BENERU
Cash flow and yieldsPublished Updated

If what's left after 35 years of repayments is a 35-year-old condominium, isn't there no real benefit?

BENERU writes for readers who live in Japan. Taxes, loans and the other rules described here are those of Japan, and they assume a resident of Japan.
This page is a translation of the Japanese original. If the two differ, the Japanese original prevails.

2 people have answered. Each answerer sees it differently.

RitaSharp-tongued debugger

Yeah yeah, it's Rita. "While you're repaying the loan, the profit is zero" — that premise is a bug. It isn't zero. Every month it's moving, either plus or minus. You just can't see it.

Let me put the answer first. Winning or losing in this investment is decided by a race between how fast the loan balance falls and how fast the unit's price falls. Whether the cash left in your hand is zero doesn't reflect the result of that race.

Let's sort out the spec. All assumptions: say you borrow the full ¥25 million at 2% over 35 years with equal principal-and-interest payments. The repayment is about ¥83,000 a month. After 10 years, the principal has gone down by about ¥5.46 million, and the balance is about ¥19.54 million. Interest during that time is about ¥4.48 million. If rent exactly covered the repayment, the cash left over looks like zero. But behind the scenes, the debt has gone down by ¥5.46 million. It's like the rent is making you save. Get it?

But that's only when the unit's price stays above the balance. If you sell after 10 years and, after subtracting fees and so on, only ¥18 million remains, you're ¥1.54 million short of the balance. Far from savings, it's a hole. The price of a new unit includes the seller's expenses and profit, so the price may already start below the balance at the moment you buy. Am I wrong?

No, let me pick up the other side's argument too. "If I hold it for 35 years without selling, doesn't the price along the way not matter?" It's right, it's right — but the premise that you can hold it all the way for 35 years is itself a bet. A job transfer, interest rates, increases in the repair reserve fund, vacancies. There are any number of reasons to let go of it midway. If the balance is above the price at that point, it's a painful story.

"Does only the bank make money?" is half right too. In the example earlier, about ¥4.48 million in interest goes to the bank over 10 years. The bank has a hold on both the collateral and your salary, so it's hard for it to get into trouble even if the unit's price falls. The one who gets into trouble is the borrower. Honestly, that part is asymmetric.

"If it's for tax savings, an investment trust is fine" is comparing the wrong things. Tax savings in real estate is a mechanism where you create a loss on paper through things like depreciation and get back some of the tax charged on your salary. If what's inside the loss is real out-of-pocket money, only part of it comes back. Your sense that it's not a product you choose for tax savings is right, I think. Right?

One table is enough to check. Work out the loan balance after 10 years and after 20 years, and put them next to the asking prices of similar units in the same area that are right now 10 and 20 years old. If the price is above the balance, the profit isn't zero, it's piling up. If it's below, it looks like zero but is actually being shaved away. OK?

You know oysters in the shell — you pay for the weight including the shell, but you only eat what's inside. Don't check the weight of the shell, check how full the meat is before you buy. Oyster season has started, so it's just the right season for comparing. See ya.

(Updated 2026.10.15)
Jamie GooInvestor in training

Hey, it's Jamie! I bought my current unit because it was "No. 1 in the yield ranking" on an online property site! No. 1, I tell you, No. 1! At the time I felt like I'd won a gold medal.

What started it was exactly the same as this question. I was recommended a new studio unit and thought, "If all that's left after paying for 35 years is a 35-year-old unit, why not just buy an old unit cheap from the start!" It seemed like a really clever reverse idea.

So I sorted the property site by highest yield, and at the very top was a 38-year-old studio unit. Price ¥4.8 million, rent ¥50,000, gross yield 12.5%. More than double the number I'd heard in the pitch for the new unit! I barely did a viewing before applying.

Then, 1 year later. The tenant moved out, and the rent for the next listing, by the real estate agent's estimate, was ¥40,000. It seems the previous person had lived there a long time and their rent had stayed higher than the current market. On top of that, at the owners' association general meeting, the repair reserve fund went up from ¥7,000 a month to ¥16,000. It's an old building, so there are lots of places to fix. Well, of course!

I recalculated. At first, rent was ¥600,000 a year, the management fee of ¥9,000 and reserve fund of ¥7,000 came to ¥192,000 a year, and taking fixed asset tax as ¥30,000 a year, what's left is ¥378,000 a year. About 7.9% against ¥4.8 million. When that becomes rent of ¥480,000, ¥300,000 a year for the management fee and reserve fund, and ¥30,000 in tax, what's left is ¥150,000 a year, about 3.1%. The No. 1 at 12.5% was No. 1 in a list sorted by the number before expenses.

That's when I realized. What someone who holds a new unit for 35 years gets at the end is exactly the kind of unit I have now. Units over 35 years old tend to see rents fall and repair costs rise. Whether there's a real benefit becomes pretty visible if you look into the rent and expenses of that "final unit" using old units that exist today. I'd just done it in the reverse order and bought the final unit first!

There are 3 things I'd like to tell myself back then.

  • Look at what number the ranking is sorted by. If it's gross yield, subtract expenses and recalculate
  • Get the long-term repair plan and see when, and by how much, the repair reserve fund is scheduled to rise
  • Compare the current rent with the listing rents of nearby units of the same size

I told this story to the person who recommended the new unit. They said, "Well then, you're all prepared for 35 years from now," and when I shot back, "Prepared? I'm living it!" they just went on to the next page with "Now, about the brochure for this new unit"!

(Updated 2026.10.15)

Read a little deeper