes your hand reach for it, right? But whether it's tasty when cooked is decided by where it's grown, the milling date, and the skill of whoever cooks it. Picking it up by the label is fine, but before the register, read the back of the bag too. Ciao.

(Updated 2026.10.18)

Read a little deeper