BENERU
Choosing and buying propertyPublished Updated

For an investment condominium unit, should I choose new or second-hand?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. ¥7.8 million. Before the new-or-second-hand talk, I'm putting this number down. Where it comes from, I'll show with a formula now.

The price of an investment unit is set, roughly, by this formula.

Price = annual rent ÷ yield

New and second-hand, it's the same formula. The only difference is where the two numbers that go into the formula move from here.

From here on it's all an assumption. New, with rent of ¥90,000 a month, ¥1.08 million a year. If it's sold at a gross yield of 4%, ¥1.08 million ÷ 4% is ¥27 million. Say that after 10 years, rent has fallen to ¥80,000 a month, ¥960,000 a year. If the people buying a 10-year-old unit at that point want 5%, ¥960,000 ÷ 5% is ¥19.2 million. ¥27 million − ¥19.2 million is ¥7.8 million. That's the first number.

Now then. Let's split this ¥7.8 million. The fall in rent alone gives ¥960,000 ÷ 4% = ¥24 million, minus ¥3 million. The remaining ¥4.8 million is the part from the required yield rising from 4% to 5%. In other words, someone buying new takes on two downhills at the same time: the part where rent falls, and the part where "new" wears off and the yield rises. Am I wrong?

Well, wait. If you're thinking second-hand has no downhill, no way. Buy a 10-year-old unit for ¥19.2 million, and if after another 10 years rent is ¥75,000 a month, ¥900,000 a year, and the required yield is 5.5%, then ¥900,000 ÷ 5.5% is about ¥16.36 million. It falls by about ¥2.84 million. It falls all the same. But new falls about 29% in 10 years, and this second-hand one about 15%. The angle of the slope is different. Get it?

Didn't I say "the same formula" earlier? Yeah. So it's not a story where new is a loss and second-hand is a gain either. Even new, in a place where rent hardly falls in 10 years, the formula is on new's side. Conversely, even second-hand, if the required yield keeps rising because of age or location, the slope gets steep. Which one to choose is decided not by the label but by the angle of the slope of the two numbers.

The slightly tricky part is that gross yield doesn't include the management fee or the repair reserve fund. With second-hand, the reserve may already have been raised, or equipment replacement may be close, so a gross 5% can be in the 3% range in hand. Honestly, the proper way is to put rent into the formula after subtracting what goes out. OK?

So there's one way to compare. In a place similar to the unit you're interested in, look up the rent and the actual sold prices of units 10 years older, and put them into this formula. Whether the angle of the slope that comes out is one you can bear over the years you'll hold it. Right?

Daikon, you know — freshly picked in winter it's juicy and pricey, but the kind simmered for a few days in the oden pot is soaked with flavor, and a slice can be cheaper. Huh? Simmer it too long and it falls apart? Oh, is that so. That's the story of second-hand equipment and the reserve fund. Look all the way to the bottom of the pot before you put the ladle in.

(Updated 2026.10.14)
Drunken WangLiving memory of the times

Wang here. Tonight I'm drinking warmed Shaoxing wine. Whether to buy a new unit or an old one. If you ask me, the deciding factor is less the newness of the unit than the script for the reserve money taken every month.

On April 18, 2011 (Heisei 23), the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism issued the "Guidelines on Repair Reserve Funds for Condominiums." About the repair reserve fund the seller presents at the time of sale, the state itself wrote that there were cases where the initial monthly amount was set remarkably low, and that because of this, cases had also arisen where the reserve fell short and money for repair work ran out. It was to show people buying new a guideline for the amount.

Then 13 years passed. On June 7, 2024 (Reiwa 6), the state revised these guidelines. For the stepped-increase method, which starts cheap and raises the amount every few years, it introduced a way of thinking about increases: taking the monthly amount when saving the same amount throughout as the base amount, the amount at the start of the plan should be at least 0.6 times the base amount, and the final amount within 1.1 times. Turned over, that means until then there could be plans where the starting amount didn't reach 60% of the base.

Meanwhile, on the old-unit side, from April 1, 2018 (Heisei 30), licensed real estate brokers came to explain to buyers, as important matters, a summary of the results of a building condition survey, the so-called inspection, and so on. A system was made that puts into words, at the place of sale, how worn an old building is.

Let me talk about Shaoxing wine. The longer Shaoxing wine sleeps in the jar, the more its edges soften. I hear there's wine laid down in the year a daughter is born and opened on the day she marries. Kaoliang liquor is the opposite: the kind you drink in a Manchurian winter burns your throat from the start without any aging. Neither is better. The difference is whether the years of aging are in the price, or the strength is in the price.

Well, never mind my story. With new, the cheap reserve makes the early income and expenses look good. My view is that the state spent 13 years putting a guideline on the size of increases because there were quite a few cases where that cheapness came back to bite later. With second-hand, it has become an age where, if you want to look, you can see how far the reserve has risen, how much has been saved, and how worn the building is. Rather than new or old, the difference is whether the script for money from here on can be seen.

Well, it won't kill you. But not being able to sleep is a problem. On the night a notice arrives that the reserve is going up sharply, few people sleep soundly.

Before buying, get the long-term repair plan and look at the current monthly repair reserve fund side by side with the monthly amount in the final year of the plan. How many times larger it has become is the price tag that unit is hiding.

Then, a toast to liquor you can see through all the way to the bottom of the jar.

(Updated 2026.10.14)

Read a little deeper